
...
![]()
By Darlin Tillery
Life & Trends Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
An employee sending what they described as a courtesy reminder about jury duty, only to be asked whether they had found coverage and what time they could still come in, has caused uproar online.
Reddit user Amazing_Decision3694 shared this week that they had received a jury summons just before a planned week off and told their manager they had been scheduled as the opener.
The original poster (OP) pointed out to fellow Redditors that they would still be paid by their employer during jury duty and said the reminder text was more than they were required to provide.
Read More on Life
In the posted screenshot, the manager replied: “Did you ever find coverage,” then added, “I tried but no luck with short notice.”
The manager later asked, “What time is your jury duty," then said, “I have a morning person, but I’ll need a closer.”
Reddit critics did not mince words with their 1,200 comments in one day.

...
A typical response declared that, “Employers are required BY LAW to accommodate jury duty, no questions, no exceptions. This guy’s a moron.”
Another pundit noted that, “Part of the role of being a manger is to be the responsible party. If you can’t get your staff to cover, you cover.”
Court in the Act
Although no state was mentioned, legal backdrop is clear in guidance from the United States District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina, which makes clear: “No employer shall discharge, threaten to discharge, intimidate, or coerce any permanent employee by reason of such employee’s jury service, or the attendance or scheduled attendance in connection with such service, in any court of the United States...”
According to the court, people summoned for service must report unless they are deferred or excused. Any worker who faces pressure from an employer, “should patiently listen to the employer and then contact the jury clerk or other court officer immediately.”
The court also states that work concerns usually do not qualify someone for a delay in service.
“Please be aware that work is usually considered a hardship for everyone and that only extenuating circumstances will be considered with regard to work-related issues,” the court says.
That leaves staffing problems with the employer, not the summoned worker.
In guidance published by ADP, the company states, “Under federal and many state laws, providing time off for jury duty is required.”
ADP also says, “Employers are prohibited from disciplining or otherwise retaliating against employees who serve on a jury. At the end of their jury service, employees must be reinstated to their position.”
Pay rules vary. The Reddit poster said their employer continues paying them during jury duty, which is more generous than federal law requires in many cases.
The North Carolina federal court states, “There is no federal statute requiring employers to pay jurors their regular salary or wage while they are performing jury duty.”
ADP notes that, “Some states require employers to pay employees for jury service,” while many businesses choose to do so on their own.
Back on the Reddit case, the worker made clear they did not plan to solve the coverage issue, or report later in the day.
Based on the court’s own guidance and the reactions from commentators, many readers saw the exchange less as a scheduling mix-up and more as a manager trying to hand off a legal obligation that was never the employee’s to fix.
Newsweek has reached out to Amazing_Decision3694 for comment via Reddit. We could not verify the details of the case.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines