10

Loading video...

Marni Rose McFall

By Marni Rose McFall

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The "lipstick index" refers to the idea that when times are tough financially, consumers turn to small, inexpensive luxuries like lipstick instead of pricier items.

The term was first introduced by Leonard Lauder, former chairman of Estée Lauder, who observed the trend after analyzing customers' behavior in the aftermath of the 9/11 terror attacks. Since then, it has been used as an informal economic indicator to gauge consumer confidence and spending behavior during recessions.

The U.S. economy has rebounded from the pandemic recession, but inflationary pressures and geopolitical events continue to impact the economic outlook ahead of the 2024 election.

Read More on News

Red lipstick

...

What is the Lipstick Index?

The lipstick index posits that lipstick sales rise during recessions as consumers cut back on big-ticket items but still seek small indulgences. Purchasing a lipstick or similar small luxury item can provide a psychological boost, helping people feel better about themselves in tough times.

According to Zubin Sethna, an author and expert in entrepreneurial marketing and consumer behavior, "the reliability of the lipstick index as a predictor of economic downturn is somewhat inconsistent."

He told Newsweek that accurate instances of the lipstick index occurred in the 2001 and then 2008/9 recessions where "there was an increase in sales of not only lipsticks but also other cosmetic products during this period, despite an overall decline in consumer spending. This supported the idea that consumers seek small luxuries during economic hardships."

However, Sethna explained, during the 2020 economic downturn "the cosmetic industry, including lipstick sales saw a significant decline. Factors such as mask mandates and reduced social activities contributed to this drop, indicating that the Lipstick [Index] may not apply uniformly across different types of economic crises."

Are There Other Informal Indexes to Watch?

Another prevalent index which is used as an informal economic indicator is the hemline index. This index suggests that there is a correlation between women's skirt lengths and economic performance, positing that during economic booms, hemlines rise, resulting in shorter skirts while during economic downturns, hemlines fall, leading to longer skirts. This concept was first introduced by economist George Taylor in the 1920s.

In recent years, this has been reflected in the work of Miuccia Prada, who is the head of both Prada and Miu Miu. Miu Miu has been the most popular fashion brand in the world for two-years running according to fashion-data platform Lyst. In 2021, the label released it viral ultra-mini skirt, but since the outset of the cost-of-living crisis, their collections have predominately shown midi skirts, favoring longer lengths in times of economic downturn.

Miu Miu miniskirt

...

However, Sethna describes that hemline index as "more anecdotal and culturally specific, lacking consistent empirical support. Its predictive power is limited and varies greatly based on fashion trends and cultural factors."

A similar metric is dubbed the Big Mac Index. This theory uses the price of a Big Mac in different countries to measure purchasing power parity and currency valuation.

Sethna argues that this theory is "more robust" than the hemline index. He explained that "the Big Mac Index is grounded in economic theory and provides a tangible measure of currency valuation and cost of living across countries."

Should You Pay Attention to These Indicators?

"Traditional economic indicators like GDP or unemployment rates might not capture these nuanced shifts in consumer spending habits," according to Sethna. "The lipstick index highlights how consumer seek emotional gratification and comfort through affordable luxuries, offering a perspective on consumer resilience and adaption strategies."

Sethna told Newsweek that "Each of these unusual indicators provides a unique perspective on economic conditions, but they all come with specific strengths and limitations." He explained that "The reliability and usefulness of these indicators depend on the context in which they are used and should ideally complement more traditional economic measures.

Sethna argued that "recessions often prompt a broader re-evaluation of spending habits, leading to increased price sensitivity, a heightened value on sustainability, ethical production, health and wellness, and a general shift toward more mindful consumption."

"Consumers tend to prioritize essentials, seek out deals, discounts, and second-hand options, and place a higher value on meaningful experiences over possessions."

What's Next

Amid economic uncertainties, the performance of cosmetic sales and other similar unusual indicators will be observed by analysts and consumers.

Sethna explained that "the dynamics of consumer behavior during economic downturns reveal nuanced ways individuals navigate financial constraints."

"In times of economic uncertainty, the allure of small indulgences often reflects the resilience of the human spirit."

Do you have a story we should be covering? Do you have any questions about the economy? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines