10
Loading video...


By Dan Gooding and Gabe Whisnant
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Chief Justice John Roberts has hit pause on an order demanding the Trump administration bring back by midnight Monday a Salvadoran immigrant accidentally deported.
In an emergency appeal, the Justice Department had argued that U.S. District Judge Paula Xinis exceeded her authority when she directed the government to bring Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia back to the United States from the CECOT prison, an acronym for Terrorism Confinement Centre in Spanish.
The appeal came as the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against the Trump administration Monday morning, ruling it still has to move to bring Abrego Garcia home by 11:59 p.m. ET.
Read More on U.S.
"There is no question that the government screwed up here," U.S. Appeals Court Judge James Harvie Wilkinson III, in his motion.
On Monday afternoon, Roberts lifted the order, saying parties had until 5 p.m. ET Tuesday to submit further responses on why it should be implemented or not.

...
Why It Matters
Abrego Garcia's case is the latest in a string of challenges against President Donald Trump's immigration policies and moves since January 20. The administration argues that it no longer has jurisdiction over him, but other wrongly-deported individuals have been returned to the U.S. in the past.
Also on Monday, a divided Supreme Court allowed President Trump to resume using a wartime-era law to deport alleged, marking a significant win for the administration in a closely watched battle over presidential authority.
In a 5-4 decision, the court granted Trump's emergency request and overturned a lower court ruling that had temporarily halted deportations under the Alien Enemies Act while legal challenges proceeded. The majority emphasized that detainees must still be given an "opportunity" to present their case before a judge prior to removal.
What To Know
Although the administration acknowledged that Abrego Garcia should not have been deported—citing an immigration judge's finding that he likely faced persecution by local gangs—it claimed he is no longer in U.S. custody and cannot be retrieved.
Judge Xinis had given the government until just before midnight Monday to "facilitate and effectuate" his return, saying in a ruling Sunday that the government "forcibly put him in a facility that intentionally mixes rival gang members without any regard for protecting the detainees from 'harm at the hands of the gangs.'"
The Trump administration then asked the Fourth Circuit to intervene and issue a stay. Before it could issue its ruling, the Department of Justice (DOJ) took the case a step further and filed its appeal to the Supreme Court.
"The United States cannot guarantee success in sensitive international negotiations in advance, least of all when a court imposes an absurdly compressed, mandatory deadline that vastly complicates the give-and-take of foreign-relations negotiations," the appeal read.

...
In its appeal, the government again repeated the allegation that Abrego Garcia is a member of MS-13, a criminal gang that began in Los Angeles but has roots in El Salvador. The administration has more recently claimed he is a human trafficker, which did not appear in original court documents from 2019.
Abrego Garcia's attorneys argue the government has not provided any real evidence to back up the claim. No criminal records were found in Maryland for him.
The 29-year-old father, who has lived in Maryland since arriving in the U.S. in around 2011, was arrested by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) on March 12, and was then placed on one of the flights to El Salvador's CECOT prison on March 15, following what an ICE official called an "administrative error."
Despite this admission, the government has stuck to its stance that he should have been deported. Its attorney, who argued the case in front of Judge Xinis on Friday, has reportedly been put on leave, per The New York Times.
With around eight hours to go before Xinis' deadline, Justice Roberts said he was issuing a stay on Friday's original deadline, "pending further order of the undersigned or the court."
What People Are Saying
U.S. Appeals Court Judge Stephanie Dawn Thacker, in her ruling: "We
deal here with what I hope is the extraordinary circumstance of the government conceding that it made an error in deporting the plaintiff to a foreign country for which he was not eligible for removal. In this situation, I think it legitimate for the district court to require that the government "facilitate" the plaintiff's return to the United States so that he may assert the rights that all apparently agree are due him under law."
Lucia Curiel, an immigration attorney who represented Abrego Garcia in his 2019 immigration court case, in a press release Friday: "The court's order confirms what we've said all along, Kilmar should never have been deported. He had legal protection, and ICE violated it. The judge's decision sends a strong message, but it is only meaningful if the government follows through. ICE violated Kilmar's rights once. Failing to comply now would only deepen that injustice and raise serious constitutional concerns,"
Tricia McLaughlin Assistant Secretary at the Department of Homeland Security on Fox News Sunday: "The bottom line is whether this MS-13 gang member is locked up in a U.S. detention facility, or El Salvador, he is off of American streets and that's what really matters. He's not only a MS-13 gang member, he's also a human trafficker.
"The fact that the mainstream media is framing him as a Maryland father and this darling of the media is really disgusting and disturbing."
What's Next
The Monday afternoon decision puts Abrego Garcia's return to the U.S. in doubt, at least for another day.
Reporting by The Associated Press contributed to this story.
Update: 4/7/25, 4:12 p.m. ET: This headline and article have been updated with additional information following Justice John Roberts' ruling.
Update: 4/7/25, 7:38 p.m. ET: This article has been updated with additional information.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines