
...

By Lydia Patrick
Life & Trends Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
What a woman found in her boyfriend’s belongings has shocked the internet.
Redditor u/Ill-Eye7586 shared a romantic card she discovered that had been sent to her partner by another woman. The post gained over 18,000 upvotes in the subreddit Am I Overreacting.
"He says this was just a thank you for him sending her those things…. I’m just like- you must think I’m an idiot. But I must ask, am I overreacting? I said that this is completely inappropriate, and not in any way friend like on either part," she wrote.
Read More on Life
The card, which was addressed to her boyfriend, wished him a happy Valentine’s Day, thanked him for a package, and said she was “enjoying my hoodies this winter (although they took so long to get here, I can smell you on them).” The sender went on to say she hoped to see him soon, missed his face, and hoped he would play her music and tattoo her sometime in the future.
In her post, the OP explained that this was her first time ever posting on Reddit despite being a long-time lurker. She said her boyfriend swore that the sender was “just a friend” and that they had met over several years of attending a particular metal Christmas festival.
According to him, he sent her hoodies—sprayed with his cologne at her request—for her and her father, along with a case of Costco-exclusive protein shakes that she could not find in Florida, where she lives. He insisted that the card was simply a thank-you note for his generosity, but the OP told Reddit she still found the gesture “completely inappropriate.”

...
Expert Insight
Sandra Myers, president and co-founder of Select Date Society, said the Redditor’s reaction was valid, adding that when a partner’s actions threaten trust, it’s reasonable to feel upset and request a change in behavior.
"A healthy relationship requires trust, boundaries, and honest communication. It's not about forbidding friendships, but about ensuring that those friendships don't erode the trust between the two of you," she told Newsweek.
Licensed Clinical Social Worker Anat Joseph agreed, noting that gestures like sending scented clothing blur platonic boundaries and can understandably make a partner uncomfortable.
"The romantic partner is absolutely valid in her feelings. If something in the dynamic feels disrespectful, overly intimate, or creates insecurity, those emotions deserve acknowledgment. What matters is not whether the behavior was 'technically just friendship' but whether it honors or undermines the trust in the committed relationship," Joseph told Newsweek.
She recommended calmly explaining why the behavior feels inappropriate and setting clear boundaries moving forward.
Reddit’s Response
Commenters on the post had strong opinions.
"‘I’ll be good in the meantime’ is all you need to know. They’ve been bad together," wrote one user.
"NOR. Even if 'nothing' ever happened between them, him allowing this behavior and feeding into it is a giant red flag and would not be acceptable.
How would he feel if some guy sent you a card like this, saying he misses how you smell, misses seeing you, and asks for you to send him clothing spritzed in your perfume?" shared another Redditor.
"Yeah, but how would he feel about you actually complying to another man’s request to send clothes spritzed to smell like you? It’s not about the woman’s card—it’s about his actions," added another commenter.
Newsweek reached out to u/Ill-Eye7586 for comment via Reddit. We could not verify the details of the case.
Newsweek's "What Should I Do?" offers expert advice to readers. If you have a personal dilemma, let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice on relationships, family, friends, money and work and your story could be featured on WSID at Newsweek.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines