10

Loading video...

Shane Croucher

By Shane Croucher

Senior Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The weapon allegedly used by Luigi Mangione, the suspect in the shooting of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, is believed to be a so-called "ghost gun".

Ghost guns are often untraceable. They are assembled from parts bought separately or even 3D-printed. As such, they are often unregistered, unlike a weapon bought from a manufacturer or a licensed intermediary, such as a gun store.

The Biden Administration has attempted to regulate ghost guns and bring them under the same rules as regular firearms, meaning they need serial numbers so they can be traced and their purchasers subject to background checks.

Read More on News

But the ghost gun rules are under challenge by gun rights groups in the Supreme Court, who believe they infringe on the U.S. Constitution's Second Amendment protections on Americans' right to bear arms.

In light of the potential use of a ghost gun in the UnitedHealthcare case—seen as a targeted assassination—is it time for the U.S. to ban all ghost guns? Newsweek asked academics, campaigners, and lawmakers. Here's what they said.

ghost guns in new york city

...

Senator Ed Markey (D-MA)

3D printed ghost guns are homemade weapons that, pose a grave danger to the public because they can evade metal detectors and lack serial numbers, which would allow them to be traced.

We must stop the proliferation of ghost guns and enact commonsense solutions to gun violence, including passing my 3D Printed Gun Safety Act, which bans the distribution of the digital files used to create and print those guns.

Amy Cooter, Director of Research, Academic Development, and Innovation (RADI), Center on Terrorism, Extremism, and Counterterrorism, Middlebury Institute

Ghost guns should almost certainly be banned, but there are enormous practical difficulties in making that happen such that any regulation would likely merely add time to sentences for already committed or separate criminal actions.

Regulation would also have some immediate push back from certain militia world groups who see ghost guns as a way to escape "tyrannical" government control over firearm access.

Kelly Roskam, Director of Law and Policy, Johns Hopkins Center for Gun Violence Solutions

A report of crime gun analysis and intelligence from 2017-2021 released by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives (ATF) on February 1, 2023, the National Firearms Commerce and Trafficking Assessment: Crime Guns – Volume Two, shows a 1000 percent increase in the criminal use of ghost guns since 2017.

The ATF rule at issue in the pending Supreme Court case Garland v. VanderStok requires that manufacturers and retailers of ghost guns comply with the requirements of the Gun Control Act—to mark their products with serial numbers, maintain sales records, and conduct background checks to ensure that prohibited persons can't access guns.

It is essential to maintain this rule and for states to strengthen their laws to ensure that ghost guns may not be sold or possessed unless they are imprinted with a serial number and that background checks are conducted for the sale of ghost guns whether they are sold by licensed dealers or private persons.

It is crucial that federal and state governments regulate the sale and possession of ghost guns because failure to do so allows individuals to circumvent essential public safety laws.

Luigi Mangione arrest photo

...

Joshua Fisher-Birch, Researcher, Counter Extremism Project

The federal government, states, or cities may want to ban or restrict access to "ghost gun" kits and 3D-printed firearms.

"Ghost gun" kits and 3D-printed firearms potentially allow individuals access to weapons when they should be prohibited from owning firearms for legal reasons.

A variety of extremist sympathizers, from racially motivated violent extremists (REMVE) to online ISIS supporters, have spread designs for 3D-printed firearms and, in the case of some REMVE groups, have advocated the purchase of 80 percent lower receivers, which can be milled or otherwise turned into functioning firearms.

Notably, some affiliated with the broad American REMVE movement have specifically advocated that individuals not legally allowed to own firearms could 3D print lower receivers and have spread information for doing so.

Content related to 3D-printed firearms can often be found in online locations affiliated with neo-Nazi accelerationists.

Emma Brown, Executive Director, Giffords

Ghost guns are a criminal's dream come true. The targeted assassination of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, potentially committed with a ghost gun, shows just how dangerous these weapons are in the wrong hands.

Anyone can print them at home or buy unfinished parts online without a background check or training. Yet due to extremists in the gun lobby, the ATF's rule to stop criminals from getting ghost guns is under threat.

Americans' safety from ghost guns now lies in the hands of the Supreme Court justices. Here's the bottom line: Ghost guns threaten public safety and must be subject to background checks like the guns they are

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines