Activists with the Abolitionist Action Committee protest

...

Khaleda Rahman

By Khaleda Rahman

National Correspondent

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A federal appeals court has vacated the conviction and death sentence of a woman who has spent 27 years on death row.

In a 2-1 decision, the U.S. 5th Circuit Court of Appeals found that the state of Texas violated Brittany Holberg's right to due process by failing to disclose that their primary trial witness was a paid informant.

Why It Matters

Holberg, 52, was convicted and sentenced to death for capital murder in the course of committing or attempting to commit robbery in 1998 when she was 25.

Read More on U.S.

Holberg, a sex worker and drug addict, testified that she had acted in self-defense when, as a 23-year-old, she stabbed a former client, 80-year-old A.B. Towery, in his Amarillo apartment in 1996, saying she had feared for her life after he attacked her.

Prosecutors relied on testimony from Vickie Kirkpatrick, Holberg's jail cellmate, to secure the conviction but did not disclose that she was working as a confidential informant for the Amarillo Police Department. She recanted her testimony in 2011, saying the state had used her pending burglary charge as leverage to ensure she testified against Holberg.

Activists with the Abolitionist Action Committee protest

...

What To Know

Kirkpatrick had testified that Holberg had admitted to killing Towery to get money for drugs.

Prosecutors did not disclose that Kirkpatrick had been working as a confidential informant for the City of Amarillo police, but presented her to the jury in Holberg's trial as someone who "wanted to do the right thing," Judge Patrick E. Higginbotham, an appointee of Ronald Reagan, wrote in the ruling on Friday.

The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals and a federal-district court both ruled that prosecutors had not violated Holberg's rights by failing to disclose Kirkpatrick's status as a confidential informant.

But Higginbotham wrote that Kirkpatrick's testimony was "critical to the State's case, providing the supporting evidence for the robbery, undercutting Holberg's account of self-defense, and painting her as an unremorseful addict who posed a continued threat to society."

The Supreme Court has recognized that witnesses "who are compensated for their testimony have acute incentive to lie," Higginbotham wrote.

He added the court has concluded that such testimony can be presented during trial only when their status as a paid information is disclosed. This is so that the jury can "weigh a witness's credibility" and that status "is subject to rigorous cross-examination, and the jury receives a clear instruction to be cautious when weighing such testimony."

Higginbotham added: "In light of Kirkpatrick's role as a key prosecution witness, one that supplied the State's only testimonial account of the violent encounter and the 'direct evidence' of the alleged robbery, 'there is no sound theory, considering the record as a whole, to support the conclusion that the evidence' of Kirkpatrick's suppressed status as a confidential informant did not reasonably affect Holberg's trial. The state court's finding of immateriality is an unreasonable application of clearly established Supreme Court law."

What People Are Saying

Higginbotham wrote in the ruling: "We pause only to acknowledge that 27 years on death row is a reality dimming the light that ought to attend proceedings where a life is at stake, a stark reminder that the jurisprudence of capital punishment remains a work in progress … Ms. Holberg's 27 years on death row is a showcase of the State's failure to abide by a core structure of prosecution: the Brady doctrine.

"There is a reason Brittany Marlowe Holberg has been on death row for over 27 years. The State denied her right to due process by keeping from the jury evidence favorable to the defendant, and this suppression prejudiced her case."

Judge Stuart Kyle Duncan, an appointee of President Donald Trump, wrote in a dissent: "No jury in its right mind would believe that a 23-year-old cocaine-addled prostitute 'defended' herself against a frail old man by (1) stabbing him 58 times, (2) bludgeoning him with various objects including a steam iron, and (3) ramming a lamp base down his throat while he was still alive."

Duncan said the evidence about Kirkpatrick was not 'material,' writing that "a wealth of other powerful evidence—evidence entirely unconnected to Kirkpatrick—obliterated Holberg's self-defense claim and proved she robbed Towery after killing him."

What Happens Next

The court vacated Holberg's murder conviction and death sentence, and sent the case back down to the district court to decide how to proceed.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines