
...

By Robert Alexander
Senior Crime & Court Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A federal district court has ruled that the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) acted unlawfully when it directed federal agencies to terminate more than 25,000 probationary employees at the start of 2025.
The decision, issued by Judge William Alsup of the Northern District of California, September 12, 2025, concluded that the OPM exceeded its statutory authority by ordering removals and requiring agencies to use pre-drafted termination letters citing performance as the reason, even though performance was not the true basis for the separations.
Newsweek contacted the OPM and the Department of Justice for comment via email outside of normal office hours on Tuesday.
Read More on U.S.
Why It Matters
The ruling draws a clear boundary around executive authority and protects the neutrality of the federal civil service.
By finding that the OPM overstepped when it ordered agencies to fire more the probationary employees under false pretenses, the court reinforced that only individual agencies—not OPM—have the power to make personnel decisions.
The decision safeguards employees' reputations by requiring corrections to personnel records and ensures that future administrations cannot bypass statutory protections to carry out purges of the workforce.

...
What To Know
Background To The Ruling
The controversy traces back to a January 20, 2025, memo from Acting OPM Director Charles Ezell that instructed agencies to list all probationary employees within four days, update those lists daily, and then justify any decision to keep them.
OPM created an exemptions process that prioritized "mission critical" roles, while providing agencies with a template termination letter citing "performance" as the reason for dismissal—even though performance was not the true basis for the decisions.
Although the memo stated that agencies had discretion, the court later found OPM effectively dictated outcomes, turning an advisory guidance into a binding government-wide mandate.
That directive became the center of the lawsuit, with Judge Alsup ruling it exceeded OPM's authority and violated federal law. Federal agencies ultimately terminated 25,406 probationary employees in less than a month.
Plaintiffs—including the American Federation of Government Employees (AFGE), other labor unions, and the State of Washington—challenged the directive, arguing that OPM's actions violated the Administrative Procedure Act, and undermined statutory protections for federal workers.
In earlier phases of the litigation, the district court issued provisional reinstatement orders at several agencies, but those orders were stayed by the Supreme Court while the case proceeded.
By the time of the final ruling, Judge Alsup determined reinstatement was impractical due to the passage of time and organizational changes. Instead, the court issued permanent injunctive relief, which permanently or indefinitely requires a party to refrain from a specific act.
Under the ruling, OPM is barred from directing other agencies to terminate probationary employees and from distributing pretextual termination templates.
Agencies must correct personnel records to remove inaccurate references to performance-based dismissals, notify affected employees of those corrections, and certify compliance to the court.
The government argued during litigation that OPM was merely issuing guidance, not mandating terminations, saying: "The government disagrees but does not persuade. It contends that OPM did not direct other agencies employment decisions: '[A]ll it did was give agencies guidance'. And, in response to that guidance, each agency exercised its independent judgment."
The court rejected that characterization, citing evidence that agencies understood OPM's instructions as binding and that OPM retained discretion over exemptions: "Agencies were required to send daily updates to OPM showing which probationary employees had been terminated and to justify any decision to retain an employee. OPM retained the discretion to grant or deny exemptions, and in practice it exercised that discretion across multiple agencies," the court found.
Broader Implications For Employees
The decision underscores limits on OPM's authority. Federal law allows the agency to recommend personnel policies, and, in certain cases, direct separations tied to suitability investigations.
Judge Alsup emphasized, however, that OPM does not have the power to order government-wide mass firings. "Congress intended agencies themselves—not OPM—to hold authority over hiring and firing decisions," the ruling stated.
The ruling's broader implications extend to the balance between executive authority and civil service protections.
For affected employees, the decision ensures that their personnel records will not reflect false performance-related dismissals, even though reinstatement is not forthcoming.
What People Are Saying
Everett Kelley, National President American Federation of Government Employees, in a statement emailed to Newsweek, September 15, 2025, said: "This is another significant victory for federal employees and for all Americans. Judge Alsup's decision makes clear that thousands of probationary workers were wrongfully fired, exposes the sham record the government relied upon, and requires the government to tell the wrongly terminated employees that OPM's reasoning for firing them was false."
Andrew Feldman, Founder & Principal, Feldman Strategies LLC in an email to Newsweek the same day, said: "The ruling marks a major legal victory for AFGE and the thousands of probationary workers whose lives and families were completely upended by this illegal act—especially given that the Supreme Court allowed the administration to continue its purge for months while the case proceeded."
What Happens Next
Federal agencies must now correct the personnel records of more than 25,000 terminated probationary employees, notify them of the changes, and certify compliance to the court, while OPM is permanently barred from ordering mass firings or issuing pretextual termination letters.
The Justice Department is expected to appeal, with the case potentially reaching the Supreme Court, and the ruling itself sets a precedent that future administrations cannot bypass established civil service rules to carry out government-wide purges.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines