
...
![]()
By Darlin Tillery
Life & Trends Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A mother is questioning her trust in her nanny after a car accident revealed what she calls a serious violation of an explicit safety rule.
In a post on Reddit, the mother and original poster (OP), user Mysterious-Cat3303, explained she had previously instructed her nanny not to place her two-year-old daughter in a car seat while wearing a bulky jacket, citing safety concerns.
"I told her this because I saw her pull into the driveway once, and my daughter was wearing a bulky jacket in the car seat," she wrote. "After I corrected this, she said, OK, she’ll make sure she isn’t wearing her jacket. Cool."
Read More on Life
But that trust was broken when the nanny and child were rear-ended in a minor accident.

...
No one was injured, but when the OP arrived at the scene, she found her daughter once again strapped into her car seat with a thick coat.
“I was already a little emotional because I was worried about the crash,” she recalled, “and when I saw the jacket I definitely spoke to nanny in a pretty stern tone about it.”
However, the nanny’s response—"but [your] daughter was fine"—struck a nerve.
"But what if the crash had been worse and my daughter had really been injured because she was improperly placed in the carseat?" the OP wrote. "I was really annoyed, and I’m still pretty upset about it a couple of days later."
Reddit users overwhelmingly backed the OP's position, with one writing, “Nanny didn’t take your feedback, put your kid at risk, and then her excuse was ‘but did she get hurt???’”
“Yeah, no. As a nanny, I would expect to get fired.”
Another user pointed out, “After you informed her it was dangerous, it should’ve never happened again. I’d be so upset.”
In response, the OP confirmed she was still upset: "[I'm] honestly reconsidering her employment,” she added.
'Can't be tolerated'
Safety experts agree that this kind of situation warrants serious concern.
According to MommyBites, “Even a one-time offense from this list is cause for serious concern... you’re under no obligation to employ them longer than you’re comfortable with.
"You can fire a nanny at any time, so don’t think twice about firing your nanny without any notice if your child’s safety and well-being are at risk.”
Another parent, writing in San Francisco Moms, recalled her own decision to terminate a long-term nanny after a series of what she called careless mistakes involving safety.
“There are certain things that can’t be tolerated,” Kelly Arditi wrote. “For me, it’s safety.”
This OP echoed that concern: “It’s hard to trust her now.”
Newsweek has reached out to Mysterious-Cat3303 for comment via Reddit. We could not verify the details of the case.
To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, click here.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines