Mail ballot

...

Alia Shoaib

By Alia Shoaib

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A ruling about whether Mississippi can count postmarked mail ballots that arrive after Election Day could have a "national impact," according to a former federal prosecutor.

On Tuesday, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals is to hear oral argument in RNC v. Wetzel, a lawsuit filed by the Republican National Convention to disallow the counting of ballots that are received after Election Day in Mississippi.

Mississippi counts mail-in ballots that are received up to five business days after an election as long as they are postmarked on or before Election Day.

Read More on Politics

Writing on her Substack blog on Monday, former federal prosecutor Joyce Vance said that the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals' judgment could have a widespread impact.

"Remember, this is the Fifth Circuit, a court with a propensity for reaching maximalist results when a more narrow ruling would have served and enabling the Supreme Court to go off on a tangent, like it did when it reversed Roe v. Wade in the Dobbs case, which also came out of Mississippi," Vance wrote.

The Fifth Circuit hears appeals from federal district courts in Mississippi, Louisiana and Texas.

Newsweek reached out to the RNC via contact form on its website outside of regular working hours.

"Hopefully, the panel judges, James Ho, Stuart Duncan, and Andrew Oldham—all Trump appointees—will push aside the RNC's argument and rule in favor of Mississippi's Republican Secretary of State [Michael Watson], who is the defendant," she added.

She said that the case "could end up having a national impact."

The case is being heard by the appeals court after a district court rejected the RNC's challenge to Mississippi's mail ballot counting process.

Judge Louis Guirola ruled that the state's procedure for counting lawfully cast absentee ballots, postmarked on or before Election Day, was consistent with federal law and the Constitution.

Mail ballot

...

The case is part of a Republican effort to stop states from counting postmarked ballots that arrive after Election Day. The RNC and others have this year filed challenges to the ballot return rules in Nevada, Illinois, Mississippi and North Dakota.

Claire Zunk, communications director for the RNC's election integrity unit, told NPR in August: "Counting ballots that come in after Election Day in Mississippi and other states threatens election security and undermines transparency for voters."

Republicans have long taken issue with mail-in ballots, frequently saying that they allow fraud.

Vance said in her Substack blog that mail-in ballots are typically used by "voters who Republicans seem to believe are inclined to vote Democratic."

Around 20 states count postmarked ballots that arrive after Election Day in order to allow people to vote by mail on the day of election and to account for any postal delays.

Vance, who was U.S. attorney for the Northern District of Alabama during the Obama administration, added that this system generally helps student, the elderly, those who are sick or who have disabilities, as well as voters who must work on Election Day.

The Justice Department wrote in an amicus brief that changing the current rules in Mississippi could impact whether members of the military and Americans living abroad have their ballots counted.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines