10

Loading video...

Faye James

By Faye James

US news reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Americans could receive unsolicited political calls featuring artificial intelligence-generated voices before November’s midterm elections if the Federal Communications Commission approves a request to relax cellphone calling restrictions.

The conservative advocacy group Club for Growth is seeking permission for noncommercial political calls using artificial or prerecorded voices, including AI-generated speech, without recipients’ prior express consent. The FCC has invited public comment on the request.

The rules have not changed. However, with reply comments due October 19, the proceeding could affect how political organizations reach voters before the November 3 election and whether voters must agree to receive those calls.

Read More on News

A consent exemption would not automatically make voter intimidation or deceptive election messages lawful. Critics nevertheless argue it could remove an important enforcement barrier.

Democratic FCC Commissioner Anna Gomez opposes the request: "We’ve already seen dark money groups use AI to put candidates' likeness behind inflammatory comments ahead of this election," Gomez said. "Exempting political calls from the need for consumer consent would supercharge that strategy, and misleading messages could land directly on the handheld phone of nearly every voter in our country."

Club for Growth, on the other hand, presents it as a way to improve political communication. "Our petition asks the FCC to treat First Amendment protected political speech the same way it already treats wireless calls about package deliveries, bank accounts, and doctor’s appointments," said the group’s president David McIntosh.

"We think the Constitution protects a conversation with a voter at least as highly as a delivery update."

Newsweek contacted the FCC by email for comment on the petition’s scope, potential decision timetable and safeguards.

File photo: a person uses a mobile phone in central London in November 2014.

...

What Could Voters Receive?

Club for Growth says AI-powered calling could help political organizations communicate in more languages and gather voter feedback. It claims that political speech deserves treatment comparable to certain permitted automated calls about deliveries, banking and medical appointments, according to Reuters.

For recipients, that could mean an artificial voice asking about political preferences or discussing campaign issues. Reuters reported that the group envisages a human initiating a call before an AI agent conducts an interview. These could be interactive conversations, rather than simply recorded messages.

"Campaigns could use AI technology to replace the staff, vendors, or volunteers that they rely on for things like polling and phone banking, potentially reducing costs and increasing scale," Patrick Crotty, senior attorney at the National Consumer Law Center, told Newsweek. "Existing AI models could be repurposed relatively cheaply and easily to perform these tasks – albeit with great risk of obtaining biased results or spreading misinformation."

Restrictions on artificial voices apply independently of whether a call uses an auto-dialer. In February 2024, the FCC ruled that AI-generated voices fall within the Telephone Consumer Protection Act’s existing category of artificial voices. That subjects them to consent requirements and applicable exemptions. However, it doesn't prohibit every use of AI on a telephone call.

Would Callers Have To Disclose AI?

Existing federal rules require artificial or prerecorded messages to identify the person or organization responsible at the beginning and provide a telephone number during or after the message.

Identifying that organization is different from telling someone the voice is artificial. The FCC proposed explicit AI disclosure requirements in 2024, including disclosure at the beginning of calls. But that proposal should not be confused with an adopted requirement: the current calling regulation does not contain an explicit AI-specific disclosure provision.

A voter hearing a campaign’s name would not necessarily learn whether the speaker was human. Newsweek asked the FCC whether callers operating under any exemption would have to disclose their use of AI and is awaiting a response.

Would There Be a Limit?

The requested approach includes a three-call limit per recipient over 30 days and an opt-out mechanism, according to the National Consumer Law Center, which opposes the petition.

"The risk that AI will make inaccurate or offensive claims is significant," Crotty said. "Prerecorded messages deliver identical information to each recipient and can be screened in advance to identify false and offensive statements. However, an AI-generated chatbot can deliver dynamic messages that vary based on the training information used to build the AI and the responses of the call recipient."

The organization says that multiple campaigns, political action committees and nonprofits could each make calls. Three calls from one organization would not necessarily mean three political calls overall. Furthermore, it also objects to the proposed allowance for callers to take up to 10 days to honor stop requests.

The National Consumer Law Center says that voters could continue receiving calls close to Election Day.

What Happens Next

In 2024, New Hampshire voters received calls using a cloned voice resembling then-President Joe Biden that discouraged participation in the presidential primary. The FCC subsequently imposed a $6 million fine against the organizer for illegal caller-ID spoofing.

Update 10/8/26, 12:35 p.m. ET: This article was updated with comments from Patrick Crotty.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: John Fitzpatrick, Dan Gooding and James Debens

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines