
...

By Jon Paul Hoornstra
Contributing Sports Writer
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Major League Baseball's free agency system effectively places international players into two buckets: amateurs and professionals.
"Amateurs" by definition have not been paid to entertain audiences by playing baseball; "professionals" have. The latter category is easy to define.
More news: Shohei Ohtani Gave New Marlins Manager Parting Gift Before He Left Dodgers
Read More on MLB
The overwhelming majority of Asian stars in MLB, from former New York Yankees outfielder Hideki Matsui to Chicago Cubs left-hander Shota Imanaga, were among the best players in their homeland's best professional league before arriving in the U.S. or Canada.

...
"Amateurs" are overwhelmingly Latin American players who sign as teenagers, though the occasional Asian-born player, like Shin-Soo Choo, will attempt to climb the minor league ladder in America without pursuing stardom in KBO or NPB first.
Under the terms of the Collective Bargaining Agreement, MLB teams are allotted a certain amount of money (an "international amateur bonus pool") to use as signing bonuses to entice these players every year. A new international amateur signing period begins Jan. 15, 2015.
More news: Surprising Yankees Reliever Drawing Interest as Starter From Rivals: Report
Pitcher Roki Sasaki finds himself caught in a strange area somewhere between "professional" and "amateur." By the dictionary definition of the word "professional," the Japanese phenom fits the bill. Although the 23-year-old hasn't been formally posted by his NPB team, the Chiba Lotte Marines, he's declared his intent to leave after four seasons with the Marines.
However, under the posting system agreed to by MLB and NPB, Sasaki does not have enough playing experience with the Marines to qualify as a professional international free agent. Therefore, he is being classified as an "amateur." His signing bonus is limited to whatever amount a team can offer within its international amateur bonus pool limit — reportedly about $7.6 million if he signs after Jan. 15.
More news: Mets Focused on Dodgers' Free Agent Rather Than Top-End Starters: Report
Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic recently proposed that MLB should exempt Sasaki from teams' 2025 international amateur bonus pool limits. The reason? Teams have already reached handshake agreements with the eligible amateur players (mostly from Latin America) who they would like to sign in 2025. To sign Sasaki, the signing team might have to renege on one or more of those agreements.
Others have questioned the wisdom of that idea.
More news: MLB News: Dodgers' Deferred-Money Contracts Stir Controversy
"As far as giving teams, separating Sasaki from the entire pools themselves, I think the thought behind it comes from a good place with good intentions, but you can't just make Roki Sasaki's signing exempt from the bonus pools," Baseball America's Ben Badler said on a recent episode of Foul Territory. "He's an international player. He doesn't meet the requirements to be a foreign professional under the (collective bargaining agreement). So he falls under the bonus pools. I don't think MLB should subsidizing a team by allowing them to sign Sasaki, and then have a whole separate bonus pool for them to sign a whole other group of international prospects.
"If a team wants to break off commitments that they have with players, then they should do that and deal with the ramifications. If other teams have saved money in their pool, in anticipation of Sasaki potentially coming over ... then those teams should not be penalized."
More news: Dodgers Sign Fan Favorite to $74 Million Contract Extension
Clearly, Sasaki is exposing a loophole in an imperfect system. Any player who is younger than 25, or has not played as a professional in NPB for a minimum of six seasons, is subject to international bonus pool money restrictions even if they're among the best pro players in their homeland.
However, it's rare a player with so little experience would make the leap from Japan to MLB. Shohei Ohtani followed a similar path seven years ago, but he also did so at the expense of millions of dollars available to him through the posting system.
More news: Blake Snell, Dodgers Agree to Five-Year, $182 Million Contract: Reports
Sasaki and Ohtani are generational talents. Few players, if any, will try to follow their path in the future.
Perhaps that means MLB would not be setting a dangerous precedent by exempting their contracts from teams' international signing bonus pools. Or perhaps that means MLB and the Players Association should merely work on closing the loophole Sasaki is exploiting in the language of the next CBA.
For more MLB news, visit Newsweek Sports.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines