10
Loading video...

By Daniel R. DePetris
Fellow, Defense Priorities
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
If you've listened to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu lately, you might think the Middle East is at the precipice of a new, more peaceful era. The idea behind this newfound optimism is simple: because Israel and the United States dealt Iran such a hard-blow during the so-called 12-day war last month, the Iranians no longer have the capacity to cause mischief in the region or threaten Israel as they once did. Israel, the argument continues, now has a golden opportunity to shift the Middle East's political and security landscape to its advantage.
"I think we can work out a peace between us and the entire Middle East with President Trump's leadership, and by working together, I think we can establish a very, very broad peace that will include all our neighbors," Netanyahu said at the White House this week.
It's hard not to agree with at least some of this.
Read More on Opinion

...
Iran's conventional military power, never particularly strong to begin with given decades-long U.S. and European export controls on military technology, was dealt a huge setback in the 12 days Israeli aircraft were in the air. Tehran's military leadership was hit to an extent it hadn't experienced since the long eight-year war with Iraq's Saddam Hussein in the 1980s. The Israeli Air Force handled Iran's air defense system with ease, so much so that Israeli pilots established air superiority over the country and greased the skids for U.S. B-2 bombers to drop their 30,000-pound payloads on two of Iran's main nuclear facilities at Natanz and Fordow. Meanwhile, Iran's so-called axis of resistance, a network of proxy militias, is in a desultory state after more than a year of relentless Israeli airstrikes and ground operations.
There is some diplomatic movement in the region as well, none of which serves Iran well. In Lebanon, Tom Barrack, the U.S. ambassador to Turkey, is mediating between Israel, Hezbollah, and the Lebanese government in an attempt to establish a new peace regime between all three. According to Barrack, the Lebanese government's response to Washington's position paper was "spectacular," an indication the Trump administration believes there's a realistic chance to finally usher in an Israel-Lebanon peace accord.
Talks between Israel and Syria are ongoing, which would have been unthinkable during the reign of former dictator Bashar al-Assad, whose partnership with Iran and insistence that Israel hand over the Golan Heights to Damascus in exchange for normalization nipped any détente in the bud. But Assad is now in Moscow, sulking in exile, and Damascus is ruled by an entirely different government that is interested in normalizing relations with Syria's traditional adversaries. This not only includes the United States—the Trump administration revoked some long-standing U.S. sanctions against Syria last month—but also Israel, whose officials have engaged in discrete talks with the Syrian administration of President Ahmed al-Sharaa for months.
Just because some pieces of the puzzle are being moved doesn't mean the game will end with all players satisfied.
The Israel-Lebanon talks, for instance, are complicated by several factors. Despite last November's ceasefire between Israel and Hezbollah, the Israeli military continues to strike Hezbollah positions inside Southern Lebanon on a near-weekly basis. The Israeli government argues that it's merely penalizing Hezbollah for its own violations of the ceasefire, which mandates the Lebanese militant group withdraw north of the Litani River and hand over their weapons stockpiles to the Lebanese army. Hezbollah, of course, has a different interpretation, claiming it won't disarm as long as Israel is dropping bombs on Lebanese soil and holding five separate observation posts inside Lebanese territory. Lebanese President Joseph Aoun, while certainly no fan of Hezbollah, also doesn't want to be seen as getting kicked around by the Israelis and has a domestic political incentive to not roll over in negotiations.
Israeli-Syrian talks won't be easy either. Notwithstanding Netanyahu's vision of a total turning of the page, it's more likely these ongoing talks will result in the two neighbors establishing some military deconfliction protocols and guardrails along their shared border. Ahmed al-Sharaa may be open to exploring a new relationship, but the notion he would formalize it with the Golan Heights under full Israeli control is difficult to envision. In fact, it would be a radical break with Syria's past policy and one that would get him into trouble with the more conservative elements of his political base. And it was only two months ago when Israel struck near the Syrian presidential palace in a ploy to warn the new Syrian government of attacking Druze-led areas.
None of this even accounts for the ongoing war in Gaza, which remains an albatross around Israel's neck and makes it extraordinarily tough for any state in the region, whether it's Saudi Arabia or Syria, to mend relations with Jerusalem even if it wanted to.
If all of this sounds pessimistic, that's because it is. The Middle East moves slowly, so don't be surprised if the new dawn everybody is talking about doesn't come to fruition.
Daniel R. DePetris is a fellow at Defense Priorities and a syndicated foreign affairs columnist at the Chicago Tribune*.*
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines