
Getty Images

By Alex J. Rouhandeh
National Political Correspondent
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Inside a sun-drenched dining room within the Montclare Senior Residences on Chicago’s Southside, JB Pritzker, the billionaire governor of Illinois with eyes on a Democratic presidential nomination in 2028, appeared before a crowd of Black elders ahead of last month’s primary elections. Beside him stood Illinois Lieutenant Governor Juliana Stratton, his endorsed candidate for the U.S. Senate.
“We need to send somebody to Washington on our behalf who’s a fighter,” Pritzker said to applause. Though cellphones went off more than six times during the morning’s speeches, the crowd watched attentively. “I want to introduce you to our next United States Senator, Juliana Stratton.” Further applause echoed through the room as Stratton, wearing a necklace that read “persist,” walked to the center of the room. “I am running for United States Senate because I want to take your voices to Washington. I want to fight for those of you in this room,” she said.
Speaking to Newsweek afterward, Stratton—who would go on to win—said, “When I ask people, ‘What are you looking for?’ they don’t always come to a policy conclusion. They say, ‘I’m looking for someone to go to the mat fighting for me,’ so first and foremost, that’s my key responsibility, to fight for the people of Illinois.”
Read More on Politics

...
That word—fighter—appeared everywhere in Illinois’ Democratic primaries this cycle. It was on the lips of every candidate, in every district, at every level. But not every fighter won. The results of the federal-level primaries, a significant portion of them to fill seats vacated by retiring incumbents, sorted the Democratic Party into three legible camps: an Activist Left that ran on movement energy and small-dollar donations; a Technocratic Center that ran on institutional relationships and corporate money; and a Progressive Establishment that split the difference—credentialed insiders who refused corporate cash and campaigned like fighters. One of those camps won decisively.
“As you think about the next presidential election, I don’t know that Democratic Party primary voters are as far to [the] left as people think they are, and I think the results in Illinois reinforce that,” Doug Sosnik, political director for President Bill Clinton’s White House, told Newsweek. “I think [Illinois’ result] reinforces the notion that you really should be somewhat measured.”
Next January, Senator Dick Durbin, 81, will be exiting the Senate after 30 years in the upper chamber, over 20 of them as Democratic Whip, making him Chuck Schumer’s second in command. Retiring alongside him in Illinois are four House Democrats holding political decades of top Democratic positions on powerful subcommittees—attained in part through their seniority in firmly blue districts in one of the party’s most important strongholds.
Given Illinois’ standing in the Democratic firmament—it’s the fourth largest state for Democratic donors, behind California, New York and Washington, D.C. according to Open Secrets—and the significance of those retirements, how the party voted this election could predict which course it takes in 2028, when Democrats will be tasked with choosing a standard-bearer to challenge MAGA in the post-Donald Trump era. Two years after Kamala Harris’ defeat, the Democratic Party remains without a cohesive identity, as the 2024 loss uncrowned its established leadership without anointing heirs. If the primary results indicate anything, it’s that the credentialed Progressive Establishment, who’ve embraced the label of fighter, could be poised to seize the role of heir apparent.

Getty Images
Mapping the Party
To understand who won and why, it helps to map the ideological terrain. The three camps competed across Illinois’ open primaries with different theories of what the Democratic Party should be and how it should fight. The results were not evenly distributed.
This map roughly mirrored that of intra-party factions in the U.S. House of Representatives. There, Democratic lawmakers can join three ideological caucuses: the Congressional Progressive Caucus, the New Democrat Coalition and the Blue Dog Coalition. The CPC, with nearly 100 members, is the most liberal; the NDC, with 115, occupies the center-left; the Blue Dogs, with just 10 members, represent the party’s conservative flank.
“I think these things bleed over a little bit, but, generally speaking, some of the winners [of Illinois’ 2026 primaries] definitely represented the left edge of the possible,” David Dayen, executive editor of The American Prospect, a bimonthly progressive magazine, told Newsweek.
On the Activist Left, the theory is confrontation without qualification. The system is broken and the party has enabled its failure; the answer is organizing, movement-building and nominating candidates who look and speak like the streets rather than a congressional cloakroom. These campaigns run on small-dollar donations, treat their offices as mutual aid infrastructure and measure success as much in cultural resonance as electoral math.

...
When entering the campaign office of Kat Abughazaleh, one is not to hang their coat at the front rack. After this reporter presumptively hung his coat amongst the others, he was told by a volunteer, “Those are actually there for our clothing drive. If you hang it there, someone may take it.”
Beyond the racks, a skeleton at least 10-feet tall looms in the office’s center. Yellow walls are plastered with artwork and vintage-inspired campaign posters reading messages like “Resist Fascism! Liberation Now!!!” Presiding from a stuffed orange couch sits Abughazaleh, the then-26-year-old former Media Matters reporter turned influencer and activist who dared to challenge the district’s beloved 14-term Representative Jan Schakowsky in March 2025.
“I’m the antifascist candidate,” Abughazaleh told Newsweek when asked if she saw herself as representing the antiestablishment wing. “As far as the tear-it-all-down thing, I mean, the status quo wasn’t working. It does need to be totally changed, but we don’t need to tear it down. Trump is already doing that.”
Creating a ‘Third Space’
Abughazaleh campaigned to the left of progressive 9th District opponent Evanston Mayor Daniel Biss—who ultimately won—branding herself in video ads as a fighter “who will stand up to ICE, tell white supremacists to screw off, who will fight for an economy that works for the people and not billionaires.” With over 320,000 followers on Instagram and 350,000 on TikTok, Abughazaleh leveraged her platform to become the race’s top fundraiser, taking in over $3 million via over 57,000 grassroots donors.
She utilized those dollars in an unconventional way. Using her office as a mutual aid hub, she said, her team had fed and clothed thousands of people in the district. Volunteers gathered for knitting circles to make clothes for the needy, and Abughazaleh said they’ve had two different mosh pits at campaign events. The campaign became a true “third space,” 29-year-old volunteer Mia Orlando told Newsweek.
In Illinois’ 7th District, this community-centric approach to leftist campaigning rematerialized in Anthony Driver Jr. and Kina Collins, both of whom have backgrounds in community organizing. In that race, they ultimately split the left-flank vote, clearing the path for state Representative La Shawn Ford, the favored candidate of the Progressive Establishment who was endorsed by the district’s incumbent Danny Davis.
At the other end, the Technocratic Center offered a different theory of the party: Governance is complex, Washington is transactional and the candidate with the deepest institutional relationships and most sophisticated policy fluency is best equipped to deliver results. The problem, in the Trump era, is that the Democratic base doesn’t primarily want results. It wants a fight.
Despite raising over $30 million for his Senate run compared with Stratton’s over $4 million, Representative Raja Krishnamoorthi, who has served Illinois’ 8th Congressional District since 2017, said he felt like the outsider in this race. A member of the New Democrat Coalition, he attained far less support from elected politicians.
Speaking to Newsweek before the election, Krishnamoorthi said that he would draw on his entrepreneurial mindset to address technological challenges of the 21st century, differentiating him from his peers. “I am not the establishment candidate,” he said, “and I don’t think I ever came out of that even when I first ran for office.”

...
Robin Kelly—the third contender in the Senate race, who raised $3 million—perhaps fits least neatly into this category but offered a variation of the profile, particularly when it came to her campaign’s emphasis on Washington relationships. Though she held the endorsement of three of the four founding members of “the Squad,” including Michigan Representative Rashida Tlaib and Minnesota Representative Ilhan Omar, her campaign was also firmly linked to the Washington establishment, with endorsements from former Democratic House Whip Jim Clyburn and the Congressional Black Caucus.
Kelly’s campaign relied on corporate PAC money, and the progressive credentialing couldn’t paper over that structural liability. High-profile leftist endorsements don’t transfer cleanly to candidates who take corporate checks. The base has learned to read the funding architecture, not just the endorsement list.
In Illinois’ 9th District, this faction was represented by State Senator Laura Fine. Endorsed by the New Democrat Coalition Chair, Representative Brad Schneider of Illinois, Fine accepted corporate PAC money and was the favored candidate of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, a pro-Israel lobbying group that has become a boogeyman of the progressive left. AIPAC’s preferred candidate in the Illinois 7th race was Chicago City Treasurer Melissa Conyears-Ervin, an MBA whose campaign emphasized her financial acumen.

...
Insiders Who Speak Like Outsiders
The third camp—the one that won—doesn’t resolve easily into the familiar left-versus-center binary. Its candidates are credentialed insiders who speak like outsiders, academically trained technocrats who campaign as fighters, institutionally backed progressives who reject corporate money. It’s a new hybrid: call it the Progressive Establishment. Its intellectual lineage runs directly through Senator Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts.
“I transitioned from being an academic to a candidate for office through organizing and activism,” Biss, who ran in the 9th District, told Newsweek. “Simultaneously, I think people are looking around at government and saying, ‘Hey, it sucks.’ There’s a lot of well-intentioned people who seem to not be able to make a lot of change…. So, it was just a matter of making sure that we were sharing both sides of my personality and record.”
Before getting into politics, Biss was a professor at the University of Chicago, a similar background to his endorser Warren, although she taught law at Harvard University while he taught mathematics. Stratton also went to law school, working as an administrative law judge for several government agencies. Many of Warren’s protégés filled the top ranks of the Biden administration and implemented an expansive policy agenda that surprised those who viewed the former president as a staunch moderate. Deep technical expertise paired with activism and fiery language has proven potent in the era of President Donald Trump. As his administration has made battles with America’s top universities a priority of its culture war, college campuses have become an ever-fertile breeding ground for the left. However, in Democratic politics, voters and party insiders have been loathe to allow the activist student to supplant the activist professor.

...
Intramural Maneuvers
While the clashes between the three camps played out differently across the ballot, this election’s results told a consistent story: Nuance beat purity on the left, and fighter beat dealmaker in the center. The Israel-Palestine conflict was a prominent test case of that theory, particularly in the race to represent Illinois’ 9th District, which is nearly 12 percent Jewish. AIPAC spent heavily against both Biss and Abughazaleh in favor of Fine. Yet Biss, a Jewish liberal Zionist, and Abughazaleh, a Palestinian American who wants to cut off Israel’s military aid, still found themselves in conflict. Biss allied with like-minded interest groups, like the pro-two state solution group J Street, to back his campaign and leveraged his stance to gain a strategic edge over his opponent.
“People who were between myself and Kat saw that I had a nuanced position on the question of Israel and Palestine, and they saw that Kat took a position that was more hard line,” Biss said. “I believe to my core that the background and experiences and nuance that I bring to this issue will make me a deeply effective fighter for justice for Palestine, but we had to have some complicated conversations with voters”
Whilst Abughazaleh was on the rise, Fine was declining, and Biss said he drew in her supporters once they realized Abughazaleh could win the race. Amid this dynamic, Skokie school board member Bushra Amiwala, also critical of Israel, was amplified by AIPAC-aligned groups—which her campaign said was meant to harm her reputation—helping her secure 5 percent of the vote that might have otherwise gone to Abughazaleh. Biss, endorsed by Schakowsky, beat Abughazaleh by over 3.5 points—a margin that reflected the ceiling of the activist-left coalition when faced with a credentialed progressive running a more institutionally anchored campaign. The gap between them wasn’t ideological distance so much as institutional mass.
At Abughazaleh’s election night party, a supporter told Newsweek she was unimpressed by Biss securing the endorsement of Warren. Her reasoning: “She’s a center-right Democrat.”
In the 7th District, dynamics played out similarly as Conyears-Ervin placed second while the activist lane was split between Driver Jr. and Collins, allowing Ford—endorsed by Illinois’ state House Speaker Emanuel “Chris” Welch and State Senate Majority Leader Kimberly Lightford—to pull ahead.

...
Nuance Within Limits
Stratton beat Krishnamoorthi by seven points, despite trailing in most polls ahead of election day and losing the fundraising battle. Endorsed by Warren and committed to opposing Schumer if he seeks another term as the upper chamber’s top Democrat, Stratton will head to Washington with a disposition that’s sure to appeal to the party’s aggrieved base that’s become discontented with figures like the man she’ll be replacing.
Like Krishnamoorthi, Kelly’s reliance on corporate PAC money proved a key differentiator between her and Stratton, who refused such donations. Stratton’s campaign was backed by Pritzker and his family fortune made through the Hyatt Hotels Corporation. She made this difference a campaign issue as she pledged to take on the wealthy, picking up the backing of Illinois’ incumbent Senator Tammy Duckworth as well as Welch and Lightford in the process.
State party dynamics were also swirling in the background. When Pritzker was running for governor in 2018, Kelly endorsed Biss, who went on to lose to Pritzker. In 2021, Kelly became chair of the Democratic Party of Illinois, with the support of Durbin despite Pritzker backing a different candidate. However, a little over a year later, Kelly dropped her reelection bid after concluding that her opponent, Elizabeth Hernandez—who was backed by Pritzker—had more support. Hernandez remains chair to this day.
“It was on him,” Kelly told Newsweek. “I know people wanted me to win, but for their various reasons, they chose not to vote for me, so I stepped back so the people that were out there voting for me, they didn’t have to feel the pressure that I know some of them were getting.” Kelly suggested Pritzker’s wealth gives him a greater influence over the Illinois Democratic Party than a governor would normally have. “I know in my race, people have kept their mouth shut,” Kelly said. “They think it’s better for them, even if someone hasn’t specifically whispered in their ear.”

...
Fights Remaining
DDespite the wins of Stratton, Biss and Ford, the Progressive Establishment’s night wasn’t a complete victory. Former Representative Melissa Bean won the 8th District primary for her old House seat with AIPAC support, beating Warren’s endorsed candidate, nonprofit executive Junaid Ahmed. Bean fits the Technocratic Center mold and had the support of New Democrat Coalition Chair Schneider, yet it’s notable her victory came with a Duckworth endorsement and a bio noting her ability to “fight for what matters.”
Donna Miller, who won in the 2nd District with the backing of Schneider and AIPAC despite facing a Warren-endorsed challenger in State Senator Robert Peters, also leaned into the fighter moniker, using the word three times on her campaign bio page alone.
The rhetorical capture of fighter as the Democratic default is now virtually complete, with candidates across the Democratic spectrum emphasizing the moniker, no matter their ideology and governance style. Yet, while Democratic voters want a fighter, they appeared less interested in one focused on fighting against an establishment that has become increasingly rooted in Elizabeth Warren-style progressivism.
The combination of the Biss and Ford victories, in addition to the win by Stratton, paint a nuanced picture of what the Democratic base may be seeking in its future candidates. Both Biss and Ford faced antiestablishment candidates to their left who failed to gain traction. Meanwhile, Stratton bested Krishnamoorthi and Kelly, who hold deeper ties to Washington and the business community. The ideological sweet spot that resonated wasn’t simply left of center. It was a specific formula: credentials that signal competence, rhetoric that signals combat and funding architecture that keeps the corporate taint off their brand. Candidates who had two of the three won. Those with just one, lost.

...
Purity and Compromise
Progressivism comes in different flavors, yet it’s clear the kind that won in Illinois embraces an experienced, technocratic approach to governance, which accounts for the institutions, paired with the words of a fighter and the media persona to match.
Many of these individuals come from backgrounds in academia and governance and run campaigns that take an adversarial approach to the billionaire class. With the top one percent holding over 30 percent of America’s wealth, this message has value. Yet, in a post-Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission era, where campaigns are marked by multimillion-dollar spending, how to fund a campaign always remains a question.
If one relies on small-dollar donors and activists like Abughazaleh, they may neglect the institutional backing and interest group support that propelled a candidate like Biss. If one relies on corporate donors like Krishnamoorthi and Kelly, they may face the accusations of being beholden to big business that Stratton evaded by relying on the personal wealth of Pritzker. If one relies on a benevolent billionaire backer, well: “Dare to dream that we ever live in a time when the Illinois Democratic Party and the Cook County Democratic Party are not the personal fiefdom of one person,” former Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot, a backer of Kelly, told Newsweek. “We are losing a lot of institutional knowledge when [Durbin] steps down.”
That’s the unresolved tension at the heart of the Progressive Establishment’s emerging coalition: it campaigns against the billionaire class while depending, structurally, on a specific kind of wealth. And while Illinois showed progressives can resolve the tensions between costly campaigns and independence from corporations, there may be no Pritzker available at presidential scale in 2028—and no obvious answer to the question of how a credentialed insurgency gets capitalized.
In the era of Trump, a Democrat must be a fighter. A brand centered around working with Republicans and cutting deals with the private sector doesn’t jive well with that. However, as an increasingly college-educated party, it’s clear the Democratic base values knowledge and experience. Pair that with a fighter’s rhetoric, and one may just secure their seat within the Progressive Caucus or even the presidential nomination come 2028.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines