Supreme Court

...

Mandy Taheri

By Mandy Taheri

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The U.S. Supreme Court is weighing two Trump administration emergency requests: one involving the removal of a Federal Trade Commission (FTC) member and another regardinga freeze on federal foreign aid.

Why It Matters

The Court currently has a 6-3 conservative majority and has ruled in favor of the Trump administration on many key issues including immigration enforcement and cuts at federal government agencies. Over a dozen emergency requests from the Trump administration have been granted by the Court this term.

Read More

Brett Kavanaugh Reveals What He Sees as Biggest Threat to Democracy4 min read

Brett Kavanaugh Reveals What He Sees as Biggest Threat to Democracy

Mary Trump Takes Aim at Donald Trump’s ‘Display of Grief’ for Charlie Kirk3 min read

Mary Trump Takes Aim at Donald Trump’s ‘Display of Grief’ for Charlie Kirk

Man Indicted Over Threats to ‘Hunt’ Supreme Court and Federal Judges4 min read

Man Indicted Over Threats to ‘Hunt’ Supreme Court and Federal Judges

The cases examine executive power, including the lawfulness and precedent governing removal of FTC commissioners, and whether a president may withhold congressionally appropriated foreign aid.

What To Know

In Trump v. Slaughter, the administration is requesting the Court to halt a ruling that reinstatesan FTC commissioner that Trump fired, Rebecca Slaughter.

Trump first sought to oust the Democratic commissioner in the spring. She sued, and lower courts ordered her reinstated, citing laws that restrict removal of FTC commissioners to cases involving misconduct or neglect of duty.

The Justice Department has maintained that the FTC and similar agencies fall squarely under presidential authority, allowing Trump to remove commissioners without cause. Slaughter, however, argues that her position is protected by law and by decades of legal precedent.

Earlier this month, Chief Justice John Roberts temporarily paused lower rulings and directed Slaughter's attorneys to file their response to the government's arguments by September 15.

The second case, Department of State v. AIDS Vaccine Advocacy Coalition, the administration is seeking to block billions of dollars in foreign aid. Since inauguration day, Trump has worked to pause foreign aid, issuing an executive order on the matter, which led Secretary of State Marco Rubio to freeze payments from the State Department and then now-dismantled U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID).

A judge ordered the administration to spend $4 billion in foreign aid by September 30; however, Trump's legal team argues the president has the right to propose a rescission, a cancellation of previously approved funds.

Roberts ordered a response to the application be filed by 4 p.m. on Friday.

Amicus briefs have been filed for both cases. Representative Rosa DeLauro, a Connecticut Democrat, filed against the Trump administration in the latter case regarding foreign aid.

Supreme Court

...

What People Are Saying

Representative Rosa DeLauro, a Connecticut Democrat, in an amicus brief filed in Trump v. Slaughter: "Because the President's limited authority to temporarily withhold funds proposed for rescission under the ICA does not permit the President to withhold those funds through their date of expiration without action from Congress, the district court's injunction imposes no greater burden on the government than already exists under that law. The stakes for Congress and the public, however, are high. The fiscal year ends on September 30, less than three weeks from today."

Justice Brett Kavanaugh at the 6th Circuit Judicial Conference last week: "We all fall short at times, but I think redoubling our efforts on tone, especially when the tone around us is in the public sphere, in the political world, on all sides, is loud, it's probably important."

Senator Elizabeth Warren, a Massachusetts Democratic wrote on X in March: "Donald Trump just illegally fired two independent commissioners at the FTC who fight big corporations that abuse consumers and workers. Why? Trump's billionaire donors expect a return on their investment. He works for them, not you. The courts must reinstate the commissioners."

White House spokesperson Abigail Jackson said earlier in September regarding a Court case pertaining to mass federal firings, per Reuters: "Yet another win for the Trump administration affirming the president's lawful actions and dismissing the unlawful ruling by a lower court judge."

What Happens Next?

The Court's fall term begins on October 6.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines