
...

By Sean O'Driscoll
Senior Crime and Courts Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A U.S. Supreme Court justice has demanded to know why former President Donald Trump should have immunity from prosecution if Richard Nixon did not have the same privilege for the Watergate scandal.
"What was up with the pardon for President Nixon? I think that, if everybody thought that presidents couldn't be prosecuted, then what was that about?" Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson pointedly asked Trump's lawyer D. John Sauer.
The exchange occurred during oral arguments on Thursday in Trump's Supreme Court challenge to his indictment in Washington, D.C., for alleged interference in the 2020 presidential election. Trump says that he has presidential immunity from the indictment. Newsweek sought email comment on Thursday from Trump's attorney.
Read More
Donald Trump Lawyer Makes Surprising Admission to Amy Coney Barrett4 min read

Supreme Court May Create New Immunity Test for Donald Trump Case3 min read

Why the Supreme Court Can’t Solve All of Donald Trump’s Legal Problems3 min read

Brown Jackson's question pointed to the skeptical nature of the questions directed at Sauer's claim that Trump had immunity for all official acts in office.
Nixon resigned as president as a result of the Watergate hotel burglary scandal, in which Republican operatives broke into the Democratic Party headquarters to gain information. His successor as president, Gerald Ford, pardoned Nixon.

...
Sauer replied: "He [Nixon] was under investigation for both his private and public conduct at the time... I think everyone has understood that the president, since President [Ulysses S.] Grant's carriage-riding incident, everyone has understood that the president could be prosecuted for private conduct." President Grant was arrested in 1872 for speeding in his horse-drawn carriage.
Trump was indicted on four counts of allegedly working to overturn the results of the 2020 election in the run-up to the January 6, 2021 riot at the U.S. Capitol. The case has been frozen while the Supreme Court considered the presidential immunity issue.
It is one of four criminal cases that Trump is facing as the presumptive Republican presidential nominee. He has also pleaded not guilty to charges in the other cases, denying any wrongdoing, and has repeatedly said that they form part of a political witch hunt.
In his opening statements, Sauer said that, if the court did not grant Trump immunity, then "there can be no presidency as we know it."
"The implications of the court's decision here extend far beyond the facts of this case," he added.
Sauer also said a lack of immunity would be "incompatible with our constitutional structure" and that America relies on an "energetic" presidency that is not tampered by fear of prosecution.
Brown Jackson later said to Sauer that the ability to prosecute a president, rather than placing a "chill" on the presidency, is a protection from a corrupt one. She added that a U.S. president has more power than anyone in the world, so there must be measures in place to ensure that the office is not used improperly.
Justice Elena Kagan asked Sauer if he felt a military coup by a president should have immunity from prosecution.
"How about if a president orders the military to stage a coup?" Kagan asked.
"If it's an official act, there needs to be impeachment and conviction beforehand through Congress," Sauer replied.
Kagan then asked if the coup would be considered an "official act" of the presidency.
"On the way you described that hypothetical, it could well be," Sauer said.
"That sure sounds bad, doesn't it?" Kagan replied.
Update 4/25/24, 11:25 a.m. ET: This article was updated to include additional reporting on the Supreme Court hearing.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines