
...

By Jesus Mesa
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Tucker Carlson recently claimed that the Ukrainian military is selling a significant portion of the weapons it receives from the United States, even suggesting that some have ended up in the hands of Mexican cartels.
In the latest episode of "The Tucker Carlson Show" on X, the conservative commentator asserted that "up to half" of U.S. weapons sent to Ukraine are being sold on the black market and went further to suggest that "the CIA is profiting off of it."
A vocal critic of U.S. support for Ukraine's defense against Russia's unprovoked invasion, Carlson provided no evidence to support his claim. Expressing disbelief, he remarked, "Everything about this [war] is a lie," and reacted with alarm to his own allegations, stating, "They're selling weapons to drug cartels? Are you kidding? This is a nightmare."
Read More on World
The Claim
Carlson's assertion was made as part of a conversation with retired U.S. Lt. Col. Daniel Davis. He insisted that his claim was not speculative, stating, "I know this for a fact. A fact, OK? Not speculation."
"They're selling it, and a lot of it ends up with the drug cartels on our border," Carlson said. "This is a crime. Our intelligence agencies are fully aware of it. Do you really think they're not profiting from this? Of course, they are. You think the CIA isn't involved? Yes, they are. I can't prove it, but I believe it. Are we supposed to believe they don't know? I know, but they don't? They know. And no one is talking about it."
He further alleged that the New York Times could "get on the web to order Ukrainian weapons" but again did not provide any direct evidence of where or how those weapons were allegedly being sold.
The Facts
Claims that NATO weapons and ammunition are being put on sale on the dark web have re-surfaced in recent months, but as other outlets have reported, there is no evidence that any such products have actually made it into the hands of a prospective buyer.
A Newsweek analysis of similar claims made in 2022, the year the war began, reveals a coordinated effort by Russian disinformation networks to spread false narratives about Ukraine's handling of Western-supplied weapons.
This effort has included fabricated dark web ads, with pro-Russian outlets circulating images of a supposed Javelin anti-tank weapon for sale online. However, the listing was traced back to pro-Russian Telegram channels, and the images themselves dated to 2014— preceding both the war and the current levels of U.S. military support.

...
Russian state media amplified these claims, with RT running an "investigation" into alleged Western arms sales, despite fact-checkers, including the BBC World Service Disinformation Team, debunking the evidence. In another instance, Russian media misrepresented official oversight measures as proof of illicit activity.
U.S. and Ukrainian officials have implemented strict auditing measures to track military aid. Keith Kellogg, a former national security advisor under the Trump administration, said that "inspector generals are on the ground in Ukraine" monitoring weapons transfers and financial aid to ensure accountability.
Reports from Ukraine Oversight, a U.S. government website tracking military assistance, indicate that while some weapons have gone missing in combat zones, there is no evidence of significant black market sales at the level Carlson suggests.
When the European Commission and the U.S. State Department introduced new protocols in October 2022 to monitor Western-supplied arms, Russian outlets distorted the initiative to suggest it was a response to widespread weapons trafficking. A June 2024 Harvard study acknowledged it was "highly likely that some weapons will go missing over the course of the conflict" but noted the difficulty in proving the extent of illicit sales.

...
Harvard also debunked claims that Ukrainian arms were being sold to "Finnish gangsters, French rioters, Nigerian fighters, and Mexican cartels," citing a report from the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime.
Additionally, an analysis from the Kyiv Post dismantled Carlson's claim by examining the types of weapons sent to Ukraine and their likelihood of reaching Mexican cartels. Most military aid in 2024 consisted of artillery systems, Bradley infantry fighting vehicles, and advanced missile systems (HIMARS and ATACMS)—none of which are practical for cartel use.
There have been no reports of Mexican criminal organizations deploying heavy U.S. artillery systems.
The Ruling

...
False. Despite Carlson's assertion that his claim is based on fact, not speculation, neither he nor any independent sources have provided evidence to support the allegations of widespread Ukrainian arms sales. Reports from the Kyiv Post, United24 Media, and U.S. oversight bodies all indicate that weapons transfers are being closely monitored and that accusations of mass-scale black market sales are part of a Russian disinformation campaign.
FACT CHECK BY NEWSWEEK
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines