

By Katherine Fung and Alex Backus
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Both sides delivered closing arguments Tuesday in the criminal hush money trial against former President Donald Trump. Live updates have ended.
May 28, 2024 at 08:02 PM EDT
Jurors to return for instructions tomorrow
It's 8 p.m. in New York City. After a long, nearly 10.5 hours at the Manhattan Criminal Courthouse, the jury is being dismissed.
Judge Juan Merchan said he will read jurors instructions tomorrow, meaning deliberations will begin tomorrow. Given the late evening, court will reconvene at 10 a.m. tomorrow.
Merchan asks if anything else needs to be taken up, both sides say no. Trump appears to smack attorney Todd Blanche on the arm and whispers something. He then angrily gets up to leave.
Merchan reminds the court that once the instructions are read tomorrow, no one will be allowed in and out.
May 28, 2024 at 08:00 PM EDT
Prosecution wraps closing argument after several hours
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass thanks the jury, noting it's been a long summation and acknowledges that former President Donald Trump has the right to trial.
"He's had his day in court," he says, asking them to find Trump guilty of all 34 felony counts.
At 7:57 p.m., he finally finishes the prosecution's closing arguments.
May 28, 2024 at 07:40 PM EDT
Steinglass lists 3 reasons jurors shouldn’t believe the defense
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass lists three reasons why they should not believe the defense's arguments:
- Trump's a micromanager. Steinglass says it's "not in his nature to remain in the dark about matters that threaten to undermine his campaign."
- Michael Cohen wanted credit. He may have hid a paper trail but he would have wanted Trump to know.
- Trump was the "beneficiary" of the scheme. He "gained the most by silencing these people."
Steinglass acknowledges the lengthy closing, jokingly saying it's the "summation that never ends." Although it sounds like he's finally wrapping up. He says that no one is arguing that the former president typed the vouchers in, printed the checks, etc., but that he did "set in motion the chain of events" related to the false business records.
By contrast, Trump attorney Todd Blanche listed 10 reasons why jurors should have reasonable doubt in his closing argument, with the tenth being "Cohen is the human embodiment of reasonable doubt, literally."
Judge Juan Merchan has sustained several objections from the defense about Steinglass' comments about the charges and implementation of law. Steinglass asks to approach, Merchan denies a sidebar.
On the conspiracy that prosecutors are accusing Trump of, Steinglass says, "We're beating a dead horse here."
Steinglass pushes back on Blanche's arguments that events that took place after the election could be called into question. "The defendant was still actively trying to prevent his catch-and-kill scheme from going public," he argues.
May 28, 2024 at 07:36 PM EDT
Rep. Stefanik files official misconduct complaint against judge
Meanwhile, New York Congresswoman Elise Stefanik says she filed an official misconduct complaint against Judge Juan Merchan this evening.
"I just filed an official misconduct complaint with the New York State Unified Court System related to the "random" assignment of Acting Manhattan Justice Juan Merchan, a Biden donor whose daughter is fundraising millions off his unprecedented work, to criminal cases against President Donald J. Trump, his companies, and his allies," Stefanik wrote on X.
May 28, 2024 at 07:20 PM EDT
Proceedings will continue until 8 p.m.
After the jury stepped out for an evening recess, Trump attorney Todd Blanche objects to the argument about Stormy Daniels having to hire security after coming forward with her story.
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass argues the defense opened the door "wide enough to drive a truck through" and points to Judge Juan Merchan's earlier ruling.
Merchan says his earlier ruling was right, but tells Steinglass that after four hours, "you've gone far enough" and "you don't need to go any further" on the matter.
Merchan says the jury can work until 8 p.m., at which point Steinglass "really" needs to wrap it up. He asks that one of the other prosecutors hand Steinglass a note once we hit that 8 o'clock-mark. Merchan thanks the jury again for their flexibility.
Steinglass says to the jurors, "thanks for sticking with me" before he continues onto a slide titled: "Mr. Trump Involved Every Step of the Way." The timeline spans from the August 2015 meeting at Trump tower through April 2018. He is detailing the phone calls and emails on important dates throughout the Stormy Daniels and Karen McDougal deals.
May 28, 2024 at 06:50 PM EDT
“Cohen wasn’t playing Costello, Costello was playing Cohen”
We are nearing 7 p.m., prosecutor Joshua Steinglass asks the jury if they can go a little longer.
He shows a slide that reads: "Efforts to control witness accounts."
"Cohen knew where the bodies were buried and it was essential to keep him loyal," Steinglass says. He points out that Trump called Michael Cohen days within the FBI raid.
Steinglass notes this is when Cohen meets Costello, who offered to serve as a back channel. "Cohen never really trusted Costello and can you blame him?" he says. "He wasn't about to tell Costello the truth about the defendant's involvement."
Steinglass calls Costello's testimony about acting exclusively in Cohen's interests a "bold-faced lie."
"Cohen wasn't playing Costello, Costello was playing Cohen," he argues.
Steinglass argues that Trump's strategy worked even after he reimbursed Cohen because the former Trump fixer continued to deny wrongdoing. He calls it "disingenuous" that the defense argues Cohen shouldn't be believed for lies he told for Trump.
"It's blaming the messenger for the defendant's own message." Steinglass says that after Cohen flips, "The defendant was furious. His fixer had done the unthinkable and Trump immediately went on the attack, an attack that continues to this day."
Steinglass brings up the lawsuit Trump filed against Cohen for half a billion dollars shortly after his indictment, saying it includes Cohen's testimony to the grand jury. He argues the suit shows "the lengths [Trump] is willing to go to, to punish those that defy him."
Judge Juan Merchan sustains the defense's objection to Steinglass' argument that Trump's rhetoric is interpreted by his followers as a call to arms.
He dismisses the jury for their last recess of the day.
May 28, 2024 at 06:45 PM EDT
This case is about “cheating”
Jurors are shown a May 3, 2018 tweet from Trump that reads: "Mr. Cohen, an attorney received a monthly retainer, not from the campaign and having nothing to do with the campaign, from which he entered into, through reimbursement a private contract between two parties..."
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass asks if Trump complains to either former Trump Organization CFO Allen Weisselberg or Cohen about no legal services being rendered. "No, he just signs them, every month and he never once picks up that phone," Steinglass says.
"Despite his frugality and attention to detail, the defendant didn't ask any questions "because he already knew the answer," Steinglass argues. "The cardinal sin for Mr. Trump is overpaying for anything."
The prosecutor reads several excerpts from Trump's books that were introduced as evidence during the trial. He also presents the jury with the records chart documenting each invoice, voucher and check cut to Cohen from the Trump Organization, with dates, amounts and file numbers. It also labels each count that Trump has been charged with, totaling to 34 counts.
"New York is the business capital of the world. Whether you're a private enterprise or public enterprise, you have an obligation to keep proper books and records," Steinglass says.
"This is what this case is really about at it's core: cheating," he adds.
May 28, 2024 at 05:55 PM EDT
Steinglass: Cohen was being “reimbursed”
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass shows jurors his "favorite" email from the whole case. It's the email Michael Cohen sent to former Trump Organization controller Jeff McConney, asking, "Remind me of the monthly account?"
Steinglass argues this shows there was no retainer for Cohen to consult and that McConney/the Trump Organization had the records for how much to pay him. Steinglass argues it was "always" the plan to disguise the reimbursements as income.
"These payments have nothing to do with a retainer agreement and nothing to do with services rendered in 2017," he says. "If [Cohen] was still doing legal work, why wasn't he paid a dime for 2018?" Steinglass asks. "Because he wasn't being paid for legal work in either year! He was being reimbursed!"
Steinglass argues that Cohen used his "cool title" as attorney to the president to get him consulting clients that would go on to pay him $4 million. "He was making more money than any government job would ever pay, and don't I know that," Steinglass says to a few laughters.
Steinglass asks the jury to think about what they'd have to believe to buy the defense's arguments. He argues that Trump has repeatedly admitted to reimbursing Cohen, but that the defense cannot because it would also reveal the records were falsified.
May 28, 2024 at 05:39 PM EDT
Jurors shown two documents prosecutors call the “smoking guns”
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass is resuming his closing argument.
"Even after Mr. Trump was elected, he still had to make sure no one else found out about the conspiracy," Steinglass continues. "But here's the thing: Mr. [Michael] Cohen was still out $130,000."
"Enter the false business records," the prosecutor announces.
Steinglass argues that Trump directed Cohen to submit the faulty invoices that kicked off the falsifying of business records. He says this is how it worked at the Trump Organization "because that's how the defendant wanted it to."
"Mr. Blanche pretended that this all came from Michael Cohen, but these documents are Trump Organization documents," Steinglass says of the notes that calculated what was owed to Cohen. "It came from them!"
Steinglass argues those two documents are the "smoking guns" and that they "completely blow out of the water" the defense's claims that the payments were not reimbursements but legal fees.
"I'm almost speechless that they're still trying to make this argument," he says.
Steinglass asks the jury with all they know about Trump, would he pay twice for something? Prosecutors argue that the Trump Organization doubled reimbursement for taxes.
"But it was worth it," Steinglass says. "It was worth it to hide the truth about what this money was really for."
Steinglass points out that these payments were also reported to the IRS and that false tax filings, even if they don't result in fewer taxes being paid, is a crime. He argues this is another "unlawful means" Trump used to hide his election conspiracy.
May 28, 2024 at 05:24 PM EDT
Trump posts “BORING!” as closing arguments drag on
Court is back.
During the break, former President Donald Trump posted "BORING!" and "FILIBUSTER!" on his Truth Social. Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass has quite a bit of his closing argument left, the judge indicated court may continue until 7 or 8 p.m.
Three of Trump's children, Donald Jr., Eric, and Tiffany, are all still inside of the courtroom. Earlier this afternoon, Donald Jr. railed against prosecutors' star witness Michael Cohen.
"Michael Cohen is the embodiment of reasonable doubt," Donald Jr. wrote on X, referring to Trump attorney Todd Blanche's closing argument.
"This entire case hangs on a liar & admitted thief. He lied to his wife. He lied to every branch of congress. He lied to federal and state judges. He lied to bankers & to this very jury! You can't rely on him!!!" he wrote.
May 28, 2024 at 05:02 PM EDT
Judge: Goal to finish closing arguments today
Closing arguments have been underway for about 6.5 hours.
Judge Juan Merchan says jurors seem alert and note they've made arrangements to stay late, so we will try and push through and get all closing arguments done today.
Court is now taking a 20 minute break.
May 28, 2024 at 04:46 PM EDT
No Trump signature on Daniels’ deal but “that’s kind of the whole point”
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass shows the call record between Michael Cohen and Donald Trump half an hour before Cohen goes across the street to First Republic and funds the LLC account. He argues that Cohen is "getting the final go ahead" from Trump on this call.
Steinglass addresses Trump's signature being absent from the agreement between Daniels and Resolution Consultants LLC.
"It's true that Mr. Trump didn't sign these documents, but that's kind of the whole point," Stienglass says, to keep Trump out of it.
The prosecutor argues that the reason the Daniels payoff was in Oct. 2016 was because Trump's primary concern was the election, not his family.
Steinglass shows a flurry of calls and texts between Hope Hicks, Cohen, Daniels' attorney Keith Davidson and Trump in the lead up to the Wall Street Journal article. He says, nonetheless, Trump is "still angry" because a story comes out that "threatened his standing with female voters."
After reading Davidson's testimony about how he felt the Daniels deal maybe helped get Trump elected, Steinglass says we'll never know "if this effort to hoodwink the American people made a difference in the 2016 election, but it's not something we have to prove."
May 28, 2024 at 04:31 PM EDT
Access Hollywood tape “capable of costing” Trump the election
The proseuction is about a third of the way through its closing argument. Back from the afternoon break, prosecutor Joshua Steinglass begins with the infamous Access Hollywood tape.
Steinglass takes a jab at Trump attorney Todd Blanche's argument about how Michael Cohen was the only one who said it was a significant event. He argues this is another example about the defense trying to make this case about Cohen.
Steinglass recounts Hope Hicks' testimony about it being "so explosive it eclipsed the news of a Category 5 hurricane," and Madeline Westerhout's testimony about how the RNC considered replacing Trump as the nominee and Republicans withdrawing their endorsements.
Steinglass argues that the tape was "capable of costing him the whole election and [Trump] knew it."
He plays the clip of Trump at an Oct. 14, 2016 rally in Greensboro, North Carolina, where he said if even 10 percent of voters believed the "lies" it could "change the most important election."
Steinglass now turns to Stormy Daniels, calling the adult film star a "walking, talking reminder that the defendant was not only words." He argues that she threatened Trump's response to the Access Hollywood tape.
Steinglass disputes the defense's extortion claim about Daniels, saying that neither Daniels, her manager Gina Rodriguez nor her attorney Keith Davidson reached out to Trump or Cohen, but were focused on brokering their story to AMI.
May 28, 2024 at 03:47 PM EDT
Prosecutors continue delivering closing arguments
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass has been delivering the proseuction's closing argument for about an hour and a half. He argues both the Trump Tower doorman story and Karen McDougal story were catch-and-kills.
He is now taking aim at the defense's argument that there was manipulation of evidence on Michael Cohen's phone. "Here's a newsflash: people use their phones," he says before asking jurors, "How many times have you traded in a new phone for an old phone and you have to do a factor reset?"
Steinglass says it should be "obvious" why the defense is "so desperate" to get the jury to reject the audio recording Cohen took of Trump – "because it's nothing short of jaw-dropping."
He says it shows Trump's "cavalier willingness to hide this payoff."
"It shows he knew how much AMI paid McDougal for the deal," he says, adding that it doesn't matter if Trump would pay it in cash or not, it showed he was doing it "in a way that won't leave a paper trail."
Court is now taking an afternoon break.
May 28, 2024 at 03:04 PM EDT
Trump Tower Aug. 2015 meeting “prism” to analyze evidence
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass says the August 2015 Trump Tower meeting with Donald Trump, David Pecker and Michael Cohen is the "prism" of which jurors should analyze the evidence.
"Three rich, powerful men high up in Trump Tower trying to become even more powerful by controlling the information that might reach the voters," he says.
"The real game changer of this meeting was the catch-and-kill component, and that's the illegal part," Steinglass argues. "Because once money starts exchanging hands from the campaign... that's federal election campaign violations."
Steinglass reads a line from Trump attorney Todd Blanche's opening that said influencing an election was democracy.
"In reality, this agreement at Trump Tower was the exact opposite. It was the subversion of democracy," Steinglass says.
Steinglass addresses the defense's argument that NDAs aren't illegal and agrees that contracts are not inherently illegal, but gives the example of a contract to kill your wife, which is.
He tells jurors they may be thinking who cares if Trump slept with a porn star over a decade ago, but he argues, "It's harder to say that the American people don't have the right to decide for themselves whether they care or not."
May 28, 2024 at 03:00 PM EDT
We didn’t “pick up” Michael Cohen at the witness store
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass responds directly to Trump attorney Todd Blanche's comment that Michael Cohen was not the witness they wanted.
"We didn't choose Michael Cohen to be our witness," he says. "We didn't pick him up at the witness store. The defendant [Trump] chose Michael Cohen to be his fixer because of his willingness to lie. Eventually, Cohen came to the realization that with Mr. Trump, loyalty was not a two-way street."
Steinglass says it was clear that Robert Costello was actually a "double agent" sent to "discourage Cohen from corroborating and keep the defendant informed."
"The question is not whether you like Cohen," Steinglass tells jurors. He says it's about whether Cohen has "useful, reliable information on what went down in this case." He argues that Cohen was in the best position to know "because he was the defendant's right hand."
"This case is not about Michael Cohen. This case is about Donald Trump," Steinglass says. He says Cohen's role is to provide "context and color to the documents. Those documents tell you everything you need to know. You don't need Michael Cohen to connect the dots."
May 28, 2024 at 02:40 PM EDT
Prosecutor: The defense is “trying to have it both ways”
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass is defending the DA office's star witness, Michael Cohen. Steinglass addresses the former Trump fixer's credibility issues, acknowledging that he is a convicted felon, but pushes back on the defense's argument that he benefits from this trial.
"Anyone in Cohen's shoes would want the defendant to be held accountable," he says.
Steinglass then addresses Cohen's admission that he stole $30,000 from the Trump Organization while paying Red Finch. Steinglass makes an argument that Cohen didn't steal, saying the defense is "trying to have it both ways."
He says that if the defense wants to deny that the $420,000 was a reimbursement, then there was no theft because Cohen wasn't being paid back, it was payment for legal fees.
Steinglass admits that Cohen has difficult accepting responsibility about his tax crimes, but he was forthcoming about his other wrongdoings. He points out that the lies Cohen told to Congress in 2017 were to stay in Trump's good graces.
Steinglass says that using those lies to undermine Cohen's credibility is what some would call "hutzpah." He says of the defense's perjury claims, "to them, that is the big lie"—a nod to Trump's election fraud claims.
Steinglass says Cohen possibly got the date and time of that call wrong as there were many updates about the Daniels' deal and that the final one would not come until days later on Oct. 26, 2016. He argues that the defense is trying again to have it both ways by claiming that Cohen would say anything to get Trump convicted, while also arguing that if the jury accepts Cohen's testimony, it would not be enough.
"It's actually neither because it's wrong on both accounts."
Steinglass argues that if Cohen wanted to lie on the stand, he could have gone further. He says the defense only wants the jury to believe Cohen when the witness says things that help their case. He says Cohen was more of a fixer than an attorney.
"He got the jobs that no one wanted," he says of Cohen.
May 28, 2024 at 02:32 PM EDT
Prosecution: Stormy Daniels “is the motive”
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass accuses the defense of shaming Stormy Daniels and suggesting that her story has changed over the years.
"The defense has gone to great lengths to discredit" Daniels, he tells jurors. "There were parts of her testimony that were cringeworthy," he says, but adds they were necessary.
He says that if Daniels didn't testify about the sexual encounter, it would give the defense "more ammunition" to go after her claims. Steinglass argues that Daniels' messiness is the reason Trump tried to conceal the story from voters in 2016.
"Stormy Daniels is the motive," Steinglass says. "You can bet Mr. Trump would not pay $130,000... just because he took a photo with someone on a golf course."
May 28, 2024 at 02:16 PM EDT
Trump’s sons slam trial, Biden campaign
During the lunch break, former President Donald Trump's sons Donald Jr. and Eric slammed the trial and the Biden-Harris campaign's press conference.
"If there was ever any doubt that this was a political persecution, the fact that the Biden campaign would hold a rally outside of the courthouse during closing arguments tells you everything you needed to know. Election interference!!!" Donald Jr. wrote on X.
Eric also blasted the DA's office for lining the courtroom amid the "degradation of this city," pointing to children being shot in Times Square and women being thrown in front of trains.
"I sit here today as a son. Forget about politics for a second. I've been in that courthouse with my father almost every single day," Eric said. "The entire DA's office is lining that courtroom... they're laughing, they're giggling. This was their moment. This is how they embarrass Donald Trump. This is legal lawfare."
May 28, 2024 at 02:11 PM EDT
Prosecution begins closing argument
Court has returned from lunch. Judge Juan Merchan gives the jury the instructions about Trump attorney Todd Blanche's prison comment, saying he will be the one to decide sentencing.
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass is delivering closing arguments for the prosecution. He begins by telling jurors that in order to prove Trump's, guilt they need to show the following:
a) there were false business records
b) the false records were intended to cover up a conspiracy by unlawful means and
c) Trump was involved
Steinglass says jurors were asked to "tune out the noise," and that if they did, they "will see that the people have presented powerful evidence of the defendant's guilt."
Steinglass argues that just because there's no record of a particular conversation between Trump and Michael Cohen does not mean it did not take place. He says that Cohen had 11 numbers saved for Trump on one of his phones, and that prosecutors only knew two of those numbers.
Steinglass disputes the defense's argument that Stormy Daniels was trying to extort Trump, saying she wanted to get her story out and that she was selling her story to the press when Cohen made an offer to buy it.
He tells jurors that even if they think it's a distorted practice, "in the end, it doesn't really matter. "You don't get to commit election fraud or falsify business records because you think you've been victimized."
Steinglass points out that some of the witnesses like Trump and could have skewed the testimony to favor him. He says the ones that Trump does not like, he has attacked on social media and they have "incurred the wrath of his most fiery supporters."
May 28, 2024 at 01:03 PM EDT
Prosectors raise issue with Blanche’s prison comment
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass raises issue with Trump attorney Todd Blanche's prison comment.
Judge Juan Merchan agrees, saying Blanche, who was a prosecutor for a long time, should know it was "highly inappropriate."
"It's simply not allowed period," the judge says. "It's hard for me to imagine how that's accidental in any way."
May 28, 2024 at 12:53 PM EDT
Break
Court is now taking lunch until 2:15 p.m. The prosecution will deliver its closing argument when we return, which is expected to take between 4 and 4.5 hours.
May 28, 2024 at 12:50 PM EDT
Cohen is “literally the greatest liar of all time”
Trump attorney Todd Blanche goes through instances when prosecutors' star witness Michael Cohen lied, including to Congress.
"Michael Cohen is the GLOAT. He is literally the greatest liar of all time," Blanche says.
"This isn't a referendum on your views of President Trump. This isn't a referendum on the ballot box," Blanche says. "The verdict that you're going to reach has to do with the evidence that you heard here in this courtroom."
He adds it should be an easy and quick not guilty verdict. The defense is now finished delivering its closing argument.
May 28, 2024 at 12:37 PM EDT
Blanche lists 10 reasons why jurors should have reasonable doubt
Trump attorney Todd Blanche is now laying out 10 reasons why the jury should have reasonable doubt.
"Each one of the reasons is a repeat of what I said today, but each one makes a not guilty verdict an easy path," he explains.
1) Invoices
2) Vouchers and checks
3) No intent to defraud
4) No intent to commit or conceal (FECA, falsifying business records, tax law)
5) No illegal agreement to influence the election
6) AMI would have run Trump Tower doorman story
7) Karen McDougal did not want her story published
8) Stormy Daniels' story was already public
9) Manipulation of evidence. Blanche argues Cohen possibly tampered with the recording, asking how it can be trusted: "The answer is you can't."
10) "Cohen is the human embodiment of reasonable doubt, literally," Blanche says.
May 28, 2024 at 12:36 PM EDT
Michael Cohen is the “MVP of liars”
Trump attorney Todd Blanche is nearing the end of his closing argument, calling Michael Cohen the "MVP of liars" and a "thief."
"Michael Cohen does not take that oath seriously, period," Blanche argues. "He's literally like the MVP of liars," he says. "He lies constantly."
Blanche also addresses the Red Finch payment that Cohen admitted to pocketing.
"In fact, he's also a thief," Blanche says. "Literally, stole, on his way out the door, stole tens of thousands of dollars from the Trump Organization."
Blanche plays a clip of Cohen's "Mea Culpa" podcast where Cohen reacts to Trump's indictment, arguing that the former Trump fixer is making millions off the former president.
"He's been obsessed with President Trump for over two decades," he says, and that Cohen's love for Trump became "outright hatred."
May 28, 2024 at 12:15 PM EDT
Stormy Daniels testified to “embarrass Trump”
Trump attorney Todd Blanche asks why Stormy Daniels was called to testify if she didn't appear before the grand jury.
"They did it to try to inflame your emotions, to embarrass President Trump, that's why ladies and gentlemen," he argues. Prosecutors object, judge overrules.
Blanche continues to point out Michael Cohen's lies. "He told you he didn't want a job in the administration, another lie," he says.
"Mr. Cohen had an axe to grind because he did not appreciate what President Trump did or did not do for him after he became president of the U.S."
Blanche uses attorney Robert Costello's testimony to dispute Cohen's testimony. Costello formerly advised Cohen and was called by the defense to testify last week. Blanche points out that even as Cohen faced "the biggest crisis of his life," he told Costello that Trump did not know about the Daniels' payments.
"I don't know how many lies are enough lies," he says.
"They want you to believe that President Trump thought this was going to cost him the election, yet he never even signed the agreement," Blanche says about the Daniels deal. "What President Trump knew in 2016, you only know from one source," Blanche says in reference to Cohen.
Blanche is now going after the call between Cohen and Trump bodyguard Keith Schiller. "He told you he talked to President Trump on October 24 at 8:02 p.m. updating him about the Daniels situation. That was a lie and he got caught red handed," Blanche says.
"We all know he called Keith Schiller to talk about the fact that a 14-year-old had been harassing him for several days and forgot to block his number and Mr. Cohen wanted to fix that."
"That is perjury!" Blanche exclaims.
May 28, 2024 at 12:00 PM EDT
Blanche resumes closing argument
Court is back in session after a short morning break. Trump attorney Todd Blanche says he has about 30 minutes left of his closing argument.
Judge Juan Merchan also says he's heard from the jury, who are willing to work late today, so proceedings will go past the usual 4:30 p.m. cutoff if needed. This suggests that closing arguments may end today.
Blanche is now resuming his closing argument.
"The question for you is, was what happened with Ms. Daniels in 2016 consistent with the conspiracy—the conspiracy that the People tell you Mr. Cohen, President Trump and David Pecker entered into in 2015," Blanche resumes.
Blanche argues that what made Daniels want to go public was "a lot more than $130,000," it was Larry Flynt offering to pay Daniels' legal fees. He plays the audio of Davidson telling Cohen that Flynt told Daniels he'd give her $1M "but first you got to get out of that agreement."
Blanche argues that what happened was extortion and that it "ended very well for Ms. Daniels, financially speaking." He again reiterates that "there's nothing wrong with a non-disclosure agreement," that there's nothing illegal or sinister about it.
"There's also no evidence... except Mr. Cohen's words, that Mr. Trump knew about that agreement in 2016," he says.
"This is what they're telling you, that this is a catch-and-kill conspiracy," he continues. He argues that if that's the case, wouldn't Pecker have helped to kill the Daniels story? But instead, "Pecker says, 'No way, not going to do it.'"
Blanche argues that the Access Hollywood tape was damaging to the campaign but that it wasn't really a problem for Trump. However, "Cohen told you that he realized it was catastrophic and that he wanted to do something about it and that's what he did in respect to Ms. Daniels."
May 28, 2024 at 11:54 AM EDT
Watch: Trump’s team responds to Biden campaign
As closing arguments continued inside of the courthouse, former President Donald Trump's team responded to the Biden-Harris press conference that took place just outside of court.
"What you just heard from is a desperate and failing and pathetic campaign who knows that they are losing," Trump 2024 National Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt said. "It is a full-blown concession that this trial is a witch hunt that comes from the top."
Trump aide Jason Miller said the Biden campaign has changed its tune because "Biden's numbers are in the tank."
"So the Biden folks have finally done it, after months of saying that politics have nothing to do with this trial, they showed up and made a campaign event out of a lower Manhattan trial day for President Trump," Miller said.
May 28, 2024 at 11:43 AM EDT
“How could this issue have influenced the election?”
Trump attorney Todd Blanche says former President Donald Trump and adult film star Stormy Daniels both denied the sexual encounter, but the story was still published in 2011, "long before 2016, long before the 2015 meeting at Trump Tower."
"How could this issue have influenced the election?" he asks. "People already knew about the allegations."
Blanche argues "what really happened" is that there were people who wanted to cause damage to the situation and extort money from Trump.
Blanche says then-editor of the National Enquirer Dylan Howard's efforts to help Daniels and her manager Gina Rodriguez cut a deal is "not a conspiracy involving Mr. [David] Pecker, President Trump or Mr. [Michael] Cohen" but Howard helping them "get money."
Blanche adds that neither Rodriguez nor Howard testified so "a lot of what we're saying is speculation."
May 28, 2024 at 11:12 AM EDT
Karen McDougal deal was “not a catch-and-kill”
Trump attorney Todd Blanche moves to the story with former Playboy model Karen McDougal.
"This was not a catch-and-kill either," he tells the jury. "Ms. McDougal didn't want her story published, she wanted to kick start her career."
Blanche argues that there was an "entourage" around McDougal that wanted to be compensated, including attorney Keith Davidson and manager Gina Rodriguez. He says what McDougal ended up with "was not much" but that it "didn't seem to bother her because it did not motivate her."
Blanche argues that if the McDougal story tells the jury anything, "it's that Mr. Cohen is a liar."
He points to discrepancies between Cohen's and Pecker's testimony, e.g. Pecker testifying that Trump never bought stories and Cohen testifying Trump agreed to "take care" of it.
Blanche argues that if the McDougal story tells the jury anything, "it's that Mr. Cohen is a liar."
He points to discrepancies between Cohen's and Pecker's testimony, e.g. Pecker testifying that Trump never bought stories and Cohen testifying Trump agreed to "take care" of it.
Blanche argues that when Cohen is able to remember key conversations from 2016 with clarity, "you gotta check that..
"Is there something about those conversations that ring true?" he asks.
Blanche questions why Cohen recorded the conversation with Trump to show Pecker if he never ended up showing the publisher. He also asks how Pecker could have calmed down to the point of not needing the recording, just days after the "very angry lunch" with Cohen.
Blanche says there's "no doubt" that the recording discussed AMI and Pecker, but "there's a lot of doubt it discussed Karen McDougal."
Blanche says the "thing that mattered about Mr. Cohen's testimony" about the recording is that phone records show Cohen never answered that incoming call, even though he testified he took the call.
"Listen, he lied to you when he said he answered that call," Blanche says.
May 28, 2024 at 11:03 AM EDT
Blanche: “Makes no sense” that National Enquirer could criminally influence an election
The defense has been delivering closing arguments for over one hour. Trump attorney Todd Blanche is now arguing against the National Enquirer's ability to influence an election.
"It doesn't matter if there was a conspiracy to try to win an election, every campaign in this country is a conspiracy," Blanche argues, saying every campaign involves a group of people helping one candidate win.
Blanche highlights the jury would need to find conspiracy by "unlawful means," but that American Media Inc.'s (AMI), publisher of National Enqurier, actions were "standard operating procedure."
"Is it surprising that campaigns want to amplify the good things about their candidate and expose the bad things about their opponents? You have decades, decades of AMI doing the same thing" with other celebrities and politicians, Blanche argues. "There's zero criminal intent in that 2015 meeting."
"Indeed, Mr. [David] Pecker told you it was really good business to work with President Trump," he says.
"The idea that the National Enquirer could corruptly, criminally influence an election by republishing other stories that were already out there... should hopefully make you shake your head," Blanche says. "It makes no sense."
Blanche argues there's "nothing unusual" about catch-and-kills, noting that AMI only published half the stories they bought.
He says Pecker was "speaking from experience," so when he said he had never heard of catch-and-kill until this investigation, "that's meaningful."
Blanche argues that there was no conspiratorial agreement between the three men because if so, why would Pecker want to publish the doorman story, pending its veracity. He points to this being an example of an opportunity to stifle a negative story about Trump.
May 28, 2024 at 10:48 AM EDT
Biden-Harris campaign: “We’re not here today” because of the trial
The Biden-Harris campaign is holding a press conference outside of the Manhattan Criminal Courthouse where closing arguments are underway. But a spokesperson begins by saying the campaign is not "here today" because of the hush money trial.
"Let me say this first and foremost: we are not here today because of what's going on over there," the spokesperson said, referring to the trial. "We're here today because you are all here. We're here, primarily, because of the threat Donald Trump poses to the United States of America."
Robert De Niro clashed with Trump supporters during the chaotic press conference. The actor began delivering remarks, saying "it's really crazy," seeming to suggest supporters should not protest and that Trump wants to "sow total chaos." People are heard screaming "f*** you" as the actor continued speaking.
"If Trump returns to the White House, you can kiss these freedoms goodbye, that we all take for granted," De Niro said. "If he gets in... he will never leave."
Read more from Newsweek's Gabe Whisnant here.
May 28, 2024 at 10:30 AM EDT
Outside of court: Biden-Harris campaign hold press conference
The Biden-Harris team is set to hold a press conference outside of the Manhattan Criminal Courthouse while closing arguments continue. The campaign said it would deliver remarks at 10:15 a.m. with "special guests." One of those appears to be actor Robert De Niro.
Trump aide Jason Miller said the former president's allies will respond to "Crooked Joe Biden's minions" immediately following their campaign event outside the courthouse at 10:30 a.m.
"Joe's crookeds aren't in PA, MI, WI, NV, AZ or GA - they're outside the Biden Trial against President Trump. It's always been about politics," Miller wrote on X.
Former President Donald Trump's eldest son Donald Jr., who is sitting inside of the courtroom right now, slammed the press conference, saying it's further evidence of election interference.
"In case you needed more evidence that all of these BS cases were quarterbacked by Team Biden to interfere in the 2024 election, the Biden campaign is now showing up in NYC to explicitly cheerlead the political prosecution of my father," Donald Jr. wrote on X.
May 28, 2024 at 10:23 AM EDT
Blanche pokes holes in Michael Cohen’s testimony
Trump attorney Todd Blanche is continuing to poke holes in Michael Cohen's testimony.
"Do you believe that for a second... that after getting stiffed on his bonus in 2016, when he thought he had worked so hard... do you think that Mr. Cohen thought, 'I'm going to work for free'?" Blanche asks jurors.
"The idea that President Trump would agree to pay Mr. Cohen $420,000, even though he only owed him $130,000, is absurd," Blanche says.
He calls Cohen's account of the agreement with former Trump Organization CFO Allen Weisselberg and Trump "a ridiculous story" given Trump's well-known frugality.
"What proof do you have, what actual evidence do you have that this 'gross up' had anything to do with taxes?" Blanche asks about Cohen's testimony explaining that his reimbursement was doubled up because he was in the 50% tax bracket.
Blanche asks why McConney would not destroy the notes where Weisselberg calculated Cohen's montly payments if they were evidence of a crime.
"For all those reasons, you don't have to go further: President Trump is not guilty," he says.
Blanche goes into the "intent to defraud" which he says means "a conscious objective, a purpose to defraud" in making these false filings. "There is no evidence of that ladies and gentlemen," he argues.
"How can there be an intent to defraud... when [Trump] disclosed it to the IRS, he tweets about it and he submits it on his office of government ethics forms?" Blanche asks.
May 28, 2024 at 10:03 AM EDT
Defense shows jurors invoices
Trump attorney Todd Blanche is showing the courtroom various invoices, vouchers and checks.
He argues that Trump Organization accounts payable supervisor Deb Tarasoff was doing "what she always does" which was generate vouchers and checks based off of invoices that Michael Cohen created. The jury is familar with Tarasoff, who was called by prosecutors to testify.
"The government wants you to believe that Mr. Cohen and Mr. [Allen] Weisselberg and President Trump had some kind of conspiratorial agreement to falsify records," Blanche tells the jury.
Blanche argues that the People say Cohen "was working for free" but as the invoice stated, Cohen was rendering services as personal attorney to the president because there were outstanding matters Cohen was dealing with for Trump.
Blanche asks the jury what makes more sense: that Trump was paying his then-lawyer, or, "the version that Mr. Cohen came in here and told you... that, 'No, I was not paid. I was going to work for free.'"
"The simplest answer is the right one and that's certainly the case here."
Blanche says Tarasoff did exactly what she was instructed to do: book it as a legal expense, which is how every invoice that came from a lawyer or law firm was booked.
In Feb. of 2017, after former Trump Organization controller Jeff McConney tried to pay Cohen's invoice from the trust, Weisselberg said, "Ok to pay as per agreement with Don and Eric," Blanche continues.
He argues if there was an agreement between Cohen, Weisselberg and Trump, "there's not reason to get approval from Don and Eric."
Blanche points out that the jury did not hear from Don Jr. nor Eric — both are sitting in the front row.
He turns to former director of Oval Office operations Madeleine Westerhout's testimony about Trump sometimes looking at the checks and invoices and sometimes not looking.
"President Trump was very busy, he was running the country," Blanche says. He argues that the allegations Trump was in on the alleged "scheme" is "absurd."
May 28, 2024 at 09:44 AM EDT
Defense begins closing arguments
Trump attorney Todd Blanche begins his closing arguments by thanking the jurors for their service, being on time and paying close attention "all day, everyday... we really appreciate that."
"President Trump is innocent," Blanche says. "He did not commit any crimes and the district attorney has not met the burden of proof, period." The evidence presented by prosecutors should leave jurors "wanting more."
"You should want and expect more than the testimony of Michael Cohen," Blanche says.
He argues the case is not about an encounter with adult film star Stormy Daniels, but rather a paper case.
"This case is about documents, it's a paper case," Blanche says. "This case is not about an encounter with Stormy Daniels 18 years ago, an encounter that President Trump has repeatedly and unequivocally denied." He adds that Trump can't be convicted "on the word of Michael Cohen."
May 28, 2024 at 09:41 AM EDT
The jury is seated
The jury is seated. Judge Juan Merchan addresses them, explaining they're about to hear summations.
Under the law, "the defense must go first," Merchan explains. "I am responsible for explaining the law, not the lawyers," he continues. If you think there's a difference, "follow my instructions on the law."
Here's what we know about the panel of 12 jurors.
May 28, 2024 at 09:37 AM EDT
Closing arguments expected to stretch nearly seven hours
Judge Juan Merchan has taken the bench. Court may go past the usual 4:30 p.m. today, as closing arguments are expected to take several hours.
Trump attorney Todd Blanche says the defense plans to take roughly 2.5 hours for closing arguments, possibly longer. Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass says the prosecution is estimating 4 to 4.5 hours, noting their closings will need to be "responsive" to Trump's team.
Merchan says jurors were given charging instructions on Thursday and no errors were flagged over the weekend.
May 28, 2024 at 09:34 AM EDT
Watch: Trump’s remarks ahead of closing arguments
As he's done for the past 20 days of the hush money trial, former President Donald Trump addressed reporters before walking into the courtroom this morning.
"Make no mistake about it, I'm here because of crooked Joe Biden," Trump began.
Trump is now inside of the courtroom. Three of his children, Donald Jr., Eric and Tiffany Trump, are here and seated in the front row.
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene slammed the case, accusing Democrats of
attempting to "again" steal the election.
"The only argument that needs to be made is that Democrats have weaponized justice systems and are abusing power in order to attempt steal the election again," Greene wrote on X.
May 28, 2024 at 09:18 AM EDT
Alina Habba raises “serious concerns” over jury
Donald Trump's legal spokesperson Alina Habba raised concerns over the jury not being sequestered over the Memorial Day holiday weekend.
"These jurors are handling something that is completely unprecedented and unwarranted in America and for them to be out and about on a holiday weekend with friends and families who have opinions—who are watching the news, TV is on in the background at the pool party—I have serious concerns," Habba told Fox News on Sunday.
Read more from Newsweek's Giulia Carbonaro here.
May 28, 2024 at 09:01 AM EDT
Three of Trump’s children expected in court today
Former President Donald Trump left Trump Tower a few moments ago for the Manhattan Criminal Courthouse.
Three of Trump's children are expected to attend court today: Donald Trump Jr., Eric Trump and Tiffany Trump. This would be Tiffany's first appearance in court.
The scene outside: Supporters of the former president have gathered outside of court ahead of today's proceedings with American flags and banners. Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg was seen entering the courthouse a short time ago.
What has Trump said? The former president railed against the case in a series of posts on Truth Social Monday night.
"Why is the corrupt government allowed to make the final argument in the case against me? Why can't the defense go last? Big advantage, very unfair. Witch hunt!" Trump wrote.
"According to virtually all Legal Scholars and Experts, THERE IS NO CRIME OR CASE against President Trump, and if there was it should have been brought seven years ago, not in the middle of his Campaign for President. Prosecutorial Misconduct. Election Interference!" another post reads in part.
May 28, 2024 at 08:45 AM EDT
Soon: Closing arguments begin
Good morning, it's 8:45 a.m. in New York City. After a one week hiatus, the hush money trial resumes this morning with closing arguments.
Trump's team will be up first, followed by the prosecution. Judge Juan Merchan will then instruct jurors and deliberations will begin. The panel of 12 jurors must reach a unanimous decision. Legal experts have said that the chance of a mistrial is far higher in the former president's situation than in a normal trial. "Anything can happen in a trial like this, and it only takes one holdout," jury consultant Melissa Gomez said. Read more here.
Witness testimony: Over the last several weeks, the jury has listened to testimony from 22 witnesses. Prosecutors called 20 witnesses, including their star witness Michael Cohen, adult film star Stormy Daniels, former top Trump aide Hope Hicks and former National Enquirer publisher David Pecker. The defense called two, including Robert Costello, an attorney who advised Cohen.
The charges: The Manhattan DA's office alleges that Trump falsified business documents to cover up an alleged $130,000 hush money payment to adult film actress Stormy Daniels before the 2016 election. Trump has pleaded not guilty to all 34 charges and maintains that he never had an affair with Daniels.
Get caught up: Here's what happened on day 20.
Newsweek senior reporter Katherine Fung is inside the courtroom.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines