SCOTUS gay marriage

...

Rachel Dobkin

By Rachel Dobkin

Weekend Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Liberal-leaning Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor argued that the Court countered a landmark gay marriage ruling, Obergefell v. Hodges, in a recent case, Department of State v. Muñoz, warning that it could have negative implications for same-sex couples.

In a 6-3 decision on Friday, the Court ruled against Sandra Muñoz, an American citizen who challenged a consular officer's decision to bar her foreign husband Luis Asencio-Cordero from entering the United States to live with her.

The U.S. consulate in San Salvador denied Asencio-Cordero's visa application because he was found to be affiliated with the gang MS-13. The consular officer, however, did not disclose his reasoning for denying Asencio-Cordero's application. Since Asencio-Cordero is not a U.S. citizen and therefore has no constitutional right to enter the country, he can't elicit the consular officer's reasoning or challenge the denial of his application.

Read More

Russian Lawmaker Offers Donald Trump Advice3 min read

Russian Lawmaker Offers Donald Trump Advice

Trump-Endorsed Trent Staggs Chances of Beating GOP Rivals in Utah: Polls4 min read

Trump-Endorsed Trent Staggs Chances of Beating GOP Rivals in Utah: Polls

Ronny Jackson’s Demand of Joe Biden Raises Eyebrows6 min read

Ronny Jackson’s Demand of Joe Biden Raises Eyebrows

Since Muñoz is a citizen, she challenged the consular officer's decision with the following reasoning: "The right to live with her noncitizen spouse in the United States is implicit in the 'liberty' protected by the Fifth Amendment; the denial of her husband's visa deprived her of this interest, thereby triggering her right to due process; the consular officer violated her right to due process by declining to disclose the basis for finding Asencio-Cordero inadmissible; and this, in turn, enables judicial review, even though visa denials are ordinarily unreviewable by courts," Justice Amy Coney Barrett, a conservative-learning judge, explained in the majority opinion in the case.

The Fifth Amendment states that no person shall be "deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law."

However, Barrett wrote in the majority opinion, which was joined by the five other conservative-learning justices on the Court, that Muñoz's "argument is built on the premise that the right to bring her noncitizen spouse to the United States is an unenumerated constitutional right. To establish this premise, she must show that the asserted right is 'deeply rooted in this Nation's history and tradition,'" citing the 1997 case Washington v. Glucksberg.

Barrett added: "She cannot make that showing. In fact, Congress's longstanding regulation of spousal immigration—including through bars on admissibility—cuts the other way."

Sotomayor, along with the two other liberal-leaning justice on the Court—Justices Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson—dissented to the majority opinion.

SCOTUS gay marriage

...

In her dissenting opinion, Sotomayor cited the landmark 2015 case Obergefell v. Hodges, which granted all U.S. citizens the right to same sex marriage: "The right to marry is fundamental as a matter of history and tradition."

Late on in her dissenting opinion, Sotomayor brought up Obergefell v. Hodges again, writing, "Obergefell rejected what the majority does today as 'inconsistent with the approach this Court has used in discussing [the] fundamental rights' of 'marriage and intimacy.'"

She said that "Muñoz may be able to live with her husband in El Salvador, but it will mean raising her U. S.-citizen child outside the United States. Others will be less fortunate," warning, "The burden will fall most heavily on same-sex couples and others who lack the ability, for legal or financial reasons, to make a home in the noncitizen spouse's country of origin."

Sotomayor argued that the Court could have "resolved this case on narrow grounds
under longstanding precedent."

"This Court has already recognized that excluding a noncitizen from the country can burden the constitutional rights of citizens who seek his presence," Sotomayor wrote, citing the 1972 case Kleindienst v. Mandel. "Acknowledging the Government's power over admission and exclusion, the Mandel Court held that 'a facially legitimate and bona fide reason' for the exclusion sufficed to justify that burden."

Sotomayor said that the consular officer's belief that Asencio-Cordero had connections to MS-13, "regardless of the validity of that belief...is a 'facially legitimate and bona fide reason.'"

"Instead, the majority today chooses a broad holding on marriage over a narrow one on procedure. It holds that Muñoz's right to marry, live with, and raise children alongside her husband entitles her to nothing when the Government excludes him from the country," the justice wrote.

Sotomayor added: "Because, to me, there is no question that excluding a citizen's
spouse burdens her right to marriage, and that burden requires the Government to provide at least a factual basis for its decision, I respectfully dissent."

Newsweek has reached out to the Supreme Court via online form for comment.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines