Jeremy Corbyn Needs to Take a Long Hard Look at How Anti-Semitism Has Grown in Britain's Labour Party

This article originally appeared on

I don't know Jeremy Corbyn well enough to know whether he goes very big on soul-searching. But he should be searching deep right now and asking himself how, under his leadership of the U.K. Labour Party, the charge of anti-Semitism has even been allowed to get off the ground.

A day or so before the 'Enough Is Enough' protest outside British Parliament on Monday, I was called by a prominent member of the Jewish community, almost in tears, asking, "How on Earth has it come to this?"

When I first arrived in London in my early 20s and moved in with my partner Fiona at her parents' home, a highly active Labour household, Jewish Labour members were a big part of the scene. Ian Mikardo, the son of Jewish refugees who had become a member of Parliament (MP), was a regular. Jews rich and poor were among Labour activists. True, many wealthier members of the Jewish community may have been likelier to put their money behind Margaret Thatcher's Tories, but that too changed over time.

The leader of Britain’s opposition Labour Party, Jeremy Corbyn, speaks at the official launch of Labour’s local election campaign in Manchester, U.K., on March 22. Corbyn is facing a protest over anti-Semitism in the ranks of the Labour Party. REUTERS/Phil Noble

When we first coined the slogan now used by Corbyn—'For the many, not the few'—it was saying that we stood up for those who were poor and struggling, and for the majority of hardworking people trying to do the best for themselves and their families.

But it wasn't just about the poor. We were proud that people who had done well for themselves and wanted to support our plans for social justice saw themselves as part of the Labour 'many' too—and they helped us to win three elections in a row, including in places Labour had never dared to dream of winning in the past. Some of the very Jewish areas of Thatcher's old stomping ground in North London come to mind.

Even accepting that people at protests might go a bit over the top with their messages on posters, to those who worked so hard to win over the Jewish community to Labour's cause, it was heartbreaking, and horrifying, to see that new Labour and Corbyn Labour slogan bastardized as 'For the many, not the Jew.' How on Earth has it come to this indeed?

It has come to this because it has been allowed to come to this. Because the early signs were not spotted, and when they were, by others, they were not taken seriously. And even when it looked like they were being taken seriously—with inquiries, and former London Mayor Ken Livingstone's suspension from the Labour Party—the underlying issue was not fully addressed.

David Miliband, another son of Jewish refugees who became a Labour MP, did not mince his words on Twitter on Monday when criticizing "the veil of unctuous denials, whitewash reports and diversionary attacks" that have characterized Corbyn's handling of this.

It is not enough for Corbyn supporters and apologists to say this is all a smear, that there is anti-Semitism in all parties, that he has fought all his life against racial and religious discrimination, etc. You hear too many stories of anti-Jewish remarks at meetings, of people deliberately mixing up the issue of the Jewish faith and Israel, of jibes about Jews and money, which is why the controversy over the anti-Semitic mural initially defended by Corbyn became the Jewish community's tipping point into protest and activism outside Parliament.

Protesters hold placards and flags during a demonstration, organized by the Board of Deputies for British Jews, the Jewish Leadership Council and those who oppose anti-Semitism, in Parliament Square in London, on March 26. REUTERS/Henry Nicholls

A lot of the anti-Jewish talk, coded and otherwise, comes from the new supporters, and the old hard Left brought into the party by Corbyn's appeal. He may not have turned on the tap himself, but he has to take responsibility for turning it off. And actions will have to speak louder than his words.

The flurry of statements from Corbyn and his team suggests the protest has at least caught their attention. He is usually the one on the protest, not the object of protest, and he clearly doesn't much like the feeling. Even so, you could feel the reluctance as the words were dragged out of them day by day to say a little more of the kind of thing they don't really like to say, like, We may have got this wrong. It all felt, frankly, a bit weaselly.

Coincidentally, I have been reading a remarkable book, Holocaust by Laurence Rees. We all think we know the Holocaust story. In general terms, we do. Hitler. Six million Jews. Gas chambers. But it is only when you get into the real, horrific detail, meticulously researched, that you see the full enormity, and why we should all be reminded of the Holocaust story at regular intervals in our lives, so that those all too often hollow words—'It must never happen again'—actually mean something.

More revealing than the horrors we all know are the signs that were ignored and tolerated, the experiments that were allowed to go without challenge, the attitudes that were allowed to fester and then turn into violence and hate, leading to an at first slow but steady, then breathtakingly rapid descent into utter barbarism, and not just by the Germans.

Protesters gather to demonstrate in Parliament Square against anti-Semitism, in London, on March 26. The Board of Deputies of British Jews and the Jewish Leadership Council have drawn up a letter accusing Labour Leader Jeremy Corbyn of failing to address anti-Semitism in his party. Corbyn has today apologized to Jewish groups for 'pockets of anti-Semitism' in Labour. Jack Taylor/Getty Images

With nationalist authoritarians now in the White House and in the Kremlin, the world still recovering from an economic crash, hatred of minorities and immigrants growing in too many parts of the world, and displacement on the rise, there are too many parallels with the 1930s in our world already.

I am not remotely comparing what is happening in Labour now to what happened in Germany back then. But I am saying that, given the history of anti-Semitism, and where it ended, there can be no tolerance of it at all, at any level, ever, by anyone. And don't let anyone pretend it is not possible to separate out Israel's government from Jews around the world, because it is.

The reason my Jewish friend was in agony when he called was because of split loyalty. His loyalty to Labour made him reluctant to attend a protest in large part directed at the party he has always supported. His loyalty to the Jewish community made him feel he should be there.

So soul-searching is definitely required. But if we look at the Corbyn response to another issue recently, the poisoning of a former Russian spy on British soil, you see something of a trend that suggests maybe he doesn't do the soul-searching stuff. He uses events happening today to justify his stance on events in the past.

In one of the most bizarre pieces of 'whataboutery' of recent times, Prime Minister Theresa May identifying Russia as the likeliest perpetrator of the attack was used to remind people Corbyn had been 'right about Iraq.' So he and the posh-boy revolutionaries in his ear, like Andrew Murray and Seamus Milne, don't want to say anything that suggests they may have been wrong about Russia, wrong about Israel, wrong about New Labour, wrong about anything.

I look forward to their supporters asking me to do some soul-searching on Iraq, pretty much their answer on anything I might say by way of comment on their leadership. But on this question of anti-Semitism in the party, and how we got from where we were to where we are, there is something very wrong indeed. Corbyn needs to see it, say it, sort it. Because at a time so many people feel he is badly letting down the Labour Party and the country on Brexit, he has already let us down in allowing the anti-Semitism charge—not just to get off the ground, but to fly so high.

Alastair Campbell is a British strategist and writer best known for his work as director of communications and strategy for U.K. Prime Minister Tony Blair between 1994 and 2003. He is the author of 12 books, the latest of which is Outside Inside, his diaries from 2003 to 2005. He is ambassador for the mental health campaign Time to Change.