Laphonza Butler's Non-California Residence Raises Questions

California Governor Gavin Newsom's pick to replace recently deceased Democratic senator Diane Feinstein has raised eyebrows after it emerged that she resided with her family in Maryland until recently.

Late on Sunday night, his office announced he had chosen Laphonza Butler, president of EMILY's List, which works to elect women in favor of abortion rights to public office, to fulfill the remainder of the late senator's term. Feinstein died, aged 90, on Thursday following a period of ill health.

"A trusted adviser to [Vice President Kamala] Harris and leader of the nation's largest organization dedicated to electing women, Butler will make history as the first Black lesbian to openly serve in Congress," Newsom's office said.

California law permits the governor to appoint a senator until the next election, due to take place in 2024. Butler previously worked in California on the presidential campaigns of Harris and Hillary Clinton.

Laphonza Butler
EMILY's List President Laphonza Butler addresses a Biden-Harris campaign rally at the Mayflower Hotel on June 23, 2023 in Washington D.C. On Sunday, she was named as Dianne Feinstein's successor in the U.S. Senate. Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

However, questions have been raised over the choice after mention of Butler's residence in Maryland was scrubbed from her biography on the EMILY's List website. Archives of the site show it was still mentioned as recently as September 14, but now appears to have been deleted.

Rob Pyers, research director of the California Target Book, which analyzes political finance filings, noted Butler had given her residence in Silver Spring, Maryland, on Federal Election Commission (FEC) filings as recently as August 31.

Lists of her contributions recorded by the FEC and the California Fair Political Practices Commission, shared by Pyers, suggest she has been living in Maryland since September 2021. Prior to that, she gave addresses in View Park, a suburb of Los Angeles.

"Butler is a longtime California resident and homeowner," Izzy Gardon, deputy director of communications for Newsom's office, told Newsweek. "She moved to the D.C. area when she became president of EMILY's List. Butler will re-register here before being sworn in."

A spokesperson for Butler told Newsweek that she "has been a California homeowner since 2011 and has reregistered to vote in California."

Social media users appeared split over what some said as a case of "carpetbagging," an accusation of campaigning for election in an area where the candidate has no ties.

"Owning a home and residency are two different things," wrote one X, formerly Twitter, user, while another described the news as "not okay." However, others portrayed it as a "non-story" and credited Newsom for being "honest and unapologetic."

"This week Laphonza is focused on respecting and honoring Sen. Feinstein's legacy and getting ready to serve the people of California in the Senate," the spokesperson for Butler said. "Politics can wait."

Butler's ascension to the Senate could also upturn the Democratic race for the seat in 2024. While Politico, which originally broke the news, cited Newsom's office as saying the pick did not put limitations or preconditions on who he thought should run, the decision will make Butler the incumbent and likely key contender if she chooses to stand for a full term.

Among the California Democratic names to have launched campaigns for the seat when Feinstein announced her intention not to run for another term in February are Representatives Adam Schiff, Katie Porter and Barbara Lee.

Just hours before the appointment of Butler was announced, the Congressional Black Caucus had written to Newsom urging him to appoint Lee.

Update 10/02/23, 10:45 a.m. ET: This article was updated to include comment from Newsom's office.

Update 10/03/23, 3:01 a.m. ET: This article was updated to include comment from a spokesperson for Laphonza Butler.

Uncommon Knowledge

Newsweek is committed to challenging conventional wisdom and finding connections in the search for common ground.

Newsweek is committed to challenging conventional wisdom and finding connections in the search for common ground.

About the writer


Aleks Phillips is a Newsweek U.S. News Reporter based in London. His focus is on U.S. politics and the environment. ... Read more

To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, Click here.
Newsweek cover
  • Newsweek magazine delivered to your door
  • Newsweek Voices: Diverse audio opinions
  • Enjoy ad-free browsing on Newsweek.com
  • Comment on articles
  • Newsweek app updates on-the-go
Newsweek cover
  • Newsweek Voices: Diverse audio opinions
  • Enjoy ad-free browsing on Newsweek.com
  • Comment on articles
  • Newsweek app updates on-the-go