Decarlos Brown Jr

...

Jesus Mesa

By Jesus Mesa

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Those who get their news primarily from the social media platform X were flooded over the weekend with posts about the killing of 23-year-old Iryna Zarutska, a Ukrainian refugee stabbed to death on a Charlotte, N.C., light rail train. Surveillance footage released after delay by the Charlotte Area Transit System (CATS) shows Zarutska boarding the train after her shift at a pizzeria and taking a seat in front of a man later identified as 34-year-old Decarlos Brown, who is Black. Just four minutes later, Brown pulled out a pocket knife and stabbed her three times, including once in the neck.

Iryna Zarutska died on the train, having escaped from Vladimir Putin's war machine only to be murdered in a random act of American violence.

The footage — which pauses in the moment before the brutal attack — spread quickly across the platform formerly known as Twitter, where prominent right-leaning voices questioned why the random act of horrific violence, which occurred on Aug. 22, hadn't received wider coverage from mainstream outlets, which mostly ignored the story until Monday — especially given its connection to the war in Ukraine.

Read More on Politics

Elon Musk, the platform's owner and its most-followed user who is known for wading into controversies surrounding race and crime, posted about the case at least a dozen times over the weekend. He pinned a post comparing the coverage of Zarutska's murder to George Floyd's killing in 2020, calling it a "Divide by zero ratio."

View this post on X

Musk also said stories like Zarutska's are "sorely needed" to expose failures in the justice system, and warned his followers about "the magnitude of legacy media lies."

Other conservative figures amplified the story as well. British journalist Piers Morgan asked his 8.5 million followers: "Why is the disgusting, senseless, unprovoked murder of 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska by a man named Decarlos Brown Jr. on a train in Charlotte, NC, not getting more media attention?!"

View this post on X

'Law and Order'

President Donald Trump on Monday condemned the killing, calling the suspect a "lunatic" and a "madman" during remarks at the Museum of the Bible in Washington. "We're all people of religion, but there are evil people. And we have to confront that," Trump said. "If we don't handle that, we don't have a country."

For Trump, the Charlotte stabbing reinforces the "law and order" message he has revived as a central theme in his latest push against crime in major cities, which tend to be Democratic strongholds like Chicago, Washington, D.C., or New York. "This is exactly what he's talking about, and it's going to be an issue he's going to highlight," one adviser told Axios.

Figures close to Trump, including his top domestic policy adviser Stephen Miller, conservative activist Charlie Kirk, and Utah Senator Mike Lee, have also amplified the video online. North Carolina GOP senate candidate Michael Whatley accused former Democratic Governor Roy Cooper, who is now his opponent in the senate race, of being "soft on crime." Whatley tied Brown's release after a previous arrest to a 2020 executive order on racial profiling that Cooper had signed while in office. Cooper's campaign called that claim "a lie," insisting the order had nothing to do with Brown's long rap sheet.

Decarlos Brown Jr

...

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy blamed Charlotte officials, saying: "Charlotte failed Iryna Zarutska and North Carolinians" by not keeping a violent repeat offender behind bars. Charlotte Mayor Vi Lyles, a Democrat, initially emphasized homelessness and mental health in a public statement about the incident before later naming Zarutska and thanking media outlets that declined to share the disturbing video.

"Like so many of you, I'm heartbroken – and I've been thinking hard about what safety really looks like in our city," she said in a statement that only added to the political firestorm.

The killing has also revived debates about race and media coverage. Musk, a longtime armchair media critic who said he bought Twitter partly to correct what he claimed was its liberal bias, accused The New York Times of failing to cover Zarutska's case, writing: "Yes, The New York Times is an utter lie." Conservative commentators have argued the crime fits a larger pattern of Black-on-white violence that newsrooms avoid highlighting.

Court records show Brown had been arrested at least 14 times since 2011, with convictions for armed robbery, larceny and assault. He served about six years in prison before his release in 2020, but within months was charged again for assaulting his sister. Earlier this year, Brown was ordered to undergo a competency evaluation after a bizarre 911 call in which he claimed a "man-made substance" was controlling his body.

That evaluation was never completed, and he remained free until Zarutska's killing.

'Double Standard'

Prosecutors say the stabbing appeared to be a random act, but media critics see a double standard. They note that crimes involving white offenders and Black victims—such as George Floyd's murder in 2020 or the Daniel Penny subway vigilante case in 2023—dominated national coverage, while cases like Zarutska's often remain local stories until amplified on social media.

"If Iryna were Black and her killer white, the media would be rioting non-stop," conservative commentator Benny Johnson posted.

Critics of this "media blindspot" argument push back, saying raw interracial crime numbers can distort public perception. "Most crime is intraracial," Richard Rosenfeld, a criminology professor at the University of Missouri–St. Louis, told the science outlet SciLine in 2021.

He cited Bureau of Justice Statistics data showing that between 2017 and 2021, white victims reported white offenders in 8.7 million incidents compared with 2.38 million involving Black offenders. Black victims also overwhelmingly reported Black offenders—1.88 million incidents—compared with 371,000 by white offenders.

Decarlos Brown

...

Others note that social media amplifies rare but shocking crimes, fueling racially charged narratives while diverting attention from systemic drivers such as poverty, segregation and gaps in mental health care.

A 2023 report from the Manhattan Institute, a right-leaning think tank, underscored this point, though from a different angle. Researcher Zach Goldberg found that Americans dramatically overestimate the number of unarmed Black men killed by police while underestimating white victims of police killings. In one survey, 44 percent of liberals believed police killed 1,000 or more unarmed Black men in 2019. The actual figure was 29, compared with 44 unarmed white men.

Goldberg argued that disproportionate media attention on Black victims of police shootings creates a "racial skew" in public understanding of violence and policing.

Local officials also stressed the role of mental health assistance — or lack thereof — in Zarutska's killing. Mecklenburg County District Attorney Spencer Merriweather told Axios Charlotte that the case reflects systemic failures in handling mentally ill repeat offenders. "The public safety threat that you're actually after is one that could be remedied well before you grind your way through a court system," he said.

North Carolina faces a shortage of psychiatric beds, with patients in crisis waiting an average of 16 days in emergency rooms before state hospital placement.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines