
By Steven Asarch
Writer
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Over the past week, more than 25 subreddits have gone private or closed to new posts for a day "to protest the reddit admins' providing a home for hate speech."
On Monday, Reddit CEO Steve Huffman released a letter sharing his thoughts on the police killing of George Floyd, the subsequent protests that have been taking place throughout the United States and what Reddit can do to address issues of injustice and racial inequality. In the post, Huffman says how "critical it is for all of us to affirm with our voices and actions that Black lives matter." He also notes that Reddit is considering a few different courses of action to "be an impetus for change," among them, "on-site activations ... shifting marketing resources to address these needs, and hosting AMA's that will help guide conversations."

...
Read More on Science
To some, including the moderators of some of the site's more popular subs, Huffman's words ring hollow. R/NFL, r/NBA, r/EDM, r/ScreenWriting and more have all gone private for 24 hours in response to his statement. The football-dedicated sub asked for "a reddit policy against bigotry ... a way to report subreddits based on the content of their sub and If these cannot be met, we call for the resignation of Reddit leadership."
Meanwhile, the r/nba moderators wrote. "We ask that Reddit take concrete action to deplatform users and communities that perpetuate racism."
In an email to Newsweek, the moderators of r/AskHistorians described their sub as a "digital humanities project that provides a tightly-regulated, bigotry-free space for the public to engage with historical professionals and grassroots historians." With over 1.2 million followers and over 1.5 million readers a month, it's a place that requires constant moderation in order to stop the spread of false or misleading information.
The r/AskHistorians post announcing that new submissions would be disabled for 15-and-a-half hours—from 8:30 p.m. EDT on Tuesday to 12:00 p.m. EDT on Wednesday—managed to pull in over 32,000 upvotes.
"Racism and other forms of bigotry are embedded in Reddit through the site's rules and norms," the moderators said in their email to Newsweek. "Reddit has very few site-wide rules, and while this has the advantage of supporting the development of unique communities, like AskHistorians, it also means that there are few explicit guidelines for implementing sanctions."
Moderators for other subs—including r/AskReddit and r/IAMA—have shared their thoughts in posts discussing the Black Lives Matter movement. R/History, a sub dedicated to cataloging the past, has also shut down posting to its 14.8 million members following r/AskHistorians. (The mods of r/History declined to comment for this article.)
In 2015, when Huffman was asked about allowing "hate subs" on the platform, he replied, "While my personal views towards bigotry haven't changed, my opinion of what Reddit should do about it has. I don't think we should silence people just because their viewpoints are something we disagree with. There is value in the conversation, and we as a society need to confront these issues."
A few years later, in an AMA in 2018, Huffman wrote, "on Reddit there will be people with beliefs different from your own, sometimes extremely so. When users actions conflict with our content policies, we take action." Once the post was downvoted over 1,000 times, he wrote an update saying, "To be perfectly clear, while racism itself isn't against the rules, it's not welcome here." He also added, "When it comes to enforcement, we separate behavior from beliefs. We cannot control people's beliefs, but we can police their behaviors."
Reddit has improved its stance on hate speech over the past decade. In 2018, more than 20 controversial subs were quarantined (meaning they have no ads and can't be accessed without logging into an account), like r/watchpeopledie and r/againstgaymarriage. r/The_donald, a subreddit dedicated to President Donald Trump that tended to be an echo chamber for hate speech, was put into quarantine in June of 2019 with its volunteer moderators being removed just a few months later.
Even still, Reddit continues to draw criticism, including from its former CEO, Ellen Pao, who tweeted on Tuesday that she felt "obligated" to call out Huffman's Monday post about George Floyd and Black Lives Matter. "You don't get to say BLM when reddit nurtures and monetizes white supremacy and hate all day long," Pao wrote on Twitter.
The r/AskHistorians mods also feel that Reddit has not done enough to combat toxicity on the platform. "Every day our sub, which has zero tolerance for such speech, has to delete posts filled with exactly the racism, hatred, and threats of violence that the admins claim to oppose," the mods said. "Given the overwhelmingly positive response [the post] has received, we believe we made the right choice."
Moderators on Reddit are broken into two categories: those that are paid by the company and those that are volunteers. A majority of moderators are the latter—volunteers who have day jobs. The moderators for r/AskHistorians are researchers, museums collection managers and professors. They choose to police the sub in their free time and their "shared love and passion for our subreddit's purpose: teaching history" is what binds them, the mods said.
Without strict guidelines detailing what is and isn't allowed on the platform, hateful rhetoric can continue.
"And since rules are demonstrative of a site's values, developing explicitly anti-racist rules, outlining sanctions for violating those rules, and then actually enacting those sanctions at both the user and subreddit level are the first step," the r/AskHistorian mods said.
Reddit did not respond to a request for comment from Newsweek by publication time.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines