...
By Darlin Tillery
Life & Trends Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A woman who recently started a new job says an offhand conversation about pay left her grappling with guilt and uncertainty after learning she earns $15,000 more than the colleague assigned to train her.
The situation was shared in a brief, since-removed post on Reddit by user prettyanniie, who described feeling uneasy as the coworker, employed at the company for three years, patiently helped her settle into the role.
The woman wrote that the realization came during a casual exchange about “market rates,” when it became clear her starting salary exceeded that of the more experienced employee.
Read More on Life
The original poster (OP) said the coworker had been supportive and generous with their time, making the pay gap feel harder to ignore. Her question was simple but loaded: should she say something, or would that put her own position at risk so early on.
Caution Urged
The post prompted 450 reactions from fellow Reddit contributors weighing the risks of transparency against workplace realities.
A supporter urged caution, pointing to legal differences by region.
“Depends on whether your location protects employees discussing pay or not. Some EU countries and most of Canada doesn't, every other first world country does," they continued.
"If you do have protection, tell them after your probation ends. If not, try and drop hints, but don't explicitly tell them that."
...
Another response was more direct, warning against any involvement at all.
“I would mind your own business and keep your relationship professional," a pundit noted, adding, "You absolutely shouldn't be telling them anything about your salary."
The dilemma touches on a long standing tension around salary transparency, particularly for new hires who fear being labeled as troublemakers.
Fear of Tension
According to The Muse, discussing pay in the United States is legally protected.
“Discussing and sharing salary information inside and outside work is legally protected by U.S. federal law under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA),” career coach Yolanda Owens said in an interview published by The Muse.
“Technically, employers can't formally or informally prohibit, discourage, or retaliate against workers for sharing or discussing their wages.”
Still, legality does not always translate into comfort or ease. The Muse also notes that many workers avoid these conversations due to fear of tension or judgment.
“It can lead to tension or resentment among coworkers, especially if disparities are revealed,” said human resources (HR) consultant Wendy Sellers, also known as The HR Lady, in comments published by The Muse.
“If someone discovers they are being paid less for the same work, it can create frustration.”
Guidance from other workplace experts suggests weighing context carefully.
Deskera, a business and HR platform, stresses that pay discussions can cut both ways.
“Is it appropriate to discuss pay at work? Yes. Even if your firm has a policy prohibiting it? Yes,” Deskera’s content team wrote, noting that such conversations are protected under U.S. labor law.
At the same time, the company cautions that sharing salary information, “has the potential to cause conflict with certain coworkers, as well as anger toward management,” according to Deskera.
A Workplace Crossroads
For the woman who shared her story, the responses did not deliver a clear answer, but they did reflect a common workplace crossroads.
With probation periods, power imbalances and personal ethics in play, many commentators suggested that timing and self protection matter as much as fairness.
Newsweek has reached out to prettyanniie for comment via Reddit. We could not verify the details of the case.
To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, click here.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines