
...

By John Feng
China Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
When a Chinese biotech firm challenged a Pentagon blacklist in an American court and won a preliminary injunction, it exposed a soft spot in U.S. armor: the institutions at the heart of its political system can protect its adversaries, too.
The U.S. Defense Department had determined that WuXi AppTec, a major pharmaceutical contractor headquartered in Shanghai, was helping to support China’s military modernization and sought to place restrictions on the company. A federal judge blocked the effort.
The ruling was a blow to the Pentagon’s attempts to weaken China’s policy of military-civil fusion—a national strategy designed to channel civilian technological advances into military development.
Read More on World
The asymmetry extends far beyond one biotech company. From sanctions and tariffs to intellectual property and national security cases, Washington is competing against an authoritarian rival while remaining constrained by courts, due process and rules that its rival is under no obligation to reciprocate.

...
The Blacklist Challenge
The latest example follows the Pentagon determining in June that WuXi AppTec was one of 188 entities believed to support China’s efforts to modernize its military. The list also included e-commerce giant Alibaba, electric carmaker BYD and robotics firm Unitree for the first time.
WuXi AppTec’s inclusion on the Section 1260H watch list of “Chinese military companies”—a Pentagon designation created by Congress—meant the U.S. military could no longer do business with it, and the restrictions would extend to third-party suppliers next year.
But James Boasberg, chief judge at the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, who has previously clashed with the Trump administration over deportation flights, said the Defense Department lacked evidence to support its designation of the firm, which earned 72 percent of its revenue last year—some $4.6 billion—from U.S. clients.
The court concluded that the department had misrepresented a portfolio investment in the company as ownership by the Aviation Industry Corporation of China, the state-owned manufacturer of Chinese military aircraft and jet engines.
It made WuXi AppTec the latest Chinese company to defeat one arm of the U.S. government with help from another.
“It’s a testament to the strength and fairness of the US court system that a Chinese company can sue the US government—and win,” Kyle Chan, a fellow at the Brookings Institution’s John L. Thornton China Center, posted on X.
Related Story

Why Wang Wang Should Worry Xi Jinping
Different Rulebooks
President Donald Trump has had his fair share of knockbacks from U.S. courts, including failed attempts in 2020 to ban TikTok and the Chinese messaging app WeChat.
A year later, the Pentagon’s blacklisting of electronics company Xiaomi and geospatial data firm Luokung Technology was also struck down by the U.S. legal system.
In February, the U.S. Supreme Court stood in the way of Trump’s use of emergency powers to impose tariffs worldwide, and principally against China, to compel favorable trade negotiations. His administration has since pivoted to new Section 301 tariffs—a trade-law mechanism used to address unfair practices—justified by alleged forced labor practices, but those too can be challenged if the standard of proof is not met.
“One of western democracies’ potentially fatal flaws is the tendency to prize process above outcomes (and some would say above common sense),” James A. Lewis, a senior adviser at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, said in a post about WuXi AppTec’s federal court win.
Words like oversight, due process and the burden of proof are unlikely to bother the leaders of China’s long-ruling Communist Party, who already view American-style democracy as uncontrolled chaos and see government transparency and public accountability as fatal weaknesses.
China experts say Beijing is so averse to the Western democratic model and the threat it poses to its legitimacy that it is actively trying to redefine democracy on its terms, at the United Nations and in other international forums.

...
After the Defense Department expanded its watch list, Beijing retaliated with its own restrictions on 10 U.S. private firms with active defense contracts. The American companies, which have no recourse under the Chinese legal system, will remain blacklisted until Beijing says otherwise.
One day, they, along with other wrongfully detained Americans, may be traded for U.S. concessions, like Canadians Michael Kovrig and Michael Spavor were in 2021 for Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou.
The pair had been detained in Beijing in December 2018 on charges of spying—seen as political retaliation for the arrest of Meng in Vancouver.
Those of a realist persuasion have long known this imbalance to be true.
No Reciprocity
Many have seen the irony of fighting an era-defining superpower rivalry without reciprocity. And in the race to lead in emerging technologies, the asymmetry could be the difference between winning and losing. The White House has backed claims by the American AI company Anthropic that Chinese startup Moonshot built AI’s Kimi K3 using stolen intellectual property from its Fable model.
Anthropic paid a $1.5 billion settlement over claims it used pirated books to train its Claude AI chatbot, yet remains largely helpless against Moonshot’s alleged tactics.
“Anthropic was sued in an American court and paid the largest copyright settlement in history. There is no forum in which Moonshot will pay anything for its successful extraction and replication of Anthropic’s trade secrets,” Ryan Fedasiuk, a former member of the U.S. State Department’s China policy team now at the American Enterprise Institute, wrote for War on the Rocks, a U.S.-based national security and foreign policy analysis outlet.
“Reconciling this asymmetry is an important part of what the administration should address,” Fedasiuk said.
Even in seemingly cut-and-dried cases like the 2023 arrest of U.S. citizen Lu Jianwang, for running an undisclosed Chinese police station in Manhattan’s Chinatown—of which he was found guilty in May—legal proceedings can take years.
But to protect the rights of every defendant, court documents and transcripts are made available to the public, and the decision ultimately rests with a jury of a dozen civilians. Lu also has the right to appeal.
Trump may be critical of every domestic intervention against his agenda, but there’s little he can do about America’s greatest unfixable weakness—a system built to preserve the postwar rules-based order in general and the “American way” in particular.
There is perhaps no other way to fight the authoritarian powers the U.S. doesn’t wish to become.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines