
...

By Soo Kim
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A viral post has sparked widespread discussion on Reddit after a worker shared their boss refused to accept their two weeks' notice of resignation—even though the employee had no contractual obligation to stay.
The incident was detailed in a post on Reddit titled "My Boss didn't accept my two weeks notice." It was shared by u/BeerPowered in the r/antiwork subreddit, where it garnered more than 13,000 upvotes and hundreds of comments since it was posted on June 4.
"I got an offer that's too good to pass up. Better pay, better benefits, the whole package," the poster wrote. "I scheduled a meeting with my boss to give my two weeks' notice. Went in professional, thanked him for the opportunities, explained I found a great opportunity elsewhere. Pretty standard stuff, right?"
Read More on Work
But the response from the boss was anything but typical.
"He literally said 'No, I don't accept your resignation,'" the poster wrote. "Like … what? I thought he was joking at first, but he was dead serious. Started going on about how I'm under contract (I'm not), how I'm abandoning the team during a crucial project (we're always in a crucial project apparently), and how he's 'not going to let me leave.'"

...
"I'm in an at-will state so I'm pretty sure he can't actually force me to stay, but the threats about blacklisting me have me a bit concerned," the poster wrote. At-will employment refers to when both the employee and employer maintain a working relationship for as long as it suits both parties. So, if one is no longer happy with the arrangement, they can terminate it without any justification needed.
Employment law experts told Newsweek the poster was fully within their rights to resign and that the boss's response was inappropriate.
"Unless the employee has a contract that states otherwise, they can resign voluntarily at any time for any reason," employment lawyer Mary Goodrich Nix, a partner at Lynn Pinker Hurst & Schwegmann in Dallas, Texas, told Newsweek. "No obligation to provide a two-week notice—or any notice—unless contractually required."
She added that, while some states have employer requirements even when an employee is not under contract, "I'm not aware of any state requiring an at-will employee to stay working at an employer they no longer wish to work for."
Millions of workers across the U.S. continue to quit their jobs. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) said that 3.2 million people quit their jobs in April.
"In April, the number and rate of quits were little changed at 3.2 million and 2 percent, respectively and the number of quits was down by 220,000 over the year," the BLS reported. The agency notes that "quits are generally voluntary separations initiated by the employee. Therefore, the quits rate can serve as a measure of workers' willingness or ability to leave jobs."
'The Whole Thing Was Surreal'
The worker in the Reddit post said that they attempted to clarify that giving two weeks' notice is a professional courtesy, not a request for permission. "He got more agitated and said if I don't show up next week, he'll consider it job abandonment and make sure I never work in this industry again," the poster wrote. "The whole thing was surreal."
The poster added that they plan to start their new job in two weeks as planned, having already signed the offer letter. But the incident left them questioning whether they had done anything wrong and whether they should be concerned about legal repercussions.
Michael Goldfarb, an employment attorney and CEO of Guardian HR, told Newsweek that the scenario described in the Reddit post is not uncommon.
"This is a scenario that happens all the time, and it's exactly why we have the concept of at-will employment—so that an employee can quit at any time and an employer can terminate an employee at any time, as long as it's on a legal basis," Goldfarb added*.*
He said the poster was "absolutely correct in noting that the two weeks' notice offered was a courtesy—not a request."
Goldfarb also criticized the boss' reported threat to blacklist the employee. "That is wholly unacceptable and could potentially expose them to a defamation claim, among other possible legal actions," he said. "No employer has the right to force someone to continue working against their will."
Goldfarb recommended that the employee document the meeting in writing and notify the employer that "if any steps are taken to interfere with the ability to secure future employment—such as defaming character—all legal remedies available will be pursued."
'Insane'
Reddit users responding to the post expressed strong support for the worker.
"Dude's delusional. You gave notice, you're done in two weeks. Document everything and just show up for your last day," wrote u/sweetmercy97. "He can't force you to stay and those threats are empty at will goes both ways."
Another commenter, u/MissAnth, posted: "No, you didn't do anything wrong. You just work for an insane person. Did you do this in writing as well? You need to, and send it not only to your boss, but to his boss and to HR."
U/DoNotCommentorReply wrote: "People are absolutely insane when it comes to getting what they want. OP [original poster] leaving makes things harder for the boss, so boss is just deciding to be a piece of s*** thinking that'll make things better."
"I'm starting my new job in two weeks regardless," the original poster wrote. "Already signed the offer letter and everything."
Newsweek has contacted the original poster for comment via the Reddit messaging system.
Do you have a similar story or dilemma to share? Let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice, and your story could be featured on Newsweek.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines