U.S. Sen. Amy Klobuchar

...

Shane Croucher

By Shane Croucher

Senior Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Senate Democrats accused their Republican colleagues of rewarding waste in government spending with a proposal that would delay Supplemental Nutritional Assistance Program (SNAP) cuts for at least a year for states with high error rates.

Senator Amy Klobuchar, a Democrat from Minnesota, said she will force a vote on the proposal for food stamps, which offers up to a two-year delay to the cuts in what she called the "most absurd example of the hypocrisy of the Republican bill".

The Senate is voting on President Donald Trump's One Big Beautiful Bill, the centerpiece of his domestic agenda that brings together swathes of tax cuts and more money for priorities such as border security, deportations and the Golden Dome project.

Read More on Politics

The federal Food and Nutrition Service tracks state error rates in SNAP payments, measuring the accuracy of their eligibility and benefit determinations. Payment errors include either overpayments or underpayments.

"If they keep it high for another year, they get another [year] of delay. Insanity reigns. Rewarding errors," Klobuchar posted to X, formerly Twitter, amid the Senate vote-a-rama.

The issue centers on a contentious exemption for Alaska from a SNAP work requirement in the bill. Klobuchar said the proposal to extend up to a two-year delay to all states with high error rates is intended by Republicans to "bury their help for Alaska" in the bill.

The exemption and other provisions for the state were secured by Alaska's Republican Senator Lisa Murkowski, a holdout who has not yet signaled if she will support the final package. Trump has set a July 4 deadline for the bill to hit his desk for signature.

Newsweek has contacted Republican Senate Majority Leader John Thune's office for comment via email outside of normal business hours.

U.S. Sen. Amy Klobuchar

...

SNAP Work Requirements

The package includes new 80-hour-a-month work requirements for many adults, aged 19 to 64, receiving Medicaid and SNAP. Parents of children 14 and older would have to meet the program's work requirements.

The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates that 3 million more Americans would not qualify for food stamps if the bill becomes law.

But Republican backers of the cuts argue that Americans who are able to work but don't should not receive support through SNAP and Medicaid, a medical assistance program for low-income Americans.

"The fact of the matter is we are focusing on making sure that the able-bodied American goes to work. That's good news, not bad news," Senator Tim Scott, a South Carolina Republican, told Fox Business.

Republicans say they are trying to rightsize the safety net programs for the population they were initially designed to serve, mainly pregnant women, the disabled and children, and root out what they describe as waste, fraud and abuse.

"Under our plan, we will cut taxes for working and middle class Americans, provide funding to keep the border secured, and protect Medicaid for Americans who need it," the Senate Republicans account posted to X.

Other Democrats commented on the SNAP cuts delay proposal. "So the states that waste the MOST money get no cuts," Senator Chris Murphy, a Connecticut Democrat, posted to X. "Up is down."

Senator Brian Schatz, a Hawaii Democrat and chief deputy whip, said the proposal "is exactly why bills that are done in a rush with no hearings at all are always a mess."

"GOOD NEWS IF YOUR STATE HAS A HIGH ERROR RATE FOR SNAP YOU DONT GET SNAP CUTS FOR A YEAR AND IF YOU KEEP YOUR ERROR RATE HIGH YOU GET ANOTHER YEAR WE ARE CUTTING WASTE FRAUD AND ABUUUUUUUUUSE," Schatz posted to X.

Trump Tax Cuts

The cuts to food assistance and Medicaid in the bill are designed to partly offset the tax cuts and new spending on Trump's domestic priorities.

Republicans say the bill is crucial because there would be a massive tax increase after December when tax breaks from Trump's first term expire. The legislation contains about $4.5 trillion in tax cuts.

The existing tax rates and brackets would become permanent under the bill.

It temporarily would add new tax breaks that Trump campaigned on: No taxes on tips, overtime pay, the ability to deduct interest payments for some automotive loans, along with a $6,000 deduction for older adults who earn no more than $75,000 a year.

It would boost the $2,000 child tax credit to $2,200. Millions of families at lower income levels would not get the full credit.

A cap on state and local deductions, called SALT, would quadruple to $40,000 for five years. It's a provision important to New York and other high-tax states, though the House wanted it to last for 10 years.

There are scores of business-related tax cuts, including allowing businesses to immediately write off 100 percent of the cost of equipment and research.

The wealthiest households would see a $12,000 increase from the legislation, which would cost the poorest people $1,600 a year, according to the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office analysis of the House's version.

Middle-income taxpayers would see a tax break of $500 to $1,500, the CBO said.

Trump Spending Priorities

The bill would provide some $350 billion for Trump's border and national security agenda, including $46 billion for the U.S.-Mexico border wall and $45 billion for 100,000 migrant detention facility beds, as he aims to fulfill his promise of the largest mass deportation operation in U.S. history.

Money would go for hiring 10,000 new Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers, with $10,000 signing bonuses and a surge of Border Patrol officers, as well. The goal is to deport some 1 million people per year.

The Homeland Security secretary would have a new $10 billion fund for grants for states that help with federal immigration enforcement and deportation actions.

To help pay for it, immigrants would face various new fees, including when seeking asylum protections.

For the Pentagon, the bill would provide billions for shipbuilding, munitions systems, and quality-of-life measures for servicemen and women, as well as $25 billion for the development of the Golden Dome missile defense system.

The Defense Department would have $1 billion for border security.

Medicaid, SNAP Cuts

To help partly offset the lost tax revenue and new spending, Republicans aim to cut back on Medicaid and food assistance for the poor.

In addition to the work requirements for SNAP and Medicaid, there's also a proposed new $35 co-payment that can be charged to patients using Medicaid services.

More than 71 million people rely on Medicaid, which expanded under former President Barack Obama's Affordable Care Act, and 40 million use SNAP. Most already work, according to analysts.

The CBO estimates that 11.8 million more Americans would become uninsured by 2034 if the bill became law.

The Senate proposes a $25 billion Rural Hospital Transformation Program to help offset reduced Medicaid dollars.

It's a new addition, intended to win over holdout GOP senators and a coalition of House Republicans warning that the proposed Medicaid provider tax cuts would hurt rural hospitals.

This article includes reporting by The Associated Press.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines