10
Loading video...

By Hollie Silverman
News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Russian authorities told the World Health Organization (WHO) that "no case of plague has been recorded in Irkutsk," the agency said Tuesday, casting doubt about reports that anti-plague researcher Daria Shipilova died from suspected pneumonic plague.
The WHO statement comes as biosecurity experts question whether Russia's reported response to the incident was consistent with a routine plague investigation. While there is no evidence that a biological weapon was involved, some experts say the scale of the reported response raises questions about whether officials were investigating a different infectious agent that has not been publicly identified.
“The Russian authorities…told WHO that the woman's illness first looked like a typical acute respiratory viral infection, and that no case of plague has been recorded in Irkutsk,” a spokesperson for WHO told Newsweek in an emailed statement on Tuesday.
Read More on News
The case drew international attention after media reports on October 2 said a woman working at a research laboratory in Irkutsk died of suspected pneumonic plague and that nearly 200 contacts were under medical observation and being tested.

...
"The Soviet Union had an offensive biological weapons program at the scale that went back decades and decades, and some of those anti-plague institutes were part of that program," Dr. Amesh A. Adalja, a senior scholar at the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security, told Newsweek. "Just because there's plague on the door doesn't mean that's the only thing they work on. They work on many different biological agents there."
According to the WHO, the agency requested information from Russian authorities on October 3 under the International Health Regulations, a framework governing the reporting of potential public health emergencies.
The WHO said it has requested additional information regarding which pneumonia-causing pathogen led to the woman's death and remains ready to assist Russian authorities if needed.
The agency's statement has shifted attention away from plague itself and toward the unanswered question of what caused the illness, as well as why Russian authorities reportedly took extensive containment measures.
In an updated statement released Tuesday, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) said it "is aware of and closely monitoring reports of a suspected case of pneumonic plague in the Irkutsk region of Russia that resulted in a death."
"We are working across the U.S. government to assess developments as additional information becomes available. While the circumstances of this reported case remain unconfirmed, plague is a serious bacterial disease that is treatable with antibiotics, particularly when recognized and treated early," the statement said.
"Pneumonic plague can spread person-to-person through respiratory droplets during close contact, which is why rapid identification and treatment of infected individuals, and monitoring of potentially exposed individuals, are important public health measures," the statement continued, adding, "At this time, there is no indication of a broader threat to the United States, but CDC and our interagency partners are prepared and will continue to monitor the situation closely."
Related Story

Russia Plague: 5 Unanswered Questions
Experts Raise Biological Weapons Concern
Adalja said that several aspects of the reported response appeared inconsistent with what would normally be expected for a plague case.
"Today, Russia notified the WHO that it was not plague," Adalja said. "The way they were reacting to the cases in terms of the contacts, the hospital, the hazmat suits, the head of their equivalent of the CDC flying there, was incongruent with the plague response."
Adalja said modern plague cases are generally treatable and that researchers working in facilities that handle plague would typically be subject to established safety protocols.
"Plague might be a lot of clickbait. People get really excited about it, but it's a treatable disease of the 21st century," he said. "Even if it were a drug-resistant version, it seemed to be a very major response to it."
He noted that someone exposed to plague in a research setting would ordinarily have access to post-exposure prophylaxis and highly effective antibiotics that often prevent severe illness.
"We know that Russia has used novel nerve agents in England," Adalja said. "And [Russian President] Vladimir Putin has talked about using genetic weapons or weapons of different characteristics. So we don't know. That's actually the real story that the media got very distracted by, the plague part,"
Adalja emphasized that there is no public evidence that the Irkutsk case involved a biological weapon or that Russian authorities are investigating such an incident.
However, he said the circumstances warrant closer scrutiny.
Adalja also said it's unknown where the patient traveled, noting that if she had been trapping animals for research, she could have come into contact with a pathogen that later developed into the infection.
Kevin Esvelt, an associate professor at the MIT Media Lab and a biosecurity researcher, cited reports that Russian authorities had deployed hazmat personnel and other containment measures.
"The obvious reason to lock down hospitals and deploy FSB agents and hazmat personnel, which Russia reportedly has done, is to contain a potentially transmissible biological agent before it spreads," Esvelt wrote on X. "The question is why they will not tell the world which one."
Newsweek reached out to Esvelt by email Tuesday for further comment.

...
Who Was Daria Shipilova?
Shipilova was reported by Russian media to be an employee of an anti-plague research institute in Irkutsk, Siberia.
Her death attracted global attention after reports linked the case to suspected pneumonic plague, a severe form of infection that affects the lungs and can spread through respiratory droplets.
However, the WHO said Russian authorities later informed the agency that no plague cases had been recorded in Irkutsk and that the illness initially appeared to be an acute respiratory viral infection.
Russian authorities have not publicly disclosed the pathogen responsible for Shipilova's death.
Severity of Plague in Russia
Even if plague had been involved, experts say it is no longer the public health threat associated with historic pandemics.
Modern antibiotics are generally effective at treating plague when administered promptly, and sporadic cases continue to occur in several countries, including the United States.
"If it were plague, it's not a big deal in the 21st century," Adalja said.
He added that even a drug-resistant strain would not fully explain the scale of the reported response described in media reports.
Established procedures exist for identifying cases, tracing contacts and treating exposed individuals, particularly in laboratory settings where researchers routinely work with dangerous pathogens.
That assessment is one reason some biosecurity experts have questioned reports of an extensive government response involving hazmat teams, tight hospital controls and senior public health officials traveling to the site.
What Caused Shipilova's Death?
Following Russia's notification to the WHO that no plague cases had been recorded in Irkutsk, the central unanswered question has become what pathogen caused Shipilova's illness.
The WHO said it has requested additional information from Russian authorities regarding "which pneumonia-causing pathogen led to the woman's death."
Adalja noted that descriptions of pneumonia of "unknown etiology" are broad and do not point to a specific disease.
"Anything can cause pneumonia," he said.
Potential causes can range from influenza, RSV and COVID-19 to bacterial infections such as Legionnaires' disease and streptococcal pneumonia.
According to Adalja, doctors investigating an unexplained pneumonia case would typically conduct blood cultures, sputum cultures, imaging studies and PCR testing for a wide range of respiratory pathogens.
"You need to know how broad did they test, what did they test for, what did they not test for," he said.
For now, public health officials are still awaiting further information. While Russia has informed the WHO that no plague case was recorded in Irkutsk, the pathogen responsible for Shipilova's death has not yet been publicly identified.
Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn
here.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Hollie Silverman and Dave Siminoff.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines