
...

By Katherine Fung
Senior Writer
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Justice Samuel Alito said the Supreme Court had dealt a "crippling wound" to modern-day law procedures in a new ruling on a Sixth Amendment case.
The court issued an unanimous ruling in Smith v. Arizona on Friday, overturning an appellate court decision that affirmed Jason Smith's guilty verdict and limiting the admissibility of expert statements made outside of the court.
The court remanded the case for further hearings.
Read More
Mark Cuban’s Post Critical of Republican Party Takes Off Online4 min read

Christian Pastor Arrested on Child Porn Charges in Florida3 min read

Ex-RNC Chair Confronts Republican on Project 2025 Plan to Gut Government5 min read

Smith had been charged with multiple felonies related to drug possession after law enforcement executed a search warrant at his father's property. During the trial, a forensic scientist testified that the substances seized were illegal drugs. Smith argued the testimony violated his confrontation rights because the expert relied on data from an expert who did not take the stand.
"Our holding today follows from all this Court has held about the Confrontation Clause's application to forensic evidence," Justice Elena Kagan wrote for the opinion. "A State may not introduce the testimonial out-of-court statements of a forensic analyst at trial, unless she is unavailable and the defendant has had a prior chance to cross-examine her."
"Today, the Court inflicts a needless, unwarranted, and crippling wound on modern evidence law," Alito wrote in a concurring opinion.
Joined by Chief Justice John Roberts, Alito said the court's ruling in Smith suggested that prosecution witnesses "revert to the form that was buried a half-century ago."
"There is no good reason for this radical change," he wrote.

...
Alito explained that historically, expert witnesses had to give their opinions in response to hypothetical questions—a confusing requirement that many in the legal community urged courts to abandon, which they later did in favor of more straightforward procedures.
After the practice was changed, modern rules allowed experts to testify on facts or data that they had been made aware of or personally observed without testifying to the underlying facts or data.
"This modern system is more honest because it reflects how experts actually form opinions," Alito wrote. "It is simpler and less likely to confuse. And it avoids many of the pitfalls of the old procedure. It may not be perfect—and evidence scholars have proposed a variety of reforms—but it is unquestionably better than the old regime it replaced."
He said the court's opinion suggests that all testimony is offered for its truth, which he said "is just plain wrong."
"The Court's assault on modern evidence law is not only wrongheaded; it is totally unnecessary," Alito said. "Today's decision vacates the Arizona court's judgment because the testifying expert's testimony was hearsay.
"I agree with that bottom line, but not because of the majority's novel theory that basis testimony is always hearsay. Rather, I would vacate and remand because the expert's testimony is hearsay under any mainstream conception, including that of the Federal Rules of Evidence."
"For more than a half-century, the Federal Rules of Evidence and similar state rules have reasonably allowed experts to disclose the information underlying their opinion. Because the Court places this form of testimony in constitutional doubt in many cases, I concur only in the judgment," Alito concluded.
Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch also delivered concurring opinions.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines