Brothers

...

Thomas Westerholm

By Thomas Westerholm

Life & Trends Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A sibling is defending themselves online for refusing to give their younger brother a ride to work and causing a rift in their family.

The 28-year-old original poster (OP) explained that four months ago, their car died on the way to work, leaving them stranded with no immediate tow options.

The OP called their 24-year-old brother, knowing his schedule was open that morning.

Read More on News

'Whole thing stuck with me'

"He paused for a second, then said something like, 'Yeah, I'm not really feeling like driving right now.' That was it," the OP told Redditors.

A friend eventually drove out of their way to help. However, the OP arrived more than an hour late to work and received a write-up.

"I didn't make a big deal out of it at the time, but the whole thing stuck with me," they said.

"My brother could have helped and just chose not to, for no real reason."

Brothers

...

The Tables Turned

Now, with the brother's car in the shop for a week, he has been calling each morning asking for rides to work.

The OP declined, reminding him of what he said months earlier.

"If he wasn't in the mood to help me back then, I'm not in the mood to help him now. Simple as that," they wrote.

According to the OP, the brother is upset and feels they are being petty. The siblings' mother has sided with the younger brother, telling the OP they were "punishing" instead of setting an example.

"According to her, being the older sibling means taking the high road, even when it's not fair," the OP wrote.

"I told her that I'm tired of being the one who's expected to be generous while he gets to act like a child and face no consequences.

"So now it's a whole family thing. My brother's sulking, my mom is disappointed, and I'm stuck wondering if maybe I did go too far."

'Unresolved issues'

Dr. Karen Gail Lewis is a relationship therapist who specializes in family and sibling conflicts. Lewis told Newsweek that these types of conflicts are typically related to unresolved issues from early childhood.

"Most of the responses were complaining about mother's involvement and her support of the younger child," Lewis said.

"In fact, favoritism in those early years has the potential to do exact this in adulthood. As a child, it's 'safer' to be angry at the sibling than at the parent. The feelings, then, go underground (even if the siblings are close) showing up later in adulthood."

Lewis added that she never blames the parents—"I assume they do the best they know how"—but parental behavior is the underlying theme running through much of sibling conflict.

"If parents tell the oldest child he/she should let the younger one have toy/win game, go with them when with friends, it's understandable the older child will feel resentment," Lewis said.

The same can be true, Lewis said, if the younger sibling has mental or physical health issues that require lots of time or attention.

"If these feelings, in childhood, are not expressed and heard by parents, they go underground even if siblings are friendly as adults, and they can erupt over anything that stirs up the old feelings," Lewis said.

"As a sibling therapist, my biggest concern, actually, is that the trainings for therapists do not include any of this."

Family Conflict and Consequences

Family conflicts can indeed get messy, as Newsweek has reported.

In January, a poster on Reddit shared that after their father died, his siblings insisted that the OP wasn't his biological child and should "gift" them the money instead.

Another Reddit user shared that they upset their family by refusing to attend Thanksgiving. The OP said her parents have a long history of favoring her brother and she didn't want to subject her own children to a "toxic" Thanksgiving dinner.

While the OP has deleted their account, the general mood on the Reddit thread was summed up by one user: "[Your brother] let you down when you needed him because he didn't 'feel like it.' How is he supposed to expect anything different?

"Mom needs to keep out of it. He's an adult and adult decisions have adult consequences."

Newsweek's "What Should I Do?" offers expert advice to readers. If you have a personal dilemma, let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice on relationships, family, friends, money and work, and your story could be featured on WSID at Newsweek.

To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, click here.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines