Stock image of couple.

...

Lydia Patrick

By Lydia Patrick

Life & Trends Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The internet has rallied behind a man who stood up for his younger sister during a family dinner where his girlfriend made disparaging remarks.

The 32-year-old man shared his story on Reddit's popular "Am I The A******" (AITA) forum, seeking advice on how he defended his 21-year-old sister, Anna, from his 27-year-old girlfriend, Jenny.

"In recent months, I've noticed that whenever Anna comes up in conversation, Jenny jokes about how she's overly spoiled by my parents and me, claiming we've turned her into a 'princess'," he wrote in the Reddit thread, which quickly gained 15,000 upvotes.

Read More on Life

More From Newsweek Vault: Rates Are Still High for These High-Yield Savings Accounts

He wrote that despite their large age gap, the siblings enjoy a close relationship since he looked after her during her "bratty teen years" whilst his parents worked demanding jobs.

Tensions peaked during a family dinner with the man's parents present. Anna was recounting a recent date that left her with "the ick"—a term used to describe a sudden feeling of repulsion towards someone due to something they said or did.

aitah telling girlfriend that she gave me the ick
r/AmItheAsshole

View this post on Reddit

Anna explained how her date didn't offer to pay for their meal, leaving her to cover the entire bill.

More From Newsweek Vault: What Is a Checking Account and How Do They Work?

Jenny laughed and remarked that not every man would treat Anna like her brother would, suggesting: "You need to lower your standards."

The man was unhappy with this comment, as it implied his sister didn't deserve basic respect.

The situation escalated when Jenny added that she would never face such a scenario because men see her as "high value."

At this point, the man felt compelled to defend his sister. "I told her that she was giving me 'the ick' and asked her to stop talking to my sister like that," he posted.

When back at home, the couple had a heated argument, with Jenny accusing him of overreacting and claiming he would make a "terrible father" for favoring his sister over her. "I'm shocked to be called a 'terrible father' and honestly still don't think I was wrong, but I need another opinion," he shared on Reddit.

Stock image of couple.

...

Expert Opinion

Melissa Klass, a licensed marriage therapist from California, weighed in on the dilemma.

"A variety of issues stand out to me. The first is that we cannot be certain about the dynamics in [the original poster's] family based on his report.

"One possibility is that the situation is just as he says, and due to his parent's busy schedules, he became a de facto caretaker for his sister when they were young (leading to the closeness between them).

"It is also possible that the OP and his sister are enmeshed, and that she is, in fact, spoiled. The truth is that it doesn't matter when it comes to the situation in question. The issue here is the comments made by Jenny and the resulting fight," she told Newsweek.

According to Klass, it's important to consider that Jenny might feel threatened or unprioritized in the relationship.

Klass noted that while Jenny's comments were hurtful and inappropriate, they likely stemmed from her own insecurities or unmet emotional needs. Klass explained that the situation escalated because Jenny was unable to articulate her feelings, instead lashing out at Anna.

Klass recommended that the couple address the underlying emotions driving the conflict.

She suggested that the OP should have approached Jenny privately to discuss how her comments made him feel and the importance of maintaining a respectful relationship between Jenny and his family.

"It was not particularly appropriate for OP to tell Jenny she was giving him the 'ick' in front of everyone, but the situation was entirely appropriate to discuss upon their return home.

"As I often see in couple's therapy, the fight became about the content (what actually occurred) as opposed to the feelings or needs not being met," she said.

To overcome his situation, both partners would need to express their feelings openly and empathetically, which could lead to a resolution and a stronger relationship.

Reddit Reacts

Reddit users overwhelmingly sided with the man, affirming that he was not the a****** in this situation.

"NTA. It's like she's trying to compete with your sister. I'd have already gotten rid of her," commented one user.

Another added, "NTA. She's a walking red flag. *Jennifer then went on talk about how that would've never happen to her as men see her as "high value".*

"What is this comment ? Ewwwwwww.

"Her behavior with your sister is sooo uncalled for, please run, this is not someone who you should settle down with."

Newsweek reached out to Nonfrench_Fries362 for comment via Reddit. We could not verify the details of the case.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines