10

Loading video...

Andrew Stanton

By Andrew Stanton

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


More than a year into his papacy, Pope Leo XIV is facing a challenge that has tested modern pontiffs, demonstrating that the Catholic Church is serious about tackling abuse within its ranks.

Pope Leo addressed the issue of abuse during his general audience on Wednesday, describing preventing and countering abuse as “a way of living out evangelical conversion, starting by listening to those who have been hurt, calling evil by its name and embarking on paths of truth, justice and reconstruction.”

Abuse was a focus of his recent trip to South America, during which he met with survivors of clerical abuse in Peru. In remarks to reporters at the conclusion of his trip, he expressed the need for the church to address “spiritual abuse.”

Read More on News

“Spiritual abuse is a very serious topic in the church. It is being studied in the Vatican. There is not an immediate document as such to be published. Well, not yet,” he said. “But the concept itself, and the need to be able to address some of those issues canonically, is one of the problems.”

Clerical abuse remains a major issue facing the church. Investigations over several decades have uncovered widespread abuse allegations, as well as that church leaders failed to sufficiently address accusations of misconduct by thousands of priests across the globe.

Pope Leo XIV attends Mass as part of an official trip to Buenos Aires, Argentina, on November 9, 2026.

...

It’s a challenge the Catholic Church has been grappling with for years, and Pope Leo’s predecessors have sought to bring accountability for victims while navigating an institution that has historically faced accusations of prioritizing its own reputation over transparency.

The Pope has frequently addressed concerns around abuse and has met with victims throughout his tenure, but has faced scrutiny over how he handled misconduct allegations during his time as bishop.

The circumstances are different for Pope Leo, according to Daniel Rober, an associate professor and chair of Catholic studies at Sacred Heart University.

Rober said Pope Leo, formerly known as Robert Prevost, is the first pope who to have spent much of his previous ministry with clerical abuse as a major concern.

His predecessors had already risen to senior positions in the church by the time The Boston Globe published its landmark 2002 investigation into child sexual abuse by Catholic priests and cover-ups within the Archdiocese of Boston, Rober said.

Pope Leo’s Approach to Combating Abuse in the Catholic Church

Pope Leo has emphasized the need to listen to abuse survivors throughout his leadership.

He told the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors in March that prevention is “never just a set of protocols or procedures.”

“It is about helping to form, throughout the Church, a culture of care, in which the protection of minors and persons in vulnerable situations is not seen as an obligation imposed from outside, but as a natural expression of faith,” he said.

“It calls therefore for a process of conversion where the sufferings of others are heard and move us to take action.”

He also approved new statutes for the commission aimed at reinforcing “the Commission’s work in helping local Churches develop accessible reporting systems and listening centres,” the commission announced in June. The original statutes were issued under Pope Francis in 2015.

Most church bodies “have now instituted structures for reporting and responding,” Kevin Ahern, a professor of religious studies at Manhattan University, told Newsweek.

“And many have already worked out settlement,” he said. “But, now that the technical and legal side has been developed, there is the need to address the wider and deeper culture of power at work and that is where Leo is pointing us.”

His recent remarks on spiritual abuse suggest he is taking the issue seriously, Ahern said.

“Sexual and spiritual abuses are often tied together and wrapped up in cultures of power, clericalism and exploitation,” he said. “Pope Leo tried to address these deeper issues, which we might call cultures of sin within the church, by introducing a more dialogical, transparent and participatory way to operate the church with the synod on synodality.”

The Synod on Synodality was initiated under Pope Francis, with Leo continuing to support its implementation.

Institutional Powers Shape Church Response

Robert Orsi, a professor of history at Northwestern University, told Newsweek there is “always the impulse to protect the prerogatives and prestige of the church” and “to preserve its doctrinal and moral authority.” He said Pope Leo has “shown deep empathy and support for victims of sexual abuse within the church.”

“The Catholic Church is a global institution with great power, privilege, prestige, and property to protect, and much of the response to the suffering of victims of sexual abuse in the church has been constrained by the imperative to preserve these,” he said. “Pope Leo is deeply empathetic to victims, but he is also responsible for the institutional church.”

Orsi said lawyers have often influenced how church authorities respond to abuse allegations.

“Lawyers very often set the terms for how Catholic authorities responded to individual cases, and there was a fear that acknowledging the full extent of the harm done to victims was a legal liability,” he said.

“Pope Leo's honesty and frankness on the subject is a welcome and courageous change. He is admitting that ordained men are capable of doing profound harm to men, women, and children in their care, spiritual as well as psychological.”

Pope Leo Faces Scrutiny Over Past Abuse Cases

Leo faced skepticism from the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP) following his election as pope after the death of Pope Francis in 2025.

SNAP raised concerns about how he handled allegations of sexual misconduct during his ministry. His record on abuse cases has drawn both criticism and praise. In March 2025, SNAP filed a complaint against Prevost over his handling of allegations involving priests in Chicago and Peru.

In 2022, three women reported allegations of childhood sexual abuse by two priests to Prevost, then bishop of Chiclayo, Peru. They subsequently reported their allegations to civil authorities and accused Prevost of failing to adequately investigate their claims, according to SNAP.

The women alleged that he failed to open a preliminary investigation, notify civil authorities or adequately restrict the priests from ministry. The diocese maintained that one priest had been suspended and that the other was no longer active in ministry because of his age and health.

SNAP also alleged that Prevost, while serving as provincial of the Augustinian order in Chicago, approved an arrangement allowing James Ray, a priest accused of sexually abusing 13 minors, to live at the St. John Stone Augustinian Friary near an elementary school in Chicago's Hyde Park neighborhood from 2000 to 2002.

The Archdiocese of Chicago had been aware of allegations against Ray since at least 1990. Ray was subject to restrictions on his ministry, and the friary's prior had agreed to monitor his compliance with those restrictions.

SNAP alleged in its complaint that Prevost “was aware of the danger” Ray posed to minors when he approved the arrangement.

Rober described the pope’s record as one that “clearly reflects a ‘learning curve.’” Some of his actions have come under criticism but “hold up relatively well for the period,” he said.

He pointed to Prevost's time as bishop of Chiclayo, Peru, when he dealt with allegations involving the conservative Catholic organization Sodalitium Christianae Vitae (SCV), which faced accusations of sexual and spiritual abuse and was suppressed by the Vatican shortly before Prevost became pope.

“He took forthright action in this matter, arranging for Pope Francis to be filled in on the matter. The Sodalitium was ultimately suppressed just before the death of Pope Francis,” he said.

“As Prefect of the Congregation for Bishops, Prevost was also involved in the dismissal of multiple bishops involved in sexual abuse.”

How Pope Leo’s American Background Informs His Approach

Pope Leo is bringing an American perspective to the Vatican's approach to sexual-abuse cases, Rober said.

“Some of Leo's actions are quite consonant with those of his predecessors, but I think his forthrightness in naming broader issues of abuse in the church reflects both his American background as well as generational turnover within the church,” he said.

Pope Leo “has basically continued the two-pronged**—pastoral and procedural—**approach used by Popes Francis and Benedict,” Michele Dillon, a professor of sociology at the University of New Hampshire, told Newsweek.

The Vatican has continued honing guidelines for safeguarding people and supporting victims, “while also respecting the rights and due process of those alleged to have committed abuse,” she said.

“Getting these procedures right**—morally, pastorally, and legally—**is a challenge for the Vatican,” she said. “Despite impressive progress since 2002, there is unevenness in their formal articulation as well as in their practical implementation across the whole church.”

His experience in Peru and upbringing in the United States have given Pope Leo “good understanding of the on-the-ground diversity of the global church and how local culture impacts how child sex abuse is understood,” according to Dillon.

What Happens Next

Addressing sexual abuse is expected to remain a major priority for Pope Leo in the coming years. Rober said the most important thing for him is to “regularize the set of practices he has discreetly implemented on his own.”

SNAP has urged Pope Leo to introduce “concrete safeguards” to protect the faithful from clerical sexual abuse, including a policy requiring the immediate removal from ministry of clergy facing sexual abuse allegations and greater accountability for church leaders who have covered up abuse.

“SNAP demands that the pope do more than simply offer empty platitudes to survivors,” SNAP executive director Angela Walker said in a statement earlier in November. “Survivors have lived with the trauma of their abuse often for decades, causing a lifetime of agony.”

Orsi stressed that the sexual-abuse crisis is not over.

“It was not somehow a product of one period of history—from the earliest days of the church to the present, the danger of sexual and spiritual abuse by ordained men has been recognized in the church itself,” he said.

“Better to say that abuse is an ongoing danger in Catholicism—in all religions, for that matter—and figure out ways of living with the danger than that the problem has been solved once and for all.”

Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Samantha Beech and Rhian Morgan.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines