10

Loading video...

Nick Mordowanec

By Nick Mordowanec

Staff Writer

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch has criticized his fellow colleagues for not taking up a case involving Florida jury sizes related to felony charges.

Florida, along with Arizona, Connecticut, Indiana, Massachusetts and Utah, does not require 12-person juries to deliberate criminal cases and can rule with six- or eight-member juries. Florida is unique in that all non-death penalty-related cases only require six-member juries.

"For almost all of this Nation's history and centuries before that, the right to trial by jury for serious criminal offenses meant the right to a trial before 12 members of the community," Gorsuch, who was appointed by former President Donald Trump, wrote in his lone dissent published on Tuesday.

Read More on U.S.

Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch looks on as Senate Judiciary chairman Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-IA) speaks to reporters before their meeting on Capitol Hill, February 1, 2017 in Washington, DC. Gorsuch in a new order dissented against his colleagues, saying Florida should have juries with more than six members.

...

His dissent stems from the case Cunningham v. Florida, in which Natoya Cunningham was criminally charged out of Palm Beach County for aggravated battery and retaliation against a witness or informant. Cunningham reportedly stabbed an informant in the arm.

She was later convicted by a six-person jury and sentenced to eight years in prison.

Cunningham approached the Supreme Court to overrule its own standing in the 1970 case Williams v. Florida, where it held that "six-person juries were constitutionally permissible" and that the Supreme Court "has not revisited its express holding in Williams."

An argument she forged was that the Court's 2020 decision in Ramos v. Louisiana, claiming that the Sixth Amendment's right to "trial by an impartial jury" includes the rights that the term meant when the amendment was originally adopted. And that means a twelve-person jury in criminal cases, according to SCOTUS Blog.

The Supreme Court in that case banned the use of non-unanimous juries for felonies that had been common practice in Louisiana and Oregon, according to CNN.

Another case in 2022, Guzman v. Florida, involved Jose Guzman appealing his convictions and life sentences for three counts of sexual battery on a child under 12 years old and three counts of lewd or lascivious molestation on a child under 12 years old.

The defendant argued based on the premise in the Ramos case, that being convicted by a six-person jury violated the Sixth and Fourteenth Amendments.

But Florida Attorney General Ashley Moody, in a brief opposing the Supreme Court from taking on the Cunningham case, argued that Florida has used six-member juries dating back to 1877 and should continue to be allowed to do so.

"For nearly as long as states have had a Sixth Amendment duty to provide criminal jury trials, this Court's message to the people of Florida has been clear: the jury structure that they have settled on for a century and a half fulfills that duty," Moody's brief states. "Unsurprisingly then, Florida has continued its long-standing practice of using six-person juries in trials of noncapital offenses."

Florida currently has approximately 5,000 criminal convictions currently pending on direct appeal, Moody added.

Newsweek reached out to Moody's office and Governor Ron DeSantis' office via email for comment.

Justices reportedly denied review of Cunningham's case after considering it during six consecutive conferences.

Gorsuch called the Williams ruling "a revolutionary decision," saying: "Florida does what the Constitution forbids because of us."

"Williams made the unthinkable a reality," he wrote. "In doing so, it substituted bad social science for careful attention to the Constitution's original meaning."

Justice Gorsuch said the Court should have granted Cunningham's request to review her case and the Williams decision as a whole, arguing that in the years since that decision the Court's "cases have insisted, repeatedly, that the right to trial by jury should mean no less today, and afford no fewer protections for individual liberty, than it did at the Nation's founding."

"If there are not yet four votes on this Court to take up the question whether Williams should be overruled, I can only hope someday there will be," Gorsuch wrote.

"In the meantime, nothing prevents the people of Florida and other affected States from revising their jury practices to ensure no government in this country may send a person to prison without the unanimous assent of 12 of his peers. If we will not presently shoulder the burden of correcting our own mistake, they have the power to do so."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines