Samuel Alito

...

Mandy Taheri

By Mandy Taheri

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


"It's simply shocking that a Supreme Court Justice would allow this to happen," retired federal Judge John E. Jones III told CNN News Central host Brianna Keilar today, referring to Justice Samuel Alito. "This is just beyond the pale."

Jones, a former U.S. district judge for nearly 20 years who was appointed by President George W. Bush and current president of Pennsylvania's Dickinson College, made his comments after a January 2021 photograph of an upside-down American flag displayed outside of conservative Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito's home was reported by The New York Times. The inverted flag—spotted just days before President Joe Biden's inauguration—is a symbol used by supporters of former President Donald Trump to contest the 2020 election results.

Despite lack of evidence, Trump and his allies have repeatedly and falsely claimed that his 2020 loss to President Biden was due to widespread election fraud. The photograph of the inverted flag outside Alito's home was taken less than two weeks after a group of Trump supporters stormed the U.S. Capitol on January 6.

Read More

Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito Faces Impeachment Calls5 min read

Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito Faces Impeachment Calls

Mary Trump Says Donald Trump Deserves Credit for One Thing3 min read

Mary Trump Says Donald Trump Deserves Credit for One Thing

Russia May Push Buffer Zone Into NATO Nation: Putin Ally3 min read

Russia May Push Buffer Zone Into NATO Nation: Putin Ally

"I really believe in the integrity of the federal judiciary," Jones told Newsweek in a phone call. But, in his view, Alito's actions pull apart the Supreme Court's credibility and integrity. "There are a lot of my former colleagues who are desperately unhappy about this stuff. They're embarrassed about it," he said.

"The federal judiciary really only has its integrity; it doesn't have as Alexander Hamilton said the 'sword' or the 'purse,'" he explained. Jones warned of what happens if people no longer highly regard the Court, saying: "If people don't believe in the ability of our judiciary to rule without fear or favor, then what happens is they lose faith in that institution and the judges' decisions, or in this case the justices' decisions, cease to have the kind of impact that you want them to." He added that recently "the support and respect among the public has cratered," towards the Supreme Court.

According to the Supreme Court's code of conduct, a justice "should maintain and observe high standards of conduct in order to preserve the integrity and independence of the federal judiciary" and "should not be swayed by partisan interests, public clamor, or fear of criticism."

Newsweek filed a contact request form with the Supreme Court.

Samuel Alito

...

The nation's highest court, which consists of nine justices, has faced increased scrutiny over judges' potential partiality to the former president, which includes calls for Justice Clarence Thomas to recuse himself from Trump's immunity case since his wife, Ginni, said that she attended the former president's rally before the January 6 riot. Text messages obtained by the January 6 Committee found that Ginni told Trump's then-chief of staff Mark Meadows that he should encourage Trump not to concede to Biden.

The Supreme Court is expected to rule soon on whether Trump is protected by presidential immunity from charges in his federal election subversion case brought by Special Counsel Jack Smith. Alito's controversy calls into question his ability to rule impartially on the case.

"There won't be a recusal" relating to Alito in the case, Jones told Newsweek, adding, "I don't believe that the Chief Justice has any ability to order a recusal of a justice, they're [the justices] are all responsible to make that judgment themselves." He said Justice Alito's actions are "clearly indicative of the fact that he does not believe he has any conflict at all" and "so far as I know, I don't think he believes that there is any basis for him to recuse at this point." Jones pointed out that unlike lower federal courts where judges "would be subject to disciplinary proceedings," because "the Supreme Court polices itself, this just goes on unabated."

In a statement emailed to The New York Times, Alito placed all the responsibility on his wife, Martha-Ann Alito. Alito wrote he "had no involvement whatsoever in the flying of the flag" and that it was "briefly placed by Mrs. Alito in response to a neighbor's use of objectionable and personally insulting language on yard signs."

Jones said he doesn't find Alito's response "particularly credible," telling Newsweek that "even if it was his wife, if it [the inverted flag] was out for several days, I think he had a responsibility to do something about it." Jones previously told CNN, "I have a wife who has very strong opinions about things... but you keep that in the house" adding, "I think it's inelegant...to hang this on your wife. Own it... at least apologize."

The retired judge told CNN "I think this is just beyond the pale at this point, you can't have people doing this."

Other legal experts have commented on Alito's move to place all the blame on his wife, too.

Elie Mystal, attorney and justice correspondent for progressive news outlet The Nation, wrote in an X post sharing The New York Times' story, "Always gotta love when 'strong manly republicans for personal responsibility' throw their wives under the bus at the first available moment."

In a sarcastic tone, Constitutional law professor Anthony Kreis, who teaches at Georgia State University College of Law, wrote on X, "'TAKE THAT!,' Samuel Alito said hanging a flag upside down—a traditional and normal way to express anger at a neighbor—before planning to blame everything on his wife, who thankfully, would take the brunt of his bad decisions as the rest of women in America would soon feel."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines