10

Loading video...

Ewan Palmer

By Ewan Palmer

News Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


An appeals court has rejected an attempt to have Donald Trump removed from the 2024 presidential ballot in New Hampshire over claims his actions on January 6 amounted to an insurrection.

The United States Court of Appeals For the First Circuit has upheld a decision from a lower court which rejected longshot Republican presidential hopeful John Anthony Castro's lawsuit in New Hampshire.

The suit argued that Trump violated section 3 of the 14th Amendment, which says that a person who "engaged in insurrection or rebellion" after taking an oath of office to support the Constitution should be barred from running for office again.

Read More

Donald Trump Being Kicked off 2024 Ballot Looks More Likely5 min read

Donald Trump Being Kicked off 2024 Ballot Looks More Likely

Donald Trump’s Court Appeal Could Backfire Spectacularly4 min read

Donald Trump’s Court Appeal Could Backfire Spectacularly

Donald Trump Demands Details of Undercover Jan. 6 Plotters5 min read

Donald Trump Demands Details of Undercover Jan. 6 Plotters

A similar suit in Colorado, filed by the Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) watchdog group and Republican figures, will be heard by the state's supreme court after a lower court judge ruled that Trump had "engaged in insurrection" on January 6, but should remain on the state's primary ballot as the wording of the 14th Amendment means it cannot be applied for presidents.

Castro's lawsuit was dismissed by a federal judge in October, who rejected his argument that his suit is justified as he will be directly impacted if the "constitutionally ineligible" Trump is also on the 2024 ballots as it would affect his own White House ambitions.

Castro has filed several other lawsuits across the country arguing that Trump should be barred from running for office again over claims he violated his constitutional oath with his actions around the Capitol riot in January 2021.

Trump, the frontrunner in the GOP presidential primary, has denied all wrongdoing in connection to the January 6 attack, and has described attempts to prevent him running for office again by citing the 14th Amendment as a "trick" to prevent him winning the 2024 election.

Donald Trump in New Hampshire

...

Lawsuits in Florida, Minnesota and Michigan which also tried to disqualify Trump from running for president while citing the 14th Amendment have been thrown out by courts.

In its ruling, the New Hampshire court agreed with the previous ruling which said that Castro does not have a case to try have Trump disqualified from the state ballot as he made "no attempt to demonstrate" that he is actually competing with the former president for votes and contributions in the GOP primary race.

"Indeed, the record shows that, beyond taking steps to be placed on the ballot, Castro's efforts to compete for votes and contributors in the specific New Hampshire primary at issue were non-existent," the court wrote.

"And, consistent with that conclusion, we note that Castro's brief also cites to nothing in the record that undermines the district court's findings that Castro neither 'provided any evidence suggesting that he has voters or contributors in New Hampshire,' nor made any showing that 'he will benefit from voter or contributor defections from Trump to himself.'"

In response to the ruling, Castro told Newsweek the court had got the decision "shockingly wrong."

"The Supreme Court has already ruled that a candidate can sue before he's on a ballot (Golden v. Zwickler) and only needs to show the loss of a single vote (US v. SCRAP)," Castro said. "Instead, they applied their own outdated law and said I had to sue when I was already on the ballot, had to show I was already competing, and had to show a significant loss of votes; all of which the Supreme Court has already rejected."

After the Colorado appeals court agreed to hear arguments on removing Trump from the ballot in the Centennial State, Trump's spokesman Steven Cheung accused the judge of overstepping her role by claiming the former president had engaged in insurrection on January 6.

"The district judge rightly rejected the far-left's efforts to keep President Trump off the ballot, but she then went out of her way to wrongly criticize the president," Cheung said. "We've asked the Colorado Supreme Court to strike her wrong-headed speculation, because it goes far beyond her jurisdiction."

Update 11/23/23, 11:17 a.m. ET: This article has been updated with comment from John Anthony Castro.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines