Neil Gorsuch portrait

...

Jenna Sundel

By Jenna Sundel

News Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Justice Neil Gorsuch broke from the Supreme Court majority on Friday on a decision about whether the failure to act can still be considered a violent crime.

The Court found that knowingly and intentionally causing injury or death, "whether by act or omission, involves the use of physical force against another person."

Gorsuch voiced his disapproval of the majority's decision in a dissent joined by Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson.

Read More

Can Judge James Boasberg Be Impeached? How Process Works as GOP Push Grows6 min read

Can Judge James Boasberg Be Impeached? How Process Works as GOP Push Grows

Videos of Bernie Sanders and AOC Rally Crowd Sizes Take Off Online6 min read

Videos of Bernie Sanders and AOC Rally Crowd Sizes Take Off Online

UK Lawmaker Reacts to Trump Suggesting US Could Join British Commonwealth4 min read

UK Lawmaker Reacts to Trump Suggesting US Could Join British Commonwealth

"By looking to the common law today, the Court produces a serious misfit," Gorsuch wrote.

Why It Matters

The disagreement between the majority and the dissenting justices centers around Congress' definition of a "crime of violence." The majority said the statute "has long been understood to incorporate liability for both act and omission."

Gorsuch, however, accused the Court of resorting to "conjecture about implicit congressional purposes."

What To Know

Salvatore Delligatti was convicted of attempted murder and other crimes in 2018. An additional five years were added to his prison sentence for using a gun during a crime of violence.

Delligatti is an associate of the Genovese crime family, according to the Court filing.

Delligatti moved to dismiss the crime of violence charge, arguing that his actions did not meet the requirements of the charge. He was accused of recruiting gang members to kill a suspected police informant and giving them a loaded revolver.

The Court found that the law makes no exception when an offender causes bodily harm by omission rather than action.

"Deliberately causing injury necessarily involves the use of force in the sense relevant here," Justice Clarence Thomas wrote in the majority opinion.

Neil Gorsuch portrait

...

Gorsuch uses an analogy to open his dissent.

"Imagine a lifeguard perched on his chair at the beach who spots a swimmer struggling against the waves," Gorsuch said. "Instead of leaping into action, the lifeguard chooses to settle back in his chair, twirl his whistle, and watch the swimmer slip away. The lifeguard may know that his inaction will cause death. Perhaps the swimmer is the lifeguard's enemy and the lifeguard even wishes to see him die."

He said that while this action makes the lifeguard "a bad man," it does not necessarily qualify as a crime of violence.

"The Court thinks so. I do not," Gorsuch wrote.

Gorsuch said the Court reached a "wrong destination because it takes a wrong turn at the start." He said the majority failed to examine legislation, instead focusing on legal precedent and "assumptions about congressional purposes."

How Many Supreme Court Justices Are There?

There are nine Supreme Court justices. The current justices are Chief Justice John Roberts and Associate Justices Neil Gorsuch, Ketanji Brown Jackson, Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, Elena Kagan, Sonia Sotomayor, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett.

Who Appointed Neil Gorsuch to the Supreme Court?

Gorsuch was appointed to the Supreme Court by President Donald Trump in 2017.

What People Are Saying

Justice Clarence Thomas, in the Court's majority opinion: "Whenever an offender deliberately causes bodily harm by omission, he necessarily makes another person the conscious object of physical force."

Justice Neil Gorsuch, in his dissent: "As this Court has often explained, when Congress takes the trouble to supply an express definition, we are obliged to treat it as 'virtually conclusive,' even—and perhaps especially—if it "varies" from what we might otherwise understand (or wish) the definition to be."

What Happens Next

The Court upheld Delligatti's sentence. He is serving 25 years in prison.

Do you have a story that Newsweek should be covering? Do you have any questions about this story? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines