

By Khaleda Rahman
National Correspondent
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Justice Clarence Thomas is now the second-longest serving justice in the U.S. Supreme Court’s history, a major milestone that puts him within striking distance of another record that has stood for more than half a century.
Thomas, 77, has served on the court since October 1991. If he remains on the court until May 20, 2028, he will overtake the late Justice William O. Douglas, whose 36 years and 209 days on the bench remains the longest tenure in U.S. history.
That timeline would place any decision about Thomas’ future squarely in a presidential election year, when Supreme Court vacancies have repeatedly carried significant political consequences.
Read More on News
Thomas has not indicated when he plans to retire, and justices are under no obligation to time their departures around electoral cycles. But recent history has underscored how much the calendar can shape the outcome of a vacancy.

...
The Record Clarence Thomas Is Closing In On
The record set by Douglas, who served on the court from 1939 to 1975, has stood for more than 50 years, in part because of how young he was when he was appointed, Linda Greenhouse, a senior research scholar at Yale Law School and an expert on the Supreme Court, told Newsweek.
At 40, he was one of the youngest justices ever confirmed to the court. “And of course he stayed too long, refusing to retire after a cognitively disabling stroke,” Greenhouse said.
As Time reported in 1975, Douglas had not wanted to retire while a Republican president was in office, writing to a friend that he “won’t resign while there’s a breath in my body —until we get a Democratic President.”
Thomas was also appointed to the bench at a similar age. He was just 43 when Republican President George H.W. Bush nominated him to replace Thurgood Marshall—who had been appointed by Democrat Lyndon B. Johnson.
Marshall’s retirement was the last time a Supreme Court justice stepped down when a vacancy was likely to result in the appointment of a justice with an opposing ideology, and the liberal justice was replaced by the staunchly conservative Thomas, according to the Brennan Center for Justice.
Why the Timing of a Supreme Court Retirement Matters
While Thomas surpassing Douglas’ record would be a merely symbolic feat, it is the political timing of a justice's retirement that has taken on increasing importance in recent decades.
Speculation about the prospect of Thomas, the oldest sitting justice, or Justice Samuel Alito, who is 76, stepping down from their lifetime posts has swirled in recent months, with some calling for the justices to retire now to avoid the potential consequences of Democrats flipping the Senate in November’s midterm elections or a Democrat winning the White House in 2028.
Neither Thomas nor Alito have publicly spoken about plans to retire and they do not have any serious health concerns that have been made public, though Alito was hospitalized and treated for dehydration in March.
Why Election-Year Vacancies Are So Politically Fraught
Recent years have shown how consequential a Supreme Court vacancy arising during a presidential election year can be.
“An election-year retirement obviously heightens the political stakes and has the possibility of motivating the base of the party that holds the White House,” Greenhouse said.
After the death of Justice Antonin Scalia, the influential conservative, at the age of 79 in February 2016, Senate Republicans, who controlled the chamber, declined to move forward with Democratic President Barack Obama’s nominee, Merrick Garland, saying justices should not be nominated during an election year.
But four years later, after the death of liberal Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Senate Republicans moved swiftly to confirm Trump’s nominee, Amy Coney Barrett, to the court just weeks before voters headed to the polls—even though Ginsburg had reportedly wished not to be replaced until after the election. Her decision not to retire during Obama’s tenure was viewed by many liberals as a grave error, since it allowed Trump to cement the court’s current conservative supermajority. The court has since given conservatives significant victories, including ending the constitutional right to abortion and in April this year it issued a decision that weakened the Voting Rights Act and could aid Republican efforts to keep control of the House.
Together, the episodes illustrate the importance of the timing of a vacancy and how the confirmation process can be unpredictable and ultimately outside the departing justice’s control.
Could Trump Appoint a Fourth Supreme Court Justice?
Either of the justices retiring this summer would give President Donald Trump the chance to appoint a fourth justice to the court, after appointing three during his first term.
Trump could name a successor that will be confirmed by the Republican-controlled Senate and ensure the seat remains in conservative hands, Erwin Chemerinsky, a constitutional law scholar and the dean of the University of California Berkeley School of Law, told Newsweek.
Trump replacing either justice with another conservative would not change the court’s current 6-3 conservative majority, but it would allow for a younger justice to be put on the court who could serve for decades.
That replacement “will surely be a very conservative individual in his or her 40s or 50s,” Chemerinsky said. “It will keep this seat in conservative hands for decades.”
What Happens if Clarence Thomas Retires?
If Thomas were to retire, the process for filling his seat would follow the Constitution’s standard framework: the sitting president would nominate a successor, and the Senate would decide whether to confirm that nominee.
A retirement during a period of unified Republican control would allow President Donald Trump to nominate a replacement who could be confirmed with a simple majority vote, preserving the Court’s current conservative balance. While replacing Thomas with another conservative justice would not change the Court’s 6–3 ideological split, it would likely result in a significantly younger justice who could serve for decades.
If a vacancy were to arise when control of the Senate is divided—or during a presidential election year—the path to confirmation could become far less certain. Senate leaders could delay or decline to act on a nomination altogether, citing precedent from previous election-year standoffs.
Because Supreme Court justices serve lifetime appointments, the consequences of a single retirement can extend well beyond a single presidency, making the timing of any departure a central political calculation.
How the Midterms Could Decide the Court’s Future
This year’s midterm elections could prove consequential, with a shift in control of the Senate possibly reshaping the confirmation process for any nominee.
If Democrats win the Senate in November’s midterms**—and they currently hold a narrow edge in forecasts—**Chemerinsky argued they will decline to confirm any of Trump’s nominees to fill a vacancy created by a retirement or death of a sitting justice in 2028, pointing to the precedent set in 2016.
“The Democrats are sure to follow the precedent of the Republicans blocking consideration of Merrick Garland in 2016,” he said.
Greenehouse noted that if Democrats take back the Senate, they could also restore the filibuster for Supreme Court nominations and further complicate the path to confirmation for a nominee.
Then Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell had gutted the filibuster for Supreme Court nominees in 2017, which enabled the Senate to easily confirm Justice Neil Gorsuch, the first of three justices that Trump nominated to the court with simple majority votes.
“None of Trump's three nominees would have survived a filibuster,” Greenhouse said. “And obviously a Democratic Senate could probably muster the votes necessary to flat-out defeat a Trump nominee.”
Chemerinsky describes Thomas as “the most radically conservative justice to serve on the Supreme Court in modern times,” noting he has taken positions that “would dramatically change the law” including calling for the overturning of landmark decisions that protect same-sex intimacy, access to contraception and legalized gay marriage.
Like all justices, Thomas holds a lifetime appointment on the Supreme Court, designed to ensure judicial independence and insulate judges from political pressure as well as determine the length of their service.
At 77, Thomas is older than the average sitting Supreme Court justice. By 2028, he will be closer to 80, the average age of retirement for Supreme Court justices since 2000.
As Thomas edges closer to Douglas’ mark, the question may be less whether he can break the record than whether the political calendar will allow it.
Update, 05/07/26, 9:05 a.m. ET: This article was updated with additional information.
In a polarized era, the center is dismissed as bland. At Newsweek, ours is different: The Courageous Center—it's not "both sides," it's sharp, challenging and alive with ideas. We follow facts, not factions. If that sounds like the kind of journalism you want to see thrive, we need you.
When you become a Newsweek Member, you support a mission to keep the center strong and vibrant. Members enjoy: Ad-free browsing, exclusive content and editor conversations. Help keep the center courageous. Join today.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines

