Donald Trump

...

Adeola Adeosun

By Adeola Adeosun

Weekend Night Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


President-elect Donald Trump vowed on Sunday to end birthright citizenship through executive action. However, legal experts say the plan faces a formidable obstacle—a U.S. Supreme Court precedent for more than 120 years.

In Sunday's interview on NBC News' Meet the Press with host Kristen Welker, Trump outlined drastic sweeping changes to immigration policy, including plans for mass deportations and ending automatic citizenship for children born to undocumented immigrants in the United States.

"We're going to end that because it's ridiculous," Trump said. When pressed by Welker about using executive action to do it, the president-elect responded: "Well, if we can, through executive action."

Read More

CNN Host Confronts Democrat on Joe Biden’s Hunter Pardon: ‘Any Concerns?’5 min read

CNN Host Confronts Democrat on Joe Biden’s Hunter Pardon: ‘Any Concerns?’

John Bolton Suggests Syria May Have ‘Interesting’ Files on Tulsi Gabbard5 min read

John Bolton Suggests Syria May Have ‘Interesting’ Files on Tulsi Gabbard

Tulsi Gabbard Trolled by Critics After Assad’s Regime Collapses in Syria5 min read

Tulsi Gabbard Trolled by Critics After Assad’s Regime Collapses in Syria

Trump also incorrectly said that the U.S. is the only country that has birthright citizenship. "Do you know we're the only country in the world that has it?" Trump repeatedly emphasized to Welker. However, according to the Library of Congress, more than 30 nations, including Canada and Brazil, provide similar constitutional protections.

Newsweek has contacted the Trump-Vance transition team via email on Sunday for comment.

The constitutional right to citizenship for anyone born on U.S. soil stems from the 14th Amendment and was affirmed by the Court in the landmark 1898 case United States v. Wong Kim Ark. The Court ruled that a man born in San Francisco to Chinese parents was entitled to citizenship, establishing a precedent that has guided immigration law ever since.

When Welker asked Trump about inevitable legal challenges, he pivoted to discussing the current immigration system and said, "We're into litigation that lasts for years. Costs us hundreds of billions of dollars.'"

In an interview last month with San Francisco radio station KQED, University of California, Berkeley law professor Leti Volpp emphasized this precedent's durability and said, "We have a legal system which is based on precedent. In the case of Wong Kim Ark...there has been no chipping away at precedent through other decisions."

Trump detailed his timeline in a May 2023 campaign video: "On Day One of my new term in office, I will sign an executive order making clear to federal agencies that under the correct interpretation of the law, going forward, the future children of illegal immigrants will not receive automatic U.S. citizenship."

Beyond citizenship changes, Trump told Welker on Sunday that he would begin deportations with undocumented immigrants who have committed crimes before expanding to what he called "others" outside the criminal population.

"I think you have to do it," Trump said. "It's a very tough thing to do...but you have rules, regulations, laws. They came in illegally."

Donald Trump

...

His approach to mixed-status families represents a significant policy shift. "I don't want to be breaking up families," Trump told Welker. "So, the only way you don't break up the family is you keep them together and you have to send them all back." This could affect an estimated 4 million families where some members are U.S. citizens while others are undocumented.

Tom Homan, Trump's pick for border czar, defended this approach on CBS News' 60 Minutes with Cecilia Vega in October. When asked if mass deportation could avoid family separation, Homan responded: "Of course there is. Families can be deported together."

Pressed on why American citizen children should have to leave, Homan added: "Because their parent absolutely entered the country illegally, had a child knowing he was in the country illegally. So, he created that crisis."

The debate has drawn nuanced positions from Trump-aligned officials. Trump-appointed judge James C. Ho, mentioned as a potential Supreme Court nominee, told Reason magazine on November 11 that while he supports birthright citizenship for ordinary immigrants, it shouldn't apply to what he terms "invading aliens" or potential terrorists.

However, Volpp told KQED she was "skeptical that courts would agree that immigrants can somehow be characterized as an 'invading army,'" noting that immigrants "are not immune from prosecution" if they commit crimes in the U.S.

Senator Lindsey Graham, a South Carolina Republican and Trump ally, announced on X, formerly Twitter, on Sunday that he is working on both legislation and a constitutional amendment to end birthright citizenship, saying the current policy and birth tourism from countries like China have become "one of the biggest magnets for illegal immigration."

Constitutional scholars emphasize that while future presidents can reverse executive orders, amending the Constitution requires extraordinary consensus. Article V demands a two-thirds majority in congressional chambers, plus ratification by 38 state legislatures.

No amendment in U.S. history has been ratified through the alternative method of a constitutional convention called by two-thirds of states.

Despite his hardline stance, Trump expressed openness on Sunday to working with Democrats to protect "Dreamers"—undocumented immigrants brought to the U.S. as children—from deportation.

"I will work with the Democrats on a plan. And if we can come up with a plan, but the Democrats have made it very, very difficult to do anything. Republicans are very open to the dreamers. The dreamers, we're talking many years ago, they were brought into this country," Trump told Welker. "Many years ago. Some of them are no longer young people. And in many cases, they've become successful. They have great jobs. In some cases, they have small businesses. Some cases they might have large businesses. And we're going to have to do something with them."

Welker asked, "You want them to be able to stay. That's what you're saying?"

Trump replied, "I do. I want to be able to work something out."

Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) recipients must have entered the United States before turning 16, lived in the country continuously since June 15, 2007, completed high school or obtained a GED, and have no prior convictions. As of March 2023, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services said there were approximately 578,000 active DACA recipients.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines