Jazz Chisholm Jr New York Yankees

...

Jon Paul Hoornstra

By Jon Paul Hoornstra

Contributing Sports Writer

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Second base is a more flexible position than most in baseball. As Newsweek Sports continues its survey of the Top 10 players at each position in Major League Baseball, second base stands out as a distinct hodgepodge.

Among the best at the position are a handful of versatile fielders who have tried their hand elsewhere on the diamond. Some, like the New York Yankees' Jazz Chisholm, even succeeded at other positions before circumstances dictated a move to their current station.

More Top 10 lists from Newsweek Sports: Starting Pitchers | Catchers | Relief Pitchers | Center Fielders | Third Basemen

Read More on MLB

Still others — Mookie Betts a year ago, for example — were second basemen when 2024 spring training camps opened, only to see circumstances out of their control dictate a move to another position. Some on this list might not be second basemen when the 2025 season ends.

Jazz Chisholm Jr New York Yankees

...

Amid it all are a handful of stalwarts. Jose Altuve has played 1,765 games at second base — first among all active players, 22nd all-time — and two at any other position besides designated hitter. Ozzie Albies and Marcus Semien likewise don't figure to play anywhere besides second base this season for their current teams.

More news: Bob Uecker Dies: MLB World Remembers Legendary Announcer, Actor, Catcher

This list neglects a couple of players who might wind up spending a majority of their 2025 seasons at second base. Orioles prospect Jackson Holliday came up as a shortstop but is blocked there in Baltimore — for now — while free agent Alex Bregman might move off third base for the first time in five years depending on where he signs.

As it stands today, these are the 10 best second basemen in MLB:

10. Jeff McNeil

View this post on X

McNeil, 32, is coming off a down season in which he slashed .238/308/.384 in 129 games for the New York Mets. The "Flying Squirrel" has still been worth no fewer than 2 Wins Above Replacement each of the last three seasons, according to Baseball Reference, and is just two seasons removed from leading the National League in batting average (.326). A bounceback season in 2025 with the NL runners-up can solidify McNeil's standing on this list.

9. Brandon Lowe

View this post on X

Lowe, 30, is among the steadiest players in the league at a position of unsteadiness. His 121 OPS+ (.783 OPS) for the Rays in 2024 was right in line with his career 125 OPS+. A former All-Star who's finished in the Top 10 of AL MVP voting twice, Lowe is entering the final year of a seven-year contract with a team option for 2026 — ample motivation to make a big impression as the Rays settle into George Steinbrenner Field.

8. Nico Hoerner

View this post on X

The 2023 NL Gold Glove Award winner at second base, Hoerner remains one of the best defenders at the position in MLB. Last season saw the 27-year-old continue his steady production at the plate, lowering his already impressive strikeout rate to a minuscule 10.3 percent. Although not a power threat (29 home runs in 548 career games), Hoerner increased his line-drive percentage in 2024 to a career-high 30 percent, making him a valuable hitter in any lineup.

7. Jose Altuve

View this post on X

On the other end of the career trajectory sits Altuve, who at 34 might need only one more All-Star caliber season to punch his ticket to the Hall of Fame. Last season saw Altuve make his ninth career AL All-Star team while claiming his seventh Silver Slugger Award at the position, capping the year with his ninth postseason appearance in his 14-year career in Houston. The active leader in career batting average (.306), Altuve will try to fend off an age-related decline that eroded some of his underlying metrics in 2024.

6. Andres Gimenez

View this post on X

Gimenez will take his talents to Toronto after the Blue Jays sent two players to the Cleveland Guardians last month to secure the talented 26-year-old. A three-time Gold Glove Award winner at second base, Gimenez has averaged 6 bWAR over the last three years in Cleveland, and will hope to approach his career-best 141 OPS+ in 2022, when he made his only AL All-Star team.

5. Ozzie Albies

View this post on X

Separate bone fractures limited Albies to 99 games last year — a recurring theme for the 28-year-old — but he's averaged 4 bWAR in every full season he's played for Atlanta since bursting on the scene in 2018. Albies owns a career .270/.322/.470 slash line, plays steady defense, and is one of the best bargains in baseball. His contract guarantees $7 million in 2025, and again each of the next two years if the Braves exercise their club options.

4. Jazz Chisholm

View this post on X

Chisholm got the long postseason run he'd missed in Miami when a midseason trade to the New York Yankees afforded him a bright spotlight on baseball's biggest stage last season. The 26-year-old moved to second base, steadied the Yankees' lineup with 11 home runs and 18 stolen bases over 46 games, and delivered a home run and four steals in five World Series games. The former All-Star will get a long runway to solidify his status as a fan favorite in New York in 2025.

3. Xander Bogaerts

View this post on X

After signing a 11-year, $280 million contract with the San Diego Padres in Dec. 2022, Bogaerts moved off shortstop last season — only to move back as the Padres surged to a Wild Card berth late in 2024. A career .289/.352/.451 hitter, Bogaerts will look to play a full season after a shoulder fracture limited him to 111 regular season games.

2. Marcus Semien

View this post on X

An All-Star each of the last two seasons with the Texas Rangers, Semien has quietly become one of the best defensive second basemen in MLB since partnering with All-Star Corey Seager in the Rangers' potent middle infield. A career 110 OPS+ and a run of health that's seen him play at least 159 games in every non-pandemic season since 2018 makes Semien one of the most valuable players at any position on the diamond.

1. Ketel Marte

View this post on X

Marte, 31, finished third in National League MVP voting in 2024 while claiming his first career Silver Slugger Award at second base in his 10th MLB season. He might not repeat his .932 OPS (155 OPS+) in 2025, but Marte has already cemented his status as the best all-around player at the position in baseball.

For more MLB news, visit Newsweek Sports.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines