James Zimmermann/X
By Marni Rose McFall
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The Knoxville Symphony Orchestra and its CEO have come under scrutiny after clarinet player James Zimmermann filed a lawsuit alleging they refused to hire him over Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI).
Speaking to Newsweek, Zimmermann said, "I'm filing the lawsuit not only for financial compensation for the 100 hours I spent preparing for the audition and a year's salary I should have had the chance to earn, but more than that I'm suing to send a message to orchestra CEOs that they cannot keep getting away with refusing to employ the most merited players because of DEI disagreements."
In a statement shared with Newsweek, a representative for the Knoxville Symphony Orchestra denied that their decision not to hire Zimmermann was due to his views.
Read More on News
"The KSO employs musicians and staff members of varying backgrounds and viewpoints," the representative said. "But the KSO’s decision regarding Mr. Zimmerman was never about politics or viewpoints. The KSO made the decision not to hire Mr. Zimmermann due to legitimate safety concerns as confirmed by the Nashville Symphony. Our organization maintains a duty to all of our employees that they should always feel – and remain – safe while at work."
Why It Matters
DEI initiatives are frameworks that look to promote the fair treatment of all people, but in particular, marginalized groups who have historically been subjected to discrimination.
James Zimmermann/X
These initiatives came into the political spotlight in the U.S. in 2020, following the murder of George Floyd, an event that sparked a global conversation about racism and inequality.
Following the reelection of President Donald Trump, the president rescinded numerous executive orders from the Biden era, and ordered what he termed "ending radical and wasteful government DEI programs and preferencing."
DEI initiatives have become something of a lightning rod in modern politics, with their supporters advocating for them to increase diversity, and their critics arguing that their policies are unfair to others.
What To Know
Zimmermann, who has made multiple viral social media posts about his lawsuit, alleges that he won a blind audition for the principal clarinet at the Knoxville Symphony. However, he was then contacted by the symphony’s CEO, Rachel Ford, who said that he would not get the job. Zimmerman said that this was because of his "Ousting from the Nashville Symphony six years ago for resisting DEI as the reason."
Zimmermann was fired from the Nashville Symphony in 2020. The right-leaning Washington Free Beacon wrote an extensive piece about his firing. The outlet reported that, according to his accusers, Zimmermann has insulted, intimidated, and stalked his colleagues. The outlet reported that HR complaints had been filed against him and cited an email from Zimmermann, which described a brewing "war" and the potential for "physical harm," a claim one of his colleagues described as a "cry of help."
Addressing this email in a recent post on X, Zimmermann said, "Wasn't smart of me to email this guy after getting home late from a concert, but he and his friends had been reporting made-up stories about me to management for a year trying to get me fired."
The Washington Free Beacon’s piece cited ex-colleagues of Zimmerman who suggested he had been the target of a witch hunt. It raises the question of the role of DEI and "woke" politics in the firing.
In a statement emailed to Newsweek, a representative for the Knoxville Symphony Orchestra said, "Upon hearing from the Nashville Symphony as his prior employer, the KSO decided not to move forward with offering Mr. Zimmermann a contract."
That statement continued: "During a phone call on September 18, 2025, the KSO informed Mr. Zimmermann that a number of items had come to our attention regarding his time with the Nashville Symphony. Specifically, after the KSO’s Audition Committee recommended Mr. Zimmermann for consideration as a member of this season’s orchestra, the KSO spoke to Nashville Symphony President Alan Valentine on September 17th to learn more about Mr. Zimmermann and his termination in 2020. Mr. Valentine confirmed to the KSO what he also stated to The Tennessee Star in a September 2021 article about Mr. Zimmermann’s termination: “Two different restraining orders were granted by two different judges in Davidson County against Zimmermann on behalf of two Nashville Symphony musicians…”
Zimmermann filed a lawsuit against the Knoxville Symphony Orchestra on December 23, 2025.
The complaint seeks "compensation and other appropriate relief for the Defendant’s wrongful and discriminatory refusal to hire him."
Zimmermann has shared multiple posts about the lawsuit and the Knoxville Symphony Orchestra on X, which have amassed millions of views. One of these posts includes an email from Ford, where her contact information is visible. One reply to that post, viewed over 100,000 times, reads, "Oh good her phone number and email."
Zimmermann has now been interviewed by popular conservative media personalities Megyn Kelly and Steve Bannon. A reply to one of his posts on X, viewed over 40,000 times, describes him as "MAGA hero of the week."
Harmeet Dhillon, the United States assistant attorney general for the Civil Rights Division, has also responded to the case online, writing "Rachel, we have questions," in a post on X.
What People Are Saying
James Zimmermann told Newsweek: "The online response has been tremendous, I'm very grateful the story is receiving attention from so many prominent voices like Elon Musk, Megyn Kelly, and many others. Getting beaten up by trolls is part of the game, and I've come to accept that, there's no avoiding them if I want to fight back. I'd much prefer to play my horn in peace but I'm happy to fight the good fight. Someone has to."
The Knoxville Symphony Orchestra, in a statement given to Newsweek: "The Knoxville Symphony Orchestra (KSO) is aware of the lawsuit and related public comments from James Zimmermann. While the KSO will not go into detail about a matter currently in litigation, we certainly look forward to an opportunity to defend our organization in court."
What Happens Next
"Next step is to let the legal process play out, keep talking, and keep playing my horn," Zimmermann told Newsweek. "The life of a musician is always an adventure, and while this isn't one I expected, it's one I accept with great cheer. The best thing I can do is keep playing beautifully and I don't intend to stop doing that."
Ford told Fox News Digital that they expect to make a public announcement later this week.
Update 01/07/26, 11:35 a.m. ET: This article was updated with comment from James Zimmermann.
Update 01/08/26, 09:10 a.m. ET: This article was updated with comment from the Knoxville Symphony Orchestra.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines